If you look at their live releases, of which there are only 3 I believe, it's almost all THwtD, Makes Me Wanna Sing, Reach Out, Loud and Clear, and Makes Me Wanna Sing:
Live in America 2003 (CD):
1. Sing Along Song *
2. Makes Me Wanna Sing
3. Calling On You *
4. Free *
5. More Than A Man *
6. Caught In The Middle
7. Reach Out
8. Loud 'N Clear
9. The Way *
10. Soldiers Under Command *
11. To Hell With The Devil *
12. Honestly *
13. Winter Wonderland
14. Closing Prayer
Live in Puerto Rico 2007 (DVD):
1. Sing Along Song *
2. Makes Me Want to Sing *
3. Calling On You *
4. Free *
5. More Than a Man *
6. Caught in the Middle
7. You Won't Be Lonely
8. Reach Out
9. Loud and Clear
10. The Way *
11. Soldiers Under Command *
12. To Hell With the Devil *
13. Honestly *
14. Winter Wonderland
Live in Indonesia 2010 (DVD):
1. Sing Along Song *
2. Murder By Pride
3. Loud 'N Clear
4. The Rock That Makes Me Roll
5. Reach Out
6. Calling On You *
7. Free *
8. More Than A Man *
9. Honestly *
10. Open Your Eyes
11. All For One
12. The Way *
13. Abyss/To Hell With The Devil *
14. Soldiers Under Command *
They have SO MANY great songs that they never play live cuz they stick with the classics. Even if they just do a few intimate one-off shows and play some rare stuff we could get that at least. I'm dying to hear live versions of:
Believe
Shining Star
Lady
Against the Law
Always There for You
I Believe In You
4 Leaf Clover
Reborn
When Did I See You Cry
Make You Mine
Live Again
Wait for You... pretty much all of Reborn
Something
For You
I dunno, maybe they play more stuff at actual shows but for official releases it's the same stuff. I love Stryper, and I'm agnostic, I just love the music.