Dream Theater self titled album discussion - [SPOILER FREE DISCUSSION ONLY]

[wolven74]

Hey, it's okay He expressed his own opinion, which also happens to be not shared by us almost on a plebiscite level! In all fairness, no, I don't think it's disrespectful at all. They owe to Mike Portnoy a part of their past just like Mike Portnoy owes a part of his to them, but right now they have no obligation towards him.

Dream Theater is who they are, and they don't have to say "sorry" or "please" to anyone to state their identity on a musical level.

I'll add that I think if MP was still hung up on or hurt by his not being in DT anymore than I'm sure he'd already have fired off some social media negativity.

At this point, it looks as though MP has moved on to different things and come to terms with being out of DT. He's still a member of the bands history and is due a certain respect as a musician and a person.

[senecadawg2]

The DT12 cover art is perfect for Mangini`s drum kit.

 

[Zook]

Don´t you guys think that the decision to make it a self titled album is kind of disrespectful towards Mike Portnoy?

Well, Portnoy's dad did suggest the name so-

No it's not disrespectful an any way.

[Laich21DT]

Don´t you guys think that the decision to make it a self titled album is kind of disrespectful towards Mike Portnoy?

No. Why do you think that?

[425]

Don't you guys think that the decision to make it self titled is disrespectful toward Charlie Dominici?

Serious answer: No. I mean, MP surely isn't too happy about it, but that doesn't mean they meant any ill will by doing it.

[atmyne]

Hopefully there will be a bass solo this time around! #JMXgonewild

[Zook]

Don't you guys think that the decision to make it self titled is disrespectful toward Charlie Dominici?

Serious answer: No. I mean, MP surely isn't too happy about it, but that doesn't mean they meant any ill will by doing it.

I don't understand how anyone could perceive it as ill will to begin with.

[Mosh]

Maybe because some might think they are saying that the definitive version of Dream Theater doesn't include Mike Portnoy.

[King Postwhore]

It's a way to have a new beginning.  This album for them sound like a team output, that 5 guys, so it's a rebirth so to speak for them and to me that's why it's self titled.

[LBC.]

Hopefully there will be a bass solo this time around! #JMXgonewild

DT12 contains a bass solo (no speculation here)

[hefdaddy42]

Oh I know they probably wrote them together, but it really doesn't sound that way. I consider each "movement" as its own song.

Not sure where you get that.  It definitely sounds unified to me, and it is most certainly one song, not a collection of songs.

Pretty sure he was talking about AMBI for that part, not Octavarium.

Yes I was. If it was one song, then they would've labeled it as such. They barely even play the entire thing live.

Oh, yeah, I totally thought you were referring to Octavarium as a suite.  AMBI is definitely a suite.

[YtseCullen]

Sooo there's this... tour info, or maybe something else?

[atmyne]

Hopefully there will be a bass solo this time around! #JMXgonewild

DT12 contains a bass solo (no speculation here)

yep thank you for discretely acknowledging that

[Zook]

Maybe because some might think they are saying that the definitive version of Dream Theater doesn't include Mike Portnoy.

That's ridiculous.

[Voices]

Maybe a single won't hurt anybody. Just saying.

And I think that there will be a bass solo on the new album! 

[SaterUM]

I'm just waiting that they released a song, last time with "On the Back of Angels" of A Dramatic turn of Events the lapse between the song and the album was more earlier, damn hype

[LBC.]

Hopefully there will be a bass solo this time around! #JMXgonewild

DT12 contains a bass solo (no speculation here)

yep thank you for discretely acknowledging that

I didn`t want to be discrete.

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

[wasteland]

I didn`t want to be discrete.

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Edward Snowden, is that you? Didn't know you were into DT 

[Scotto123]

I'm seriously going nuts about this album. I desperately want a single to come out to at least satiate my anxiety about the new album. I really hope something comes out soon.

[wolven74]

I didn`t want to be discrete.

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Edward Snowden, is that you? Didn't know you were into DT 

 

[atmyne]

I didn`t want to be discrete.

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

lol i'm assuming you have no intention of not being banned from this forum...
If that's not the case you probably should refrain from hinting at leaks or spoilers or any information that hasn't officially been released. I personally don't mind, but someone like Bosk will probably go all sith ninja on your ass. jussayin.

[LBC.]

I didn`t want to be discrete.

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Edward Snowden, is that you? Didn't know you were into DT 

No, I`m not him 

People here are being killed by the hype. A very little bit of info isn`t a crime.

I'm seriously going nuts about this album. I desperately want a single to come out to at least satiate my anxiety about the new album. I really hope something comes out soon.

I don`t want any single or snippet. One thing is to know album details, and other completely different is to hear something. I prefer to hear it as a completely new thing.

[matte.braso]

mmmmmm single or In studio ep.2 this week.....hopefully both

[dparrott]

Sooo there's this... tour info, or maybe something else?

The news is there will be a single released soon.   
/sarcasm

[LBC.]

[theseoafs]

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Not sure how I feel about this new guy.

[senecadawg2]

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Not sure how I feel about this new guy.

Just look at his avatar! can't go wrong

[tiagodon]

I just thought that by making it a self titled album they would be sending a message. Something like: this album is the real deal and this is DT at its best!

[senecadawg2]

I just thought that by making it a self titled album they would be sending a message. Something like: this album is the real deal and this is DT at its best!

That is the statement it's making, and it's not inherently disrespectful towards anyone.

[chrisbDTM]

The days are eternal until 9-24 (the album will be leaked a week before that date, anyway).

Not sure how I feel about this new guy.

i mean we can keep pretending that it doesn't happen. but he's right. that's what happens these days

but FYI LBC. you can't talk about it or of it when it inevitably does leak

[wolven74]

We keep seeing that word. I do not think it means what we think it means.

[sueño]

It's "inconceivable" to some... 

[wolven74]

Slightly off topic. Bosk, any idea when DTFs look will change for DT12?




Let me guess.....





.....SOON?.....





 

[Laich21DT]

It's "inconceivable" to some... 

You keep using that word, I'm not sure if means what you think it means... 

Anyway, back on topic. Can't wait for news about the North American tour, since I plan to fork up the $$ for the meet-and-greet this time. Also, I wouldn't be too upset if there wasn't a single released prior to the album being released, although I think there will be. Last time, I listened to OTBOA and the snippets from BITS and BAI probably fifty times a piece, and when I finally listened to the album, it diminished my enjoyment of those parts.

[wolven74]

I'd be ok without a single, but I would like just one snippet. Just a little tease is ok.