The Shining
I've seen this movie several times, but haven't sat down to watch it in YEARS. Everything for the recent past has been clips and snippets. Kubrick, man. I can say a lot of the same things about this as I can 2001; it's surely high art, it's well-crafted no doubt, but so many questions...
I mentioned Jack Nicholson in discussing The Departed... what say us about him? I think he was perfect for the part... and yet, wrong for the part. Who else can you see having that discussion with Grady in the red men's room, or while locked in the freezer? No one, really; but I don't know about early on. Was Jack nuts before he ever went up there, or did the Overlook get to him? Nicholson, in my view, has a hard time playing an everyman, and I wonder if a little more contrast wouldn't have served.
Kudos to Shelly Duvall for sacrificing any dignity or self-respect for playing such a sniveling, spine-less, gutless person so completely. HAHA. We (my wife and daughter and I) all commented how horrible an actress she seemed to be (the stair scene where she's holding the bat halfway and swinging it like she's a drunk teenager playing pinata), and yet if you read the commentaries, both Kubrick and Nicholson laud her for a courageous, gutty performance. I think Nicholson said it was the hardest job he's ever seen an actor do on one of his films, or something like that (it's in IMDB "Trivia").