News:

DreamTheaterForums is a place for people who just don't have the time for music anymore. 

Main Menu

Your Controversial Opinions on DT

Started by Lucidity, December 17, 2012, 07:28:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Lucidity

Quote from: alirocker08 on December 23, 2012, 04:56:05 PM
Vacant is my favourite DT song.

Vacant was the very first DT song that I liked, and it's still one of my favorites. I love the celllo. Respect for anyone whose favorite DT song is Vacant.

snapple

Six Degrees is a weak album (especially Disc 2)
Octavarium is not a good song. at all. Fact.


King Postwhore

Quote from: snapple on December 23, 2012, 09:08:59 PM
Six Degrees is a weak album (especially Disc 2)
Octavarium is not a good song. at all. Fact.

Quote from: Polis on December 23, 2012, 09:19:26 PM
SFAM is bad.

AMA

Both of these are sooooooooo wrong.
"I don't like country music, but I don't mean to denigrate those who do. And for the people who like country music, denigrate means 'put down'." - Bon Newhart.

Sycsa

Without Jordan's Moog solo, Octavarium would be mediocre. Because of it, it's top 15 material.

JayOctavarium

Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 23, 2012, 04:05:46 PM
TMOLS-ITPOE2 is the best consecutive 30-minute stretch of music in DT history.


Hell Yes

TheGreatPretender

Quote from: JayOctavarium on December 24, 2012, 11:20:36 AM
Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 23, 2012, 04:05:46 PM
TMOLS-ITPOE2 is the best consecutive 30-minute stretch of music in DT history.


Hell Yes

Unless you count their live shows, in which case, I think Learning To Live + A Change of Seasons from LSFNY tops it.

The Presence of Frenemies

Quote from: TheGreatPretender on December 24, 2012, 11:39:34 AM
Quote from: JayOctavarium on December 24, 2012, 11:20:36 AM
Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 23, 2012, 04:05:46 PM
TMOLS-ITPOE2 is the best consecutive 30-minute stretch of music in DT history.


Hell Yes

Unless you count their live shows, in which case, I think Learning To Live + A Change of Seasons from LSFNY tops it.

Good call--that's close. Really wish there was an F# in LTL there though.

JayOctavarium

I am disappoint at the lack of F# but I respect the fact that he still gave us something instead of not doing anything at all

Destiny Of Chaos

My controversial opinions will be shared when I do my list on the Top 50 DT Songs. That should be sometime between 2014 and 2020.

SeRoX

Quote from: Destiny Of Chaos on December 24, 2012, 12:36:32 PM
My controversial opinions will be shared when I do my list on the Top 50 DT Songs. That should be sometime between 2014 and 2020.

You are pretty optimist.

TheGreatPretender

Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 24, 2012, 11:44:35 AM
Good call--that's close. Really wish there was an F# in LTL there though.

Yes, but I would say that the extended outro made up for it. I mean, I don't know, maybe that's the outro they play live all the time, they obviously wouldn't fade out live music, but hearing it that way was very cool.

The Presence of Frenemies

I will say I'm glad James didn't go for the C# in Crimson Sunset in LSFNY though. That note doesn't even sound good on record, so it probably would've been painful live.

JayOctavarium

Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 24, 2012, 02:24:05 PM
I will say I'm glad James didn't go for the C# in Crimson Sunset in LSFNY though. That note doesn't even sound good on record, so it probably would've been painful live.

"I will live ooooooooooooooooooon" ... -drum fill-


?

The Presence of Frenemies

Quote from: JayOctavarium on December 24, 2012, 02:27:51 PM
Quote from: The Presence of Frenemies on December 24, 2012, 02:24:05 PM
I will say I'm glad James didn't go for the C# in Crimson Sunset in LSFNY though. That note doesn't even sound good on record, so it probably would've been painful live.

"I will live ooooooooooooooooooon" ... -drum fill-


?

No, the "offbeaten traaAAAAACK"

JayOctavarium


Cedar redaC

-Triggered Snare, among other things, gives Images and Words more of a dark eighties feel. I like that a lot.
-A Dramatic Turn of Events is one of my favorites
-Awake is good, but drags on just a bit.
-Score is awesome, but I think that The Great Debate would have been cool to play with an orchestra. (Six Degrees was a great choice though.
-If I had to see Dream Theater Cover an album that they haven't done yet (and released a bootleg), it would probably be either Moving Pictures or Power Windows.
-John>John :neverusethis:

Sycsa

Quote from: Cedar redaC on December 24, 2012, 06:07:40 PM-John>John :neverusethis:
Since we're talking controversial opinions here, it should be quite obvious which John is which.

BanksD

Some of my controversial opinions

-Octavarium is easily in the top 3 of DT's best work in my book (even above the likes of Awake, ADTOE, and 6 Degrees)
-ADTOE  was a really good album on first impression but has not aged well for me
-Surrounded is DTs best piece lyrically speaking
-most of the albums released since SDOIT (save Octavarium) have all been great collections of songs that just do not work well as full albums (specifically Train of Thought and Systematic Chaos)
-Dream Theater's solos as of late (at least 75% of them) have not felt very impressive or all that innovative and have for the most part been more of the same
-Repentance is by far and away my least favorite DT song but it is probably the only one I refuse to sit through (though I will concede it has it's moments)
-FII has a lot of outright medicore songs but works amazingly as a full album


Most of these are probably not the most controversial of opinions but eh, whatever.

Ben_Jamin

Where are you now? Has Dereks best keyboard leads with DT. And is a fantastic gem.

Prophets of War is great and a well written song, MP's spoken word part could've been left off leaving the underline guitar which would've made the song way better.

The Shattered Fortress is the best AA Suite song. It does its job of summarizing and the Inventory lyrics dont bother me at all

Rattlehead

Quote from: BanksD on December 25, 2012, 07:21:17 AM
-ADTOE  was a really good album on first impression but has not aged well for me

I feel the same about the album... most of it is just bland and uninteresting to me now.

nikatapi

I don't like almost all JR synth solos, as well as his interpretations of older solos (He ruins Take The Time imo with his improvisations)

I think Metropolis Pt.2 would be much more interesting with Derek on keyboards

MP's drumming after FII was just rehashing the same parts over and over again

JP rushes his solos many times during live performances (not so much now with MM)

I liked MP's spoken part during Prophets of War

I like the triggered sound of the drums in I&W

FII has the best production among DT albums

JLB sounds great on OIALT





Lucidity

Quote from: Ben_Jamin on December 25, 2012, 07:33:26 AM
Prophets of War is great and a well written song, MP's spoken word part could've been left off leaving the underline guitar which would've made the song way better.

The Shattered Fortress is the best AA Suite song. It does its job of summarizing and the Inventory lyrics dont bother me at all

YES.

TheGreatPretender

Quote from: Lucidity on December 25, 2012, 11:31:17 AM
Quote from: Ben_Jamin on December 25, 2012, 07:33:26 AM
Prophets of War is great and a well written song, MP's spoken word part could've been left off leaving the underline guitar which would've made the song way better.

The Shattered Fortress is the best AA Suite song. It does its job of summarizing and the Inventory lyrics dont bother me at all

YES.
Third..ed...

LCArenas

#234
Metropolis Part I is in my top 20 DT songs. As in, not in the top 5, top 10 or top 15. Top 20; And Not as good as the majority of songs in I&W.

I'm ready to die.



Also:
The Ministry of Lost Souls is the best song on SC, and it would be one of the best DT songs ever if it wasn't for the overlong instrumental section
I don't like to listen to Outcry just because of the song's ending. It fits so bad I don't like to hear the entire song because I know how bad it's going to end.
Never Enough would be a good song if it wasn't for the intro and James' Bellamyesque singing in the verses.
ADTOE has aged well after a year, and that's something I can't say about SC or BC&SL.
People should appreciate Bombay Vindaloo and the Another Hand intro to The Killing Hand more.
Eve is a beautiful song, yet I don't feel it would fit in any of DT's albums. Maybe in the ACoS EP. I feel there should be a studio version with the sound samples heard in some of the live versions and the current one without them.
Chaos in Motion is the most unnecessary album/video release in all of DT history.

Sycsa

Quote from: LCArenas on December 25, 2012, 11:46:18 AM
Chaos in Motion is the most unnecessary album/video release in all of DT history.
Isn't that, like, mainstream opinion?

SeRoX

Quote from: LCArenas on December 25, 2012, 11:46:18 AM
Chaos in Motion is the most unnecessary album/video release in all of music history.

FFY. Yeah, that's a bit harsh but can't even believe DT agreed to present it. Man, there are bootlegs better than this DVD in every way.

MoraWintersoul

Quote from: wasteland on December 23, 2012, 03:51:10 PM
Oh, yeah, my controversial opinion is that OYALT is sung quite well, and that the vocal performance doesn't diminish the awesomeness of the record nor the amount of enjoyment on my part.
Here's an ultimate one: JLB on 5YIALT > JLB on Budokan.

wasteland

I've never really compared the two, but I may agree with this (not completely sure). There were 2004 shows where James sounded better than OIALT, that's sure.

Lucidity

Here's a nice controversial opinion-- I don't give a flying kazoodle about live albums, and haven't bothered touching one of DT's live albums aside from Score, simply for the orchestra. I mean, concerts are great, and solos and whatnot can be a bit different sometimes, but live albums in general do nothing for me. Studio albums have the same materials in higher quality the exact way the artist meant for them to be. Come at me.

SeRoX

Well, this is more than a opinion but a personal choice, I guess.

Especially when you are metal/rock band with full instruments your place is the stage. That's where you can understand if they are worth enough to listen or not.

MoraWintersoul

Quote from: Lucidity on December 25, 2012, 03:08:22 PM
Here's a nice controversial opinion-- I don't give a flying kazoodle about live albums, and haven't bothered touching one of DT's live albums aside from Score, simply for the orchestra. I mean, concerts are great, and solos and whatnot can be a bit different sometimes, but live albums in general do nothing for me. Studio albums have the same materials in higher quality the exact way the artist meant for them to be. Come at me.
You just have no idea what you're missing out on :'(
I bet you hear a lot of this so I'll shut up now.

wasteland

Quote from: Lucidity on December 25, 2012, 03:08:22 PM
Here's a nice controversial opinion-- I don't give a flying kazoodle about live albums, and haven't bothered touching one of DT's live albums aside from Score, simply for the orchestra. I mean, concerts are great, and solos and whatnot can be a bit different sometimes, but live albums in general do nothing for me. Studio albums have the same materials in higher quality the exact way the artist meant for them to be. Come at me.

As the proud possessor of more than 400 DT recordings, I second Milena but I will too shut up for the same reason. It's your opinion, after all. Respect.

Lucidity

I think another reason why I don't care for live albums is that I don't like having the same songs on my iPhone twice :3 I know that's an incredibly stupid reason but it's a very strong feeling for me. I know that DT of all bands has some wonderful live shows, but live albums aren't for me.

Cedar redaC

I really liked Live at the Marquee. The production is great, the setlist is, albeit small, great and enjoyable. Plus, you get "Bombay Vindaloo", which is a great jam track. James LaBrie as absolutely killer too (he had a cold, so there are some overdubs present, but still, it's awesome).