Nightwish Survivor - Imaginaerum - Round 4 Tiebreaker

[Evermind]

Round 4 Results:

Scaretale - 6 (37,5%)
Turn Loose the Mermaids - 1 (6,3%)
Rest Calm - 1 (6,3%)
The Crow, The Owl and The Dove - 6 (37,5%)
Song of Myself - 2 (12,5%)

Another tiebreaker! 24 hours to vote.
______

Scaretale

For the fifth time.

[jakepriest]

The Crow, The Owl and the Dove

Save Scaretale guys!

[Destiny Of Chaos]

The Crow, The Owl and the Dove

Save Scaretale guys!

[Scorpion]

That bird song is awesome.

[cramx3]

The Crow, The Owl and the Dove

Save Scaretale guys!

[425]

Scaretale. The birdie song is much better, though I can understand why it got votes.

[Ben_Jamin]

Dammit....none of these should be here.

I'll go scaretale, even though I really enjoy it.

[sfam2112]

Scaretale

[Evermind]

So, is there anyone who missed the vote and wants to vote now, or should I go and PM someone to break the tie?

[Evermind]

Alright, PM sent! Knowing the guy, he'll probably let Scaretale live just to spite me.

[Destiny Of Chaos]

Alright, PM sent! Knowing the guy, he'll probably let Scaretale live just to spite me.

Is this guy a Nightwish fan? If he is, why isn't he voting regularly? If he isn't, why should his vote count?

[Sacul]

Surprise! Guess you didn't see that coming

Anyways, so... Out of both, I enjoyed Scaretale a bit more - thus the other song shall fall into oblivion, kiss the lips of darkness, and dance with the lord of shadows (hey, those words would fit a power metal song).

Is this guy a Nightwish fan? If he is, why isn't he voting regularly? If he isn't, why should his vote count?

Not a fan here, vaguely familiar with Once tho. And I'm voting because Evermind is the evil ruler of this survivor

Alright, PM sent! Knowing the guy, he'll probably let Scaretale live just to spite me.

That, and because it has en epic opening. The other had some weird lyrics, but nice instrumentation.

[Evermind]

Alright, PM sent! Knowing the guy, he'll probably let Scaretale live just to spite me.

Is this guy a Nightwish fan? If he is, why isn't he voting regularly? If he isn't, why should his vote count?

Because us the Nightwish fans failed to determine the worst song out of those two in both main round and the tiebreaker. I pick a different person each time, sometimes they're familiar with the band's work, sometimes they aren't.

And um, why shouldn't his vote count? I sent Sacul the links for both songs, he gave them a few listens and decided the birds song was his least favourite out of the two. There's no rule that the voter should be a fan. It should be sufficient that the person is familiar with the options, that's all; and in this case we have two songs from Imaginaerum to choose from, not thirteen. I don't see a problem.

Anyway, fuck thank you Sacul!

[Destiny Of Chaos]

Alright, PM sent! Knowing the guy, he'll probably let Scaretale live just to spite me.

Is this guy a Nightwish fan? If he is, why isn't he voting regularly? If he isn't, why should his vote count?

Because us the Nightwish fans failed to determine the worst song out of those two in both main round and the tiebreaker. I pick a different person each time, sometimes they're familiar with the band's work, sometimes they aren't.

And um, why shouldn't his vote count? I sent Sacul the links for both songs, he gave them a few listens and decided the birds song was his least favourite out of the two. There's no rule that the voter should be a fan. It should be sufficient that the person is familiar with the options, that's all; and in this case we have two songs from Imaginaerum to choose from, not thirteen. I don't see a problem.

Anyway, fuck thank you Sacul!

I don't participate in survivors for bands that I don't love and listen to regularly. I don't think that my vote should carry the same weight as actual fans of the band. But that's just my personal thoughts on the matter, and you are certainly free to run your game as you see fit.

[Evermind]

Yeah DoC, sorry, but I disagree on this one. In my opinion, if the actual fans were unable to come to agreement twice, then some fresh perspective is more than helpful.

I know that the way you're running DT League (holding up your own vote in case there is a tie) is the ultimate way to solve this problem, but I want to vote in every round too, and if I'm running this survivor, I can allow myself this much.