Kamelot Survivor - The Black Halo - Round 10

[Evermind]

The Black Halo (2005)

Round 9 Results:

March of Mephisto - 2 (14,3%)
When the Lights Are Down - 4 (28,6%)
Abandoned - 4 (28,6%)
Moonlight - 2 (14,3%)
Memento Mori - 2 (14,3%)

Round 9 Tiebreaker Results:

When the Lights Are Down - 8 (66,7%)
Abandoned - 4 (33,3%)

Eliminated:

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7. When the Lights Are Down
8. The Black Halo
9. Serenade
10. Nothing Ever Dies
11. This Pain
12. Epilogue
13. Interlude I: Dei Gratia
14. Interlude II: Un Assassinio Molto Silenzioso
15. Interlude III: Midnight – Twelve Tolls For A New Day

When the Lights Are Down is eliminated in a tiebreaker, Abandoned lives on.

You have 48 hours to vote.

[Evermind]

Holding my vote, but I'm willing to go for anything that isn't Abandoned, particularly March of Mephisto or Memento Mori.

[MirrorMask]

I'm all for voting out Memento Mori! (Moonlight as a second choice)

Your dear Abandoned has probably 4 votes guaranteed, so we'd have to converge on a song that gets more than 4 votes.

[CDrice]

I voted (again) for Moonlight. My next choices would be either The Haunting or Soul Society, but at this point it's looking like they might end up as being the top two. 

[Crow]

abondored and the top 5 will be almost perfect

[Adami]

Moonlight.

[wolfking]

Memento Mori

[425]

Whichever one gives me the best shot at protecting March of Mephisto and Memento Mori, the two best on the album. Preferably Abandoned or Moonlight, which should be the two to miss out on the top 4, but just something to save the best ones.

[Adami]

Whichever one gives me the best shot at protecting March of Mephisto and Memento Mori, the two best on the album. Preferably Abandoned or Moonlight, which should be the two to miss out on the top 4, but just something to save the best ones.

Neither of those songs need saving. They're fine.

[425]

Well, there seemed to be a lot of threats to go after them. Went with Abandoned. I agree with Parama; the non-Abandoned five are a great top five. I like Serenade well enough to beat some of those, but I guess others don't like it.

[Evermind]

Alright then.

Moonlight

[MirrorMask]

Joining against Moonlight, which is not just strategy but actually the one I like the least along with Memento Mori... that will get all my votes from next round onwards.

[Destiny Of Chaos]

Cannot believe The 4th Legacy and When the Lights are Down aren't final bound.

You monsters aren't going to keep Sacrimony out too are you?



Abandoned

[MirrorMask]

You monsters aren't going to keep Sacrimony out too are you?

I'll make sure it wins the Silverthorn survivor!

[Evermind]

Sacrimony is awesome, but not quite Final worthy in my opinion. I mean, Song for Jolee is clearly the best, and then we have My Confession, Falling like a Fahrenheit and the title track... lots of amazing tunes on that one.

[MirrorMask]

Sacrimony is awesome, but not quite Final worthy in my opinion. I mean, Song for Jolee is clearly the best, and then we have My Confession, Falling like a Fahrenheit and the title track... lots of amazing tunes on that one.

Song for Jolee doesn't really grab me and I can't even remember how the title track goes, which shows how much it stuck with me.

Really, Abandoned is the only Kamelot ballad we're agreeing so far 

[Evermind]

The title track has some really weird melodies, but when it clicks with you, it's just outstanding. "A deadly serenade" and "Like fear on a silverplate" lines are fucking gold.

Song of Jolee and Fallen Star are the songs that really have that glorious Epica / The Black Halo vibe. My two favourite songs from the Tommy-fronted albums.

[Scorpion]

My favourites on Silverthorn are Sacrimony, Solitaire and Prodigal Son, probably, but I love that album a lot, so it's going to be really hard to vote for that one.

[cramx3]

Moonlight. Going strategic here to help abandoned and memento mori