Great thread. I am a long time fan of DT and JLB sympathizer. I definately feel James vocal abilities, in regards to performance of early DT discography, shows his age. Geddy lee, Halford and Dickinson, Tate (dear god), many others are unable to perform early tracks during live shows.
Anyway, that being said, I feel JLB's performance on The Astonishing, just a few years ago, was virtuosic and brilliant, on so many levels. And, at the age of 50 plus, JLB had recorded one of his best vocal performances, IMO, on TA, that I have ever heard.
Going forward, DT needs to focus on JLB's other vocal abilities, as TA did. Explore that. He still has an amazing voice, with heart and emotion that I think, is the essence of why he has a large contingent of DT fans, that appreciate him. Look at recent tracks like Breaking all Illusions, The X Aspect, JLB is present, and provides great attachment to these pieces. BAL is an instant classic. DT needs to stay in that wheelhouse and JLB will represent.
Peace. First, post in like 2 yrs....wtf