To this day I really like Toxicity, maybe a top 50 album for me, it's heavy, it's weird, it's catchy and it has something that just grabs me.
I wanted to really like all their other stuff and for a while I thought they could hold up, but the more I listened to STA and the debut, the more bland they became and I really couldn't get into Hypnotize/Mezmerise. It seems that everything I liked about Toxicity they left out and everything that annoyed me on Toxicity was used again. It's not a general change in style it's just that those little thigns are missing.