So I've listened to it enough now to have a more solid opinion. Though I'm not madly in love with it, I really enjoy most of the album. I don't hate any of the songs, but there are one or two "misses." Like "Sunny Side Up," especially the chorus. "Black Friday" is also a bit weaker but I still like it (again, the chorus kinda kills it for me). Both "Separation Anxiety" and "Cone of Shame" have a Pain of Salvation sorta vibe to me. "Matador" is probably my favorite. I love the first two, love "Motherfucker" and "Rise of the Fall"... overall a strong and fun album, great energy.
In other news, I just found out they are doing a show at Red Rocks, and I already bought tickets. So pumped!