I think Rob is a little off and a little right. Few people actually said that the song was the worst thing ever, but the point made by the majority here is that it's not worth it's spot on the setlist, and I think they have a point, even if I don't completely agree on. It's not a song anyone it's dying to hear and it has more than it fair share of haters, probably among the most hated songs in the catalogue even outside DTF(it's got its fame somewhere, this forum didn't create it). And this place is the most tolerant towards FII I've seen so far, so I wouldn't say that the fact that we're "DT nerds" goes against the song.
Besides, there isn't almost any real casual DT fans, at least not among concert goers. DT is not a band that's over the radio or on the news or whatever that people go and see because they know 10 songs because they overheard them or like one album, unless you count the girlfriend/friend just coming along. Hard to know for sure, but I'm pretty confident that this band number of hardcore fans per casual ratio is one of the highest there are for a band this size. I would guess that at least 50% of the audience has heard every album song at least once. It's not exactly A Vision or Eve, it's on the regular albums!(and it's the second track, not the 11th)
Still, as I said before, it might be one of those songs that gains better appreciation after it's played live, it certainly has the potential. I don't think it would be a big deal if they included it, it's just 5 minutes, if BMUBMD worked well live, this song can.