To make it clear right away, LordCost, you're safe. I kinda liked your song from the start but I couldn't get into it fully, like there was something missing. Fortunately for you, it clicked with me after many listens. It sounds like Steven Wilson a lot, not just the music but also the voice. Similar to his music, this goes all over the place which isn't always a good thing but here it is. There are these small atmospheric pauses and buildups (I love those drums) that really make this song interesting and definitely as if it's shorter than 9 minutes. First tree songs are very good so you'll have to be satisfied with the 4th place even though this song is good as well.
Next, there are two songs I had even more trouble getting into. First one's chorus actually got stuck in my head (and I could't remember anything else from the songs) and second was pretty forgettable for me, unfortunately.
This one seemed very familiar, mostly because it sounds like The Dear Hunter to the point it's almost forced. As I said chorus got stuck in my head from the start, the rest needed some time but in the end I liked it enough to give it green light for the next round. Soupytwist, this one's was your worst submission so far but you're still in!
And here we come to the last song... the song that is actually pretty good but I couldn't get into it no matter what. And I heard it many many times, more than any other song, because I wanted to like it more. It's ok when I'm listening to it but I can't remember one melody, one word, anything... I'm sorry, Puppies_On_Acid, you're out!
1. Parama: Huntsmen - Pyre
2. home: Sufjan Stevens, Bryce Dessner, Nico Muhly, James McAlister - Jupiter
3. Train of Naught: In Vain - Floating on the Murmuring Tide
4. LordCost: Amplifier - Forever and More
5. soupytwist: Dirt Poor Robins - Great Vacation
6. Puppies_On_Acid: Minus the Bear - Knights
As I said, there will be a week without roulette, I'm busy with homework and there is Trivium concert this weekend, I'm getting ready for it
However, I wouldn't like you to forget this roulette exists so you can send me some funny and/or bad songs just for fun
Send me your real submissions by next Monday.