What are your thoughts on DT12?

[Zook]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

[haceeb]

Yeah, but then you'll have to go and make an even more perfect album, or your opinion will be invalid.

no i don't need to 'cause i believe in DT, you guys should 'cause you don't like DT12 

[Jaffa]

I'm confirmed about weaknesses of DT12.  Guess I'd better go make a perfect album...

How about a collaboration? I need to make a perfect album too.

Cool.  Think you could handle, like, everything?  I have no musical skill whatsoever.

*snip*

 

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

I haven't said this in a while, but I love you, Zook.

[haceeb]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

[Jaffa]

 

[Zook]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

[Onno]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

What the hell is that 

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

[haceeb]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

I'm not getting this inside joke but i guess this is what happens when you not criticize DT

[Zook]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

What the hell is that 

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

That's my band. You haven't heard of us? We're the #1 Plague Metal band of all time!

But really, that particular mix is beyond terrible, and believe it of not, it can sound better.

[Onno]

Ah, another marvelous metal genre I have yet to discover! Sometimes I gaze upon this world in wonder; I am truly astounded by the magnificent creations of our glorious race!

But seriously,

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

that is actually true.

[haceeb]

Haceeb, can you criticize this please:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MCxrlJh_gs

What the hell is that 

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

I have no idea about this band : KROTCHRAUT but seems okay to me

That's my band. You haven't heard of us? We're the #1 Plague Metal band of all time!

But really, that particular mix is beyond terrible, and believe it of not, it can sound better.

no i haven't heard, seems interesting. can't say bad or great at the moment 

[Implode]

2. If you don't like the album why you're still a DT fan.
3. If you're confirmed about weaknesses of DT12 then why don't you make a perfect album.
4. All hater's should make a album which can amaze DT members and  they become your fan.
5. If you think DT lineup is not good why don't you guys make a perfect band.
6. I love DT, i love their decisions, i love current lineup and i know they're perfect.
7. If they're that bad then start listening to A7X, 1D or bieber. 

I don't know why am I still a DT fan. I am confirmed about weakness, but can I not make perfect album. I guess I guys must make perfect band. Back to 1D and Bieber for me.

It is possible to still like DT even though you dislike an album. So DT12 isn't an album I like. It's not a big deal. It's not like I've sworn off the band and condemned them. They have already proven themselves to me. I respect their decisions even if they don't cater to me personally. They are still a great band.

[haceeb]

2. If you don't like the album why you're still a DT fan.
3. If you're confirmed about weaknesses of DT12 then why don't you make a perfect album.
4. All hater's should make a album which can amaze DT members and  they become your fan.
5. If you think DT lineup is not good why don't you guys make a perfect band.
6. I love DT, i love their decisions, i love current lineup and i know they're perfect.
7. If they're that bad then start listening to A7X, 1D or bieber. 

I don't know why am I still a DT fan. I am confirmed about weakness, but can I not make perfect album. I guess I guys must make perfect band. Back to 1D and Bieber for me.

It is possible to still like DT even though you dislike an album. So DT12 isn't an album I like. It's not a big deal. It's not like I've sworn off the band and condemned them. They have already proven themselves to me. I respect their decisions even if they don't cater to me personally. They are still a great band.

i guess you're the only one sane person here 

[Jaffa]

In all seriousness, I do like DT12.  It still hasn't quite clicked with me in the way that DT's other albums have, and nothing on it really blows me away, but it's consistently very good. 

[jakepriest]

I have no idea why you have to defend DT12 so much Haceeb. It's great that you love it, as it means that DT still has the ability to impress some fans.

But for some people it's just not their cup of tea or they might just not like the songwriting. It doesn't mean because they don't like the latest album they have to stop listening to DT or create their own perfect album or anything.

[Zook]

Ah, another marvelous metal genre I have yet to discover! Sometimes I gaze upon this world in wonder; I am truly astounded by the magnificent creations of our glorious race!

But seriously,

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

that is actually true.

Do the people there care much about playing ability, 'cause.... We have none.


back to Dream Theater and this:

1. It's my favorite DT and also my album of 2013.
2. If you don't like the album why you're still a DT fan.
3. If you're confirmed about weaknesses of DT12 then why don't you make a perfect album.
4. All hater's should make a album which can amaze DT members and  they become your fan.
5. If you think DT lineup is not good why don't you guys make a perfect band.
6. I love DT, i love their decisions, i love current lineup and i know they're perfect.
7. If they're that bad then start listening to A7X, 1D or bieber. 
8. DTvarium till death!

Assuming you aren't trolling:

1. That's great.
2. Huh? people can dislike the new album but still love their back catalog.
3. This is a retarded YouTube style comment. A person doesn't have to be an expert guitar player to critique an expert's guitar playing.
4. Same as above, and really, this doesn't make sense.
5. I have. KrotchRaut anyone?
6. That's great.
7. A7X, 1D and Bieber walk into a bar...
8. Enter the brutal KrotchRaut!

[haceeb]

I have no idea why you have to defend DT12 so much Haceeb. It's great that you love it, as it means that DT still has the ability to impress some fans.

But for some people it's just not their cup of tea or they might just not like the songwriting. It doesn't mean because they don't like the latest album they have to stop listening to DT or create their own perfect album or anything.

i agree it's not their cup of tea but you can't deny Prog Mag rating and it isn't even included in Eddie Trunks list so now you know where the hate is coming from. Also consider two grammy nominations.

[Jaffa]

So, it got a good rating in a magazine and a Grammy nomination, plus Eddie Trunk didn't mention it, therefore it's perfect?

[haceeb]

Ah, another marvelous metal genre I have yet to discover! Sometimes I gaze upon this world in wonder; I am truly astounded by the magnificent creations of our glorious race!

But seriously,

You should really travel to Hoogeveen, Holland, close to where my parents live. There's a small venue here (max 100-200 people) that hosts Metal Nights once a month. You'll probably get everyone headbanging anyway

that is actually true.

Do the people there care much about playing ability, 'cause.... We have none.


back to Dream Theater and this:

1. It's my favorite DT and also my album of 2013.
2. If you don't like the album why you're still a DT fan.
3. If you're confirmed about weaknesses of DT12 then why don't you make a perfect album.
4. All hater's should make a album which can amaze DT members and  they become your fan.
5. If you think DT lineup is not good why don't you guys make a perfect band.
6. I love DT, i love their decisions, i love current lineup and i know they're perfect.
7. If they're that bad then start listening to A7X, 1D or bieber. 
8. DTvarium till death!

Assuming you aren't trolling:

1. That's great.
2. Huh? people can dislike the new album but still love their back catalog.
3. This is a retarded YouTube style comment. A person doesn't have to be an expert guitar player to critique an expert's guitar playing.
4. Same as above, and really, this doesn't make sense.
5. I have. KrotchRaut anyone?
6. That's great.
7. A7X, 1D and Bieber walk into a bar...
8. Enter the brutal KrotchRaut!

I wasn't trolling that's for sure. yeah true KrotchRaut FTW!

[Zook]

So, it got a good rating in a magazine and a Grammy nomination, plus Eddie Trunk didn't mention it, therefore it's perfect?

 

[jonnybaxy]

I've said before I don't like it... But does that mean I'm not a DT fan? No, let's be serious, do you love WDADU?

Also if ratings and Grammys meant anything nicki Minaj and beiber would be the best musicians in the world....

[haceeb]

So, it got a good rating in a magazine and a Grammy nomination, plus Eddie Trunk didn't mention it, therefore it's perfect?

First i liked it and then these institutions also expressed the same thought. I wish eddie trunk was my friend 'cause i want to be famous too

[haceeb]

I've said before I don't like it... But does that mean I'm not a DT fan? No, let's be serious, do you love WDADU?

Also if ratingsm and Grammy meant anything nicki Minaj and beiber would be the best musicians in the world,,,

i love WDADU and every DT album...
i agree with you.

[jakepriest]

So you say you agree that Grammy's don't mean anything but you still point them out to be an indicator that the album is good...

[olddtfan51@gmail.com]

After living with this album for some time I will say that the music is great the mix is ok but the mastering has ruined this album for me. 

[TheGreatPretender]

After living with this album for some time I will say that the music is great the mix is ok but the mastering has ruined this album for me. 

Get the HD tracks version.

[haceeb]

After living with this album for some time I will say that the music is great the mix is ok but the mastering has ruined this album for me. 

Get the HD tracks version.

poof and problem solved. 

[BlobVanDam]

What the hell is happening in here?

[Zook]

Oh you know, the usual. A wacky fanboy posts outlandish opinions, we all take the bait, and I shamelessly plug my band that hasn't created new music in 4 years.

[Kotowboy]

After living with this album for some time I will say that the music is great the mix is ok but the mastering has ruined this album for me. 

Get the HD tracks version.

poof and problem solved. 

BANG AND THE DIRT IS GONE.

[KevShmev]

This haceeb fella cannot be for real.

[Lucidity]

I don't see how that post is very different from something you'd see any given Bieber fan post in response to criticism. Just because someone doesn't like every single second of music a band has produced doesn't mean that person isn't a huge fan and doesn't appreciate their music. You can't just assume everything DT has made is flawless because DT made it. Bliiiiind faith, we have in you...

[haceeb]

sorry guys i was wrong, you guys can't back Dream Theater so why would you back me.......

[Shadow Ninja 2.0]

Oh my.....

[Jaffa]

sorry guys i was wrong, you guys can't back Dream Theater so why would you back me.......

You're fun.