No comment on the digital (I have almost 26,000 songs on my iPod, and MAYBE 100 of them aren't on a CD somewhere in my basement) but for me, since I don't feel like I paid more for the extra CD, I think it works. There's nothing worse than having a 78 minute CD where you feel ready for a piss break (pibroch, to our Tull fans) about 42 minutes in. I think in large part I liked it as much as I did because I got a chance to absorb it in a way that doesn't always happen in music these days. I contrast that with the new Marillion, which is good (well, after seeing much of it live, it's VERY good) but was a sort of slog to get through. And honestly, if I wasn't seeing them a week after I bought it, and wanting to know the music and give it a chance, I may not have listened to it ever again. What I did was create a playlist with the recent setlists and those songs were interspersed with others from the catalogue and it made it more digestible.