I'm a metal guy at heart, and I love Mike P., so I gave it a shot; I thought it was cartoony at the start, and other than the Sabbath cover, I haven't listened to any of it since the first release. Once Mike P. left (as much as I like AJ) they fell off the radar.
Doesn't help that I just don't see the what others do in Russell Allen. In my humble opinion, he is WAY overrated.