Awake is #1 for me. It was the first DT album I was exposed to (sometime in 1996), but its status at the top does not rest on mere sentiment alone. Additional factors include:
- near perfect combination of heaviness with technicality and progressiveness
- JP's best solo (Voices)
- JLB's varied vocal performance
- diversity: heavy songs & ballads; short songs & long ones; happy, soaring melodies & dark, disturbing tones; accessible at points & at others almost impossibly hard-to-wrap-your-brain-around
- some of their best lyrical work (Voices, SDV), as well as overall lyrical consistency
- the best instrumental
- squeezing the most amount of heaviness
out of a simplistic riff EVER (The Mirror)
- galactic cowboys are thanked in the liner notes
- lastly, as per my sig:
AWAKE HAS 5 LETTERS; JESUS HAS 5 LETTERS - CASE CLOSED.