I got into Godsmack the same time as Disturbed in 2001. I remember riding my bike to K-Mart to buy Self titled and Awake, because I had money, and K-mart sold unedited CDs. Self titled is good up to Bad Religion. Awake was boring as fuck, and I shelved it for a year. I decided to give it another chance, and it clicked more, but some songs still weren't that great. When Faceless came out I was blown away. Typical Godsmack, but just awesome.
So naturally they followed it up with a steaming turd, production wise and song wise. I was so disappointed, and eventually moved on. Just recently I went on a Godsmack binge rediscovering them. Awake was even better than I remember it, in fact only one song I'd consider filler. Self titled was still just half good, and Faceless was as good as ever, although I noticed that all the songs pretty much have the same structure. I found a few decent tunes on IV, but the production is still awful. The Oracle has some good stuff too, and 1000Hp has a couple. They'll probably never top Awake and Faceless, but I'm glad they can still churn out a few decent songs every so often.