Indiscipline's Roulette v. The Dirty Aftermath

[King Postwhore]

I'd reply but I'm too lazy.

[Indiscipline]

I'd reply but I'm too lazy.

King's compatibility index: 100% factoring in dynamism.

[The Walrus]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Zeppelin
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? A bullet
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? Uhhhh
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Uhhhh
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? EVH I guess
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Close but Mercury
Boston or Chicago? Chicago the band, the cities both suck
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? mulligan
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Root canal
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Smith
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Mustaine
The Clash or The Ramones? Nope
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Waits
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? I guess Bettencourt
Pantera or Soundgarden? Neither but Pantera by virtue of not having Cornell
Blur or Oasis? Uhhh
Radiohead or Muse? Radiohead I guess
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Who?

[King Postwhore]

I'd reply but I'm too lazy.

King's compatibility index: 100% factoring in dynamism.

100% in the brain.  Ass is 100% passive.

[Indiscipline]

King, make it 200% compatibility with me.

Katt's compatibility index: 20%, 25% if for "a bullet" you meant Lennon.

[Destiny Of Chaos]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? – Led Zeppelin!
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? – Ringo! (McCartney I guess)
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? – Zappa
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? – Anderson.
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? - Lake
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? – Randy Rhoads
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? – Mercury but both were/are fantastic
Boston or Chicago? - Boston
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Coverdale
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? – Def Leppard
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? -  Bruce (Smith) 
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? – James Hetfield YEAH-ah
The Clash or The Ramones? Hard pass on  both *flips coin* Clash
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? – The one I heard of (Petty)
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? -  Dickinson
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? - Gilbert
Pantera or Soundgarden? – Soundgarden, Cornell puts them over for me.
Blur or Oasis? – Oasis
Radiohead or Muse? – Muse
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? – Astaire
Coke or Pepsi – Coke
Portnoy or Mangini – Portnoy
Kevin Moore or Derek Sherdian – Jordan Rudess
Mac or PC – PC
Beach or mountains – Mountains
Being the world’s tallest midget or the world’s smallest regular sized person – Whatever Peter Dinklage is having
Vanilla or Chocolate – Chocolate 
Kingslamehed  or TAC – TAC
Slowly drifting into the void of eternal darkness or watching a Ben Stiller movie, on purpose – The former

[The Walrus]

  I'm gonna bomb!

[lonestar]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Zeppelin
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Lennon
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? Gabriel
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Anderson
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? Rhoads
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Mercury
Boston or Chicago? Boston
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Indifferent
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Don't Care
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Who?
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? No fucks are given here
The Clash or The Ramones? The Ramones
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Eh...
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Gilbert
Pantera or Soundgarden? Meh
Blur or Oasis? Nah
Radiohead or Muse? Neither
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Fred Astaire on the grounds that he's my kid's favorite.

[Indiscipline]

DoC's compatibility index: 60%, factoring in only the original questions/answers.

lonestar's compatibility: 20%, 55% factoring in attitude.

[ariich]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Deep Purple
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Both? But Lennon maybe by a smidgen.
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Both talented, but I'm only a moderate fan of either.
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel?  Gabriel, .
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Lake.
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? Rhoads.
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Mercury.
Boston or Chicago? I literally hadn't even heard of Chicago. So Boston by default I guess!
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Hughes, purely by virtue of liking some of the bands he's fronted.
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Def Leppard.
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Smith.
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Hetfield.
The Clash or The Ramones? Never been especially interested in either.
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Never been especially interested in either, though what I've heard from Tom Waits sounded pretty good. So him I guess.
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Dickinson.
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Can't say I know either well enough, though they're both very talented.
Pantera or Soundgarden? Weird comparison. Pantera, but I don't really know Soundgarden very well.
Blur or Oasis? Tough call. Probably Oasis slightly, but both are good.
Radiohead or Muse? Muse, but both are great.
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? No particular preference, both very talented.

[Indiscipline]

ariich's compatibility index: 45%


EDIT: missed a +5%

[Evermind]

Here I go with my extensive knowledge of fogey bands!

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Purple
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Lennon
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? Anderson
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? See above
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? EVH
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Freddie
Boston or Chicago? The band that wrote Hotel California
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Coverdale
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? The band that wrote Prisoners in Paradise
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Are those Maiden guys? I pick Bruce
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Hetfield I guess
The Clash or The Ramones? Never heard of either
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? I know at least one song by Tom Waits, so, Tom Waits
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Oh, here we go! I pick Bruce again
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Gilbert
Pantera or Soundgarden? Uh, the band that wrote Wanted Dead or Alive
Blur or Oasis? Oasis, I love Carry on Wayward Son
Radiohead or Muse? I'll pass, thanks
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? I hate stairs so Kelly I guess? Never heard of either

[Indiscipline]

Evermind's compatibility index: 35%, 70% if by "The band that wrote Hotel California" you meant Jethro Tull

[The Walrus]

Can't tell if half of Ev's answers are jokes or not. And I thought mine was bad with the fogeys. And he still has a higher compatibility than me! 

[Elite]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Zep
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Lennon
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix for the playing, Zappa for the weirdness
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? I honestly don’t care, but Ian Anderson was quite funny on stage
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Anderson yet again
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? Can’t be bothered again, but Eddie I guess
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Mercury, easily
Boston or Chicago? 25 or 6 to 4
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Who?
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Bon Jovi for the funny hits
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? The bassist
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Hetfield all the way
The Clash or The Ramones? British Punk > American Punk
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Waits
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce Dickinson
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Gilbert, although Bettencourt certainly has his moments.
Pantera or Soundgarden? The Great Southern Trendkill
Blur or Oasis? I can’t really stand Oasis, though I mist admit they have some cool song. I also loathe Song #2, do I can’t be bothered to choose any.
Radiohead or Muse? Radiohead, by miles
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? I don’t know any of their stuff


Monday is my free day. Saturday is mine

[Stadler]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin?  Led Zeppelin (but Ritchie Blackmore is my favorite musician ever)
John Lennon or Paul McCartney?  McCartney
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix (but because of the influence, not the music)
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel?  Phil Collins (of the two, Gabriel, though I love both)
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson?  John Wetton (of the two, Lake, though I love both)
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads?  Rhoads (though this is like picking which testicle I like better)
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury?  Mercury
Boston or Chicago? The city?  Boston.  The band?  Boston.
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Coverdale
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Lepp (this isn't close, though I like "Wanted Dead Or Alive" more than any other song by both bands)
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Dave Murray!!!!
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine?  Hetfield in perhaps the most lopsided win of any of these questions
The Clash or The Ramones?  The  Sex Pistols or Motorhead (I'm not big on hipster bands that actually suck)
Tom Waits or Tom Petty?  Tom Keifer
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams?   The greatest frontman in the history of hard rock/metal: Bruce Dickinson
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert?    Eeeeeesh... Gilbert
Pantera or Soundgarden?  Soundgarden, in what is now the most lopsided win of any of these questions
Blur or Oasis?  Oasis
Radiohead or Muse? Muse, but this is like selecting "Hepatitis or bubonic plague?"  I despise Radiohead.
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire?  Micheal Flatley

[romdrums]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Zep all the way.
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Lennon, but it's close.
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? Gabriel
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Anderson
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? EVH
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Mercury
Boston or Chicago? Chicago
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Coverdale
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Def Leppard
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Adrian Smith
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? James-ahh!
The Clash or The Ramones? The Clash
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Tom
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Paul Gilbert
Pantera or Soundgarden? Soundgarden
Blur or Oasis? Blur
Radiohead or Muse? Muse
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Fred Astaire

[Stadler]

My image:



or

[ariich]

Apparently I missed the first question from my list. I updated my post above. Not sure if that raises or lowers my compatibility...

[Evermind]

Can't tell if half of Ev's answers are jokes or not. And I thought mine was bad with the fogeys. And he still has a higher compatibility than me! 

I'm pretty proud of the Oasis one.

[Indiscipline]

Elite's compatibility index: 35%, 0.5% factoring in free saturday envy

Stadler's compatibility index: 45%, 85% factoring in Blackmore love, 785% factoring in Radiohead disgust

romdrum's compatibility index: 55%, 80% if you help me negotiate your emoticon with BBCode, the bane of my existance.

ariich: +5%

[The Walrus]

Can't tell if half of Ev's answers are jokes or not. And I thought mine was bad with the fogeys. And he still has a higher compatibility than me! 

I'm pretty proud of the Oasis one.

 

Stadler:



I think Stadler should have the first one because it more closely resembles him. 

[Stadler]

I've devolved to the point of the young'uns doing my computer work for me. I'm my DAD NOW!!!!  ARRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!

[jingle.boy]

Great news, ariich!

Jingle's compatibility index: 25%, 55% if we factor in honesty and humour.

Awesome... so far 55% one of a few passing grades. 

[King Postwhore]

I just woke up from a nap.


Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Led Zep because of Plant's Abs.
John Lennon or Paul McCartney?  Paul, because he's silly.
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix?  This is like asking which ball sack would I like to be kicked in.
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel?  Gabriel.  He can sing in a large gerbil ball.
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson?  John Anderson.  The only male pixel I know.
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads?  Randy. Eddie's a dick in real life.
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury?  Freddie. Don't fracture this.
Boston or Chicago?  Horns me baby!
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes?  Coverdale.  He likes to slide it in.
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi?  Bon Jovi.  Have you seen his ass in tight jeans?
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray?  Adrian. His solos are tastier.
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine?  The Cowardly Lion.
The Clash or The Ramones?  The Clash. Any lower % of punk in one's life is healthier.
Tom Waits or Tom Petty?  Petty,  I know how it feels.
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams?  Bruce.  Bowl cuts before hoes.
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert?  Nuno, Sexy as fuck. (His playing that is.)
Pantera or Soundgarden?  Soundgarden.  Who like bands with their name modeled by after conditioner?
Blur or Oasis?  Let them battle it out on Celebrity Deathmatch.
Radiohead or Muse?  Muse. 2 straight eyes.
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire?  Bob Hope.  Don't ask me to dance bub.

[Indiscipline]

King's compatibility index: 45%

[The Walrus]

I've devolved to the point of the young'uns doing my computer work for me. I'm my DAD NOW!!!!  ARRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!

 

[Sacul]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Neither.
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Neither.
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Neither.
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? I'm only slightly familiar with Ian so yeah.
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Neither.
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? Neither.
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Freddie, dunno who the other is.
Boston or Chicago? I've only listened to Boston's debut and it's nice.
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Neither.
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Bon Jovi because I used to be obsessed with It's My Life as a kid  .
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Neither.
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Neither.
The Clash or The Ramones? Neither.
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Neither.
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Neither.
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Neither.
Pantera or Soundgarden? Neither.
Blur or Oasis? I've only listened to one Oasis album so them.
Radiohead or Muse? Radiohead, not even close.
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Neither.

[The Walrus]

Yooo Sacul I used to be obsessed with It's My Life too 

[Sacul]

Yooo Sacul I used to be obsessed with It's My Life too 

I've even lost the count of how many times I've watched the video.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? That's a tough one...Zep by a hair??
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Paul McCartney & Wings>John Lennon>Paul McCartney
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Hendrix
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? Pete
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? This is like choosing between my right and left eye
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? If Randy Rhoads was still alive maybe, but this goes to Eddie
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Journey>Queen, Freddie>Steve
Boston or Chicago? Boston had exactly 2 good albums. Chicago had many. This is a no brainer
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Coverdale
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? They both had 2 great albums to begin their careers, but Def Leppard was a little more consistent after that.
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Cant have one without the other.....except that horrible time in the 90's
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Hetfield to write the song and sing, Mustaine to write the guitar solos
The Clash or The Ramones? If I have to choose...The Clash. Mostly because every Ramones song sounds the same.
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Petty
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce for singing talent. Eric for taking photos in leotards and speedos....
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Paul by a hair....
Pantera or Soundgarden? Soundgarden, no contest. Take your knuckle dragging, neanderthal, tough guy music elsewhere  except Cemetary Gates, that song rules
Blur or Oasis? Oasis
Radiohead or Muse? Muse>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Radiohead>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Creep, this song blows
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Fred by a nose?

[Stadler]

Deep Purple or Led Zeppelin? Neither.
John Lennon or Paul McCartney? Neither.
Frank Zappa or Jimi Hendrix? Neither.
Ian Anderson or Peter Gabriel? I'm only slightly familiar with Ian so yeah.
Greg Lake or Jon Anderson? Neither.
Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhoads? Neither.
Steve Perry or Freddie Mercury? Freddie, dunno who the other is.
Boston or Chicago? I've only listened to Boston's debut and it's nice.
David Coverdale or Glenn Hughes? Neither.
Def Leppard or Bon Jovi? Bon Jovi because I used to be obsessed with It's My Life as a kid  .
Adrian Smith or Dave Murray? Neither.
James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine? Neither.
The Clash or The Ramones? Neither.
Tom Waits or Tom Petty? Neither.
Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Neither.
Nuno Bettencourt or Paul Gilbert? Neither.
Pantera or Soundgarden? Neither.
Blur or Oasis? I've only listened to one Oasis album so them.
Radiohead or Muse? Radiohead, not even close.
Gene Kelly or Fred Astaire? Neither.

Frankly I don't understand the "neithers" for some of them but whatever; but the one that stuck out at me: Steve Perry.  You don't have to like him, you don't have to like his band's music (it's of a genre; it's great for it's genre, but it's of that genre), but you owe it to yourself and your musical knowledge to know who he is.

Again, not saying you should like it, or want to hear it ever again, but your musical knowledge and vocabulary is severely lacking if it doesn't know who "Steve Perry" is.  (If you need one album, and one album only, it's "Escape".  Be warned, Steve Perry is about as different than Thom Yorke as Lemmy is from Annie Haslam.)   

[King Postwhore]

Yooo Sacul I used to be obsessed with It's My Life too 

I've even lost the count of how many times I've watched the video.

Whomp. whomp!!

[Stadler]

Bruce Dickinson or Eric Adams? Bruce for singing talent. Eric for taking photos in leotards and speedos....

[Indiscipline]

Sacul's compatibility index: 10%, 50% factoring in honesty

Puppies' compatibility index: 45%

Bruce's chest hair: 86%