Having read/seen reviews and seen most of the trailers/tv spots, I can say that, as of now, this is in-fact looking more like a huge budget, modernized version of a silly TOS episode. Which is brilliant for the people who worship the original series. If that's the case, I'm sure I'll enjoy it but may not love it. Especially since I am more of a fan of TNG and onward, rather than the fun romp in space of the TOS, and I doubt we're getting a City on the Edge of Forever level of depth or brilliance in the new movie. I'm hoping for a fun classic-Star Trek feel, which isn't what I'd prefer, but I'd be satisfied with it. Of course mostly I want tight writing. I know everyone loved ST09, but I really didn't like that movie, mostly because the writing and plot holes were just pretty awful. So you give me a fun ST classic feeling romp with tight righting and I'll be cool.