Nightwish Survivor - Endless Forms Most Beautiful - Round 7

[Evermind]

Round 6 Results:

Weak Fantasy - 1 (7,7%)
Endless Forms Most Beautiful - 5 (38,5%)
Edema Ruh - 3 (23,1%)
Alpenglow - 1 (7,7%)
The Greatest Show on Earth - 3 (23,1%)

Eliminated:

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6. Endless Forms Most Beautiful
7. Élan
8. Our Decades in the Sun
9. My Walden
10. Yours is an Empty Hope
11. The Eyes of Sharbat Gula

The title track is out.
______

Well, now it's time for the epic! Hopefully it's going out, and that makes it the lucky one. I suppose.

The Greatest Show on Earth

[425]

The Greatest Show On Earth, again. I don't like that any of these has to leave the survivor entirely, but I just can't imagine it being any of the other four. As an 18-minute song, maybe it's a different conversation. But as a 24-minute song, the other four should survive.

[jakepriest]

Edema Ruh

[cramx3]

Edema Ruh

[Evermind]

Don't vote it bruh

[jingle.boy]

Greatest Show on Earth

[Destiny Of Chaos]

I cannot believe that TGSoE is actually getting votes.

I can't believe that TGSoE is in danger of missing the Nightwish Final Survivor. Wouldn't feel right without it. That beast of a song is an absolutely incredible experience that transcends what a song can be.


1.
2.
3. Yours Is An Empty Hope
4.
5. Endless Forms Most Beautiful
6. The Eyes Of Sharbat Gula
7. Elan
8.
9. Edema Ruh
10. Our Decades in the Sun
11. My Walden

[cramx3]

I cannot believe that TGSoE is actually getting votes.

I can't believe that TGSoE is in danger of missing the Nightwish Final Survivor. Wouldn't feel right without it. That beast of a song is an absolutely incredible experience that transcends what a song can be.

Agreed. I get the complaints about the length, I actually agree with that for the most part, but damn the song is amazing.  Very sad.

[425]

I cannot believe that TGSoE is actually getting votes.

I can't believe that TGSoE is in danger of missing the Nightwish Final Survivor. Wouldn't feel right without it. That beast of a song is an absolutely incredible experience that transcends what a song can be.

I understand your perspective, even though I voted for it. It will be weird to not see it if that's the way it falls.

That said. I agonized over this vote (at least as much as anyone can over a song survivor vote), listened to the album again last night and everything, but I just can't vote any of these other four out ahead of it.

[jingle.boy]

Long does not automatically mean good.

The song is 11 minutes of amazing/brilliant, 3 minutes of good, and 10 minutes of waste.  Ergo the song - AS A WHOLE - is far from amazing.  Frankly, I could've voted for it a couple of rounds ago.

[425]

I'd put it a very close sixth behind these four and the title track. Those six are bunched up pretty close, but I do think TGSOE is the weak one out there.

[sfam2112]

Edema Ruh