So, major update, since like Walrus, I finally decided - after starting from the greatest hits collection and then sampling all over the place the other songs - to properly start to listen to the discography in order!
I mean, the amount of songs I've checked out here and there was already big and I already heard some albums in full, so I already had a clear idea of what every album was like, but I've decided to do things properly.
The debut is nice, as a whole it flows quite well and there are many nice songs on it. I can't get on the second album however (Wild, Innocent and E-Street shuffle) - I know it's "my fault", 'cause the songs are quite good, but for whatever reason even the epics like Incident and NYC serenade, but it's doesn't grab me. Uh well, can't force yourself to like an album.
Now on to the classic era... BORN TO RUN is a bit weird for me, since I'd daresay that all the songs are way better when played live. For the longest time I couldn't get into Thunder Road, it's when I heard live versions that I understood the greatness of the song. I already found very nice live versions of these songs, but if one I day I commit to it and compile my own "Born to Run - live" playlist, I guess I could never need to listen to the album version again. I mean, it's a brilliant album and fully deserving of the classic status it has, but I think that this album comes truly alive when played in front of an audience.
My other favorite is DARKNESS ON THE EDGE OF TOWN, where I don't really have this "live is better" problem; I'm perfectly fine with the studio versions of Badlands, The Promised Land and the title track, even though of course live renditions from the era are a riot. Racing in the Street for example is something else live. I also think that side 2 is stronger than side 1, the final 5 songs are a great run.
Then we come to THE RIVER, double album, 20 songs; not all of them are essential, but there's a lot of good stuff that I was previously unaware of. There's also a big contrast - on the same album we have a song about the annoying ma of the protagonist's girlfriend (Sherry Darling) AND a heartwrenching story of regret and childhood stolen by an unexpected pregnancy (The River)? I've read that it was the precise point of the album, having very silly songs next to dramatic songs, still a bit weird and uneven. An enjoyable album, with the first disc being stronger than the second IMHO.
After that came NEBRASKA.... which is haunting and moody as everyone was saying. Great album made up of acoustic demos, perfect for the raw nature of the bleak stories told.
What wasn't used in Nebraska was kept for the big hit, BORN IN THE USA - Again, like Darkness, I feel it's weirdly paced 'cause all the good stuff is on side B. The album starts strong with the title track, and then follows with my THREE least favorite songs on the album, only Downbound Train redeems the first side... and it's in the second one that all the good stuff happens - No Surrender, Bobby Jean, the overplayed and overfamous classics like Glory Days and Dancing in the Dark... who else puts a hit single as penultimate track on a record?
I can see why Born in the USA became a huge best seller, but best seller does not always equal best overall. I'm still undecided on my favorite album - every album has a song or two I don't really love, and as I said many songs are totally better in their live version. Maybe Bruce has never been all about the albums per se, but more about the stories told and the live performances, where the songs really shows their strenght.
So I have finally heard in their entirety all the classic albums of the Boss. I'm looking forward to the next batch (Tunnel of Love, Human Touch, Lucky Town and The Ghost of Tom Joad), the period without the E Street Band; I'm curious to see which hidden gems are in albums that came out in his least successful period. I'm already prepared for them to not be so great from start to finish, so any other hidden gem I discover, it will be a plus. Also with these albums being so old there's not the "trauma" of having lived through them in real time, and I can appreciate them for what they are (kinda like what happens with Load and Reload, it's definitively better to hear them after years than living in real time through that era).