Haha, I really do appreciate the help!
1994 is the latest, which makes me 8, my sister 9, my younger brother 2. If it was taped (possible), then it was probably something for my sister and/or I, or my parents. Probably the latter, if the reason why I don't remember the rest is because I pulled out the blank cassette and said, "wrong movie".
Genre wise, it could have been a western, period drama, action, or family (emphasizing conservative values). Now that I think about it, it may have been a kid walking, not a grown man. Whoa, that realization hit me like a ton of bricks! Major nostalgia moment.