Back to the babes. This is a tough one for me, as I just haven't gotten too deep into Anathema, and Douglas isn't really a front person. Sharon on the other hand is a fantastic front-woman, but I just find her vocals lack a certain oomph. Don't get me wrong, she sounds great, has got fabulous range, and never misses a note. There's just a certain je ne sais quois that leaves me wanting more when I listen to Within Temptation.
Think I'm going with Douglas.