jingle.boy's 4th roulette: That's all she wrote folks - another happy ending

[jingle.boy]

OK fine.  Did Kattelox send Time Requiem?

Yes.

@ TAC... are you just listing random connections now?  You're all over the map, and only got one right.

[TAC]

I got Lonestar, JJ, and Lowdz.

That's all I got.

Kade-Amorphis? 

[Lethean]

What about wolfking for Helloween?

Also, Kattelox has a correct guess that you missed.

[The Walrus]

Damn right. Crack that whip! 

[TAC]

What about wolfking for Helloween?

No way Kade sends Dr. Stein.

[Lethean]

What about wolfking for Helloween?

No way Kade sends Dr. Stein.

I'm sure you'd know better than I.  I was just going off his discussing the old Stratovarius song in my roulette, and thinking old Strato and old Helloween might not be a huge stretch.

[wolfking]

What about wolfking for Helloween?

No way Kade sends Dr. Stein.

Tim knows me too well.

[wolfking]

Keep in mind Choirboys is Australian.

[The Walrus]

ohheywolfkingsentchoirboys

[wolfking]

Is the fifth one Wolverine, Your Favourite War?

It is indeed.

Im guessing you sent them then?

[Lethean]

Wolverine is a great pick.

[wolfking]

I think Elite sent Katatonia.

[Lethean]

Um....

[The Walrus]

And I say again, Lethean sent Katatonia. 

[Elite]

I think Elite sent Katatonia.

Not a fan of Katatonia, really.

There's one band in that list that's a definite Elite-band that I send more often in roulettes.

[wolfking]

Took a stab really haha.

[wolfking]

I think Elite sent Katatonia.

Not a fan of Katatonia, really.

There's one band in that list that's a definite Elite-band that I send more often in roulettes.

Caligula's Horse?

[wolfking]

Kade-Amorphis? 

Seems you say that like there is no way I would send them.

[Elite]

I think Elite sent Katatonia.

Not a fan of Katatonia, really.

There's one band in that list that's a definite Elite-band that I send more often in roulettes.

Caligula's Horse?

[Crow]

caligula's horse is objectively a parama band before anyone else because i made their thread in 2011 before anyone else here had any goddamn clue who they were 

[Indiscipline]

(??) -  / The Wolf

Motorhead / The Wolf?

[Train of Naught]

Umm Caligula's Horse is definitely a consul Incitatus-band and no one other than him deserves that title

[Elite]

caligula's horse is objectively a parama band before anyone else because i made their thread in 2011 before anyone else here had any goddamn clue who they were 

but you never send them in roulettes and I do

and you didn't like In Contact

[Crow]

nah i thought in contact was "okay"

TTtTaRE is where it's at though boyyy
so like, good pick 

[jingle.boy]

(??) -  / The Wolf
(lonestar) - Orphaned Land* / The Cave
(kingshmegland) - A.C.T. / The Effect
(Elite) - Caligula's Horse / All is Quiet By the Wall
(Evermind) - Wolverine / Your Favorite War
(Train Of Naught) - Soen / Sectarian
(Kattoelox) - Time Requiem - Sin to Sin
(??) - Choirboys - Run to Paradise
(??) - The Lord Weird Slough Feg / High Passage / Low Passage
(Indiscipline) - Helloween* / Dr. Stein
(jjrock88) - Fifth Angel / Time Will Tell
(Lowdz) - Eric Gillette / The Great Unknown
(Lethean) - Katatonia / Old Heart Falls
(Stadler) - Wetton/Downes / Under the Sky
(wolfking) - Amorphis / Amongst Stars
(Parama) - The Hirsch Effekt / Agitation

And a reminder as to who still hasn't been correctly identified with their song

TAC
Puppies
Bolsters

Motorhead / The Wolf?

Negatory.

[Nekov]

King sent A.C.T

[Bolsters]

Since there's 16 people and that isn't divisible by 3, will it be five getting a strike or six?

[jingle.boy]

King sent A.C.T

Since there's 16 people and that isn't divisible by 3, will it be five getting a strike or six?

Five and one third, naturally.   

To tell you the truth, I think I might dumb that twist down a little.  I had put it in place in case anyone was repeatedly sending me stuff I didn't like, and still want that option.  Nothing this round was outright tripe, so if it stays this way, I don't see the need to eliminate anyone.  Instead of finishing in the bottom 1/3rd, I think I'll make it the bottom 3.  And rather than making eliminations a for sure thing, I'd like to reserve the right to axe anyone who finishes in the bottom three 3x.  To be honest, listening to 16 tunes wasn't overly onerous, and so long as I don't have a bunch of 15+minute songs in a given round, it won't be.  So it's possible we may see 16 people to the very end.

[Indiscipline]

Nothing this round was outright tripe, so if it stays this way, I don't see the need to eliminate anyone. 

[TAC]

Kade-Amorphis? 

Seems you say that like there is no way I would send them.

No. I put the  because Chad was busting on me for guessing all over the place. So after I said that's all I got, I made another guess.

[TAC]

Indiscipline is a big Kiske guy. Did he send the Helloween? I can definitely see him liking those focking lyrics.

[jingle.boy]

Indiscipline is a big Kiske guy. Did he send the Helloween? I can definitely see him liking those focking lyrics.

[lonestar]

To be honest, listening to 16 tunes wasn't overly onerous, and so long as I don't have a bunch of 15+minute songs in a given round, it won't be.  So it's possible we may see 16 people to the very end.

Hold my beer....


Doesn't this take away the advantage given by finding the secret bands though?

[TAC]

To be honest, listening to 16 tunes wasn't overly onerous, and so long as I don't have a bunch of 15+minute songs in a given round, it won't be.  So it's possible we may see 16 people to the very end.

Hold my beer....


Doesn't this take away the advantage given by finding the secret bands though?

No, but it will ensure you see the first actual round. 

[Lethean]

I'm still thinking Stadler's pick could be one of the secret bands...