I love this show. Watched a few episodes over the weekend, but I still have a few more to go. I'm generally lousy at trying to figure out how these tricks work. Honestly, I'm just not into magic acts all that much, so I'm pretty ignorant of a lot of the techniques. I just like to be entertained by it all. That being said, a couple of things:
*SPOILERS BELOW*
(and I'm not going to use smaller font because I personally hate that)
Regarding Young & Strange's trick (I think this was ep. 2, but I can't remember now): Obiously, the screen was the diversion. And I'm not familiar with how the locks work on devices like the big red box, but I am assuming that the box is not truly locked at all and can easily be opened from either inside or outside even when it appears "locked." The guy in the box getting out and running back around the other side of the screen is easy. He justs gets out of the box as soon as the screen is in place because the box isn't really locked (or the woman is inside the screen, gets out as soon as the screen is in place, and unlocks the box to let the guy out--not sure which). That's simple. The woman in the box could potentially happen either way. Either box is actually big enough for two people and she is in it to begin with, and there is still space for the guy to get in as well, or she is in the screen. The other guy, who runs around the screen and "disappears," only to reappear in the back of the theater is a bit trickier. But this seems to be simply a duplication of Christian Bale's "teleporting man" trick from The Prestige. If I am correct, this is actually a four person trick: Young, Strange, the woman, and Young's double. When he "disappears" behind the screen, he just gets inside the screen. His double then "appears" at the back of the auditorium, where he has been waiting all along. Penn's question and the answer seem to confirm this. When he asks whether it would be physically possible for he and Teller to perform the trick if they knew every single one of the moves, Young refuses to answer the question and concedes that they have figured it out. The reason is that the answer is, "no"--they could not physically duplicate the trick even if they knew all the moves because neither one of them has a twin that could fill in as their double, and answering "no" would be a huge tipoff (although I think anyone who has seen The Prestige would have figured that out regardless; and although I'm sure Penn wasn't trying to be a jerk, he inadvertently tipped off anyone who had seen The Prestige but not made the connection when he basically loosely quoted the movie and said something along the lines of, "as long as you can keep that secret, you will have one of the best tricks ever). Correct?
The one I have a question about is teller's fish tank/coin/goldfish sleight of hand trick at the end of one of the earlier episodes (I think it was also ep. 2). I get that it's all just sleight of hand. But how in the world does he get the goldfish in the tank? That blows my mind. The only thing I can figure is that the back of the tank is not truly transparent and is a false back with the goldfish concealed behind it. When he is "putting the goldfish in the tank," he is actually just stirring up the water and obscuring your view of whatever hidden trapdoor is opening at the back of the tank to spew the goldfish into the tank, making it look as if they are comming from Teller. So, really, the tank is a much more elaborate prop than it appears to be, if that is the case. Am I right, or are the fish concealed somewhere else and I have completely missed it?