Metallica Survivor v. I AM THE TABLE

[Rattlehead]

1. Ride The Lightning
2. The Call of Ktulu
3. Fade to Black
4. For Whom the Bell Tolls
5. Creeping Death
6. Escape
7. Trapped Under Ice
8. Fight Fire With Fire

The entire album is great, not one song I don't like on it. 6,7,8 are really close and can pretty much be swapped depending on how I feel at the moment. 

[Onno]

Master of Puppets:

Winners:
Puppetz
Sanitarium

Consolation:
Battery

Rest:
4. Orion
5. Heroes
6. Damage
7. Thingy
8. Messiah

My personal ranking:

1. Puppetz
2. Sanitarium
3. Battery
4. Damage
5. Thingy
6. Messiah
7. Orion
8. Heroes

5, 6 and 7 are interchangable I guess.

[Mladen]

My ranking:

1. Master of puppets
2. Battery
3. Disposable heroes
4. Damage inc
5. Orion
6. The Thing that should not be
7. Welcome home (Sanitarium)
8. Leper messiah

[Onno]

AJFA results:

Winners:
Blackened
One

Consolation:
Justice

Rest:
4. Dyers
    Harvie
6. Eye
7. To Live
8. Frayed Ends
9. Straw

My personal ranking:

1. One
2. Blackened
3. Harvester of Sorrow
4. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
5. ...And Justice For All
6. Eye of the Beholder
7. Shortest Straw
8. To Live Is To Die
9. Dyers Eve

Place 3-6 are pretty interchangeable though.

[Scorpion]

I would like to point out that To Live and Frayed Ends were tied as well.

Also, ranking:

1. ...And Justice for All
2. Blackened
3. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
4. One
5. Eye of the Beholder
6. Dyer's Eve
7. Harvester of Sorrow
8. To Live Is To Die
9. The Shortest Straw

I originally had them ranked differently, but I relistened for the survivor and I liked TLITD quite a lot less than I initially remembered. Great album nevertheless.

[Onno]

I would like to point out that To Live and Frayed Ends were tied as well.

Also, ranking:

1. ...And Justice for All
2. Blackened
3. The Frayed Ends of Sanity
4. One
5. Eye of the Beholder
6. Dyer's Eve
7. Harvester of Sorrow
8. To Live Is To Die
9. The Shortest Straw

I originally had them ranked differently, but I relistened for the survivor and I liked TLITD quite a lot less than I initially remembered. Great album nevertheless.

They were thrown out in the same round, yes, but Frayed had one vote more. I just threw them both out since it was so close.

[Scorpion]

Yeah, but that was the round where you forgot the time limit and after the time limit, it was a tie.

Not that it matters that much, but still.

[Mladen]

My ranking would probably look something like this:

1. One
2. ...and justice for all
3. Blackened
4. To live is to die
5. The Shortest straw
6. Dyer's eve
7. Harvester of sorrow
8. Eye of the beholder
9. The Frayed ends of sanity

Needless to say, I adore every single one of these songs. 

[Elite]

Just a thought; could you please put all the results (with full titles please ) in the OP? It makes difficult looking for them with all those personal ranking interspersed.
Thanks in advance

[Onno]

Just a thought; could you please put all the results (with full titles please ) in the OP? It makes difficult looking for them with all those personal ranking interspersed.
Thanks in advance

Good suggestion, I'll do that.

[Onno]

Results for The Black Album:

Winners
Unforgiven
Wherever I May Roam

Consolation
Nothing Else Matters


4. Sandman
5. Sad
6. Misery
7. Wolf
8. God
9. Struggle
10. Never
11. Holier
12. Tread

[Onno]

Results for Load:

Winners:
Bleeding Me
The Outlaw Torn

Consolation:
Until It Sleeps


4. King Nothing
5. Ain't My Bitch
6. The House Jack Built
7. Mama Said
8. Thorn Within
9. Hero of the Day
10. Cure
11. 2x4
12. Wasting My Hate
13. Poor Twisted Me
14. Ronnie

[Onno]

My personal ranking for Load:

1. The Outlaw Torn
2. Bleeding Me
3. Until It Sleeps
4. The House Jack Built
5. Hero of the Day
6. Ain't My Bitch
7. Wasting My Hate
8. Mama Said
9. Cure
10. King Nothing
11. Ronnie
12. Poor Twisted Me
13. 2x4
14. Thorn Within

This album was really hard for me to rate; I love it so much. Numbers 1-2 are fixed, but 3-5 are quite interchangeable; after that, numbers 6-9 can be interchanged as well. Same goes for 10-12 and 13 and 14 are fixed again. All songs are really quite close together in my rating.

[Onno]

Results for ReLoad:

Winners:
Low Man's Lyric
Fixxxer

Consolation:
Unforgiven II

4. Fuel
    Devil's Dance
6. Where The Wild Things Are
7. The Memory Remains
8. Prince Charming
9. Slither
10. Carpe Diem Baby
11. Bad Seed
12. Better Than You
13. Attitude

[Onno]

Garage, Inc. Disc 1:

1. Mercyful Fate
2. Turn the Page
3. Whiskey in the Jar
4. Astronomy
5. Sabbra Cadabra
6. Tuesday's Gone
7. It's Electric
8. Die, Die, My Darling
9. Free Speech for the Dumb
10. The More I See
11. Loverman

[Onno]

Garage, Inc. Disc 2 Results:

1. Am I Evil?
2. Breadfan
3. The Prince
4. Helpless
5. Blitzkrieg
6. Stone Cold Crazy
7. Killing Time
8. Last Caress/Green Hell
9. Too Late, Too Late
10. Stone Dead Forever
11. Damage Case
12. The Wait
13. The Small Hours
14. Overkill
15. Crash Course in Brain Surgery
16. So What

[Onno]

IMPORTANT REQUEST!

Hey guys, I have a request. In two weeks I'll be leaving for fieldwork in the Pyrenees for my study, and I won't have internet access for some 6 weeks. I'm looking for someone who wants to take over the rest of the Survivor, as I'll probably leave sometime during the Death Magnetic survivor. Please respond in this thread or PM me if you want to do it


St. Anger results:

Winners:
Frantic
The Unnamed Feeling

Consolation:
St. Anger

Rest:
4. All Within My Hands
5. Shoot Me Again
6. Some Kind of Monster
7. Sweet Amber
8. Invisible Kid
9. Dirty Window
10. My World
11. Purify

[Onno]

Update: Scorpion will be taking over the Survivor while I'm away

[Scorpion]

Alright, since I can't edit the OP, here's the final results of the all the album tournaments:

Kill 'Em All:

Winners:
The Four Horsemen
Seek & Destroy

Consolation:
3. Whiplash

Rest:

4. Jump in the Fire
5. Motorbreath
6. No Remorse
7. Hit the Lights
8. Phantom Lord
9. Metal Militia
10. Anesthesia  (Pulling Teeth)


Ride the Lightning:

Winners:
Ride the Lightning
Creeping Death

Consolation:
3. Fade to Black

Rest:

4. For Whom The Bell Tolls
5. The Call of Ktulu
6. Fight Fire With Fire
7. Trapped Under Ice
8. Escape


Master of Puppets:

Winners:
Puppetz
Sanitarium

Consolation:
Battery

Rest:
4. Orion
5. Heroes
6. Damage
7. Thingy
8. Messiah



...And Justice For All:

Winners:
Blackened
One

Consolation:
Justice

Rest:
4. Dyers
    Harvie
6. Eye
7. To Live
8. Frayed Ends
9. Straw


The Black Album:

Winners
Unforgiven
Wherever I May Roam

Consolation
Nothing Else Matters

Rest:
4. Sandman
5. Sad
6. Misery
7. Wolf
8. God
9. Struggle
10. Never
11. Holier
12. Tread

Load:

Winners:
Bleeding Me
The Outlaw Torn

Consolation:
Until It Sleeps

Rest:
4. King Nothing
5. Ain't My Bitch
6. The House Jack Built
7. Mama Said
8. Thorn Within
9. Hero of the Day
10. Cure
11. 2x4
12. Wasting My Hate
13. Poor Twisted Me
14. Ronnie

ReLoad:

Winners:
Low Man's Lyric
Fixxxer

Consolation:
Unforgiven II

Rest:
4. Fuel
    Devil's Dance
6. Where The Wild Things Are
7. The Memory Remains
8. Prince Charming
9. Slither
10. Carpe Diem Baby
11. Bad Seed
12. Better Than You
13. Attitude

Garage, Inc. Disc 1:

1. Mercyful Fate
2. Turn the Page
3. Whiskey in the Jar
4. Astronomy
5. Sabbra Cadabra
6. Tuesday's Gone
7. It's Electric
8. Die, Die, My Darling
9. Free Speech for the Dumb
10. The More I See
11. Loverman

Garage, Inc. Disc 2:

1. Am I Evil?
2. Breadfan
3. The Prince
4. Helpless
5. Blitzkrieg
6. Stone Cold Crazy
7. Killing Time
8. Last Caress/Green Hell
9. Too Late, Too Late
10. Stone Dead Forever
11. Damage Case
12. The Wait
13. The Small Hours
14. Overkill
15. Crash Course in Brain Surgery
16. So What

St. Anger:

Winners:
Frantic
The Unnamed Feeling

Consolation:
St. Anger

Rest:
4. All Within My Hands
5. Shoot Me Again
6. Some Kind of Monster
7. Sweet Amber
8. Invisible Kid
9. Dirty Window
10. My World
11. Purify

Death Magnetic

Winners:
1. All Nightmare Long
2. That Was Just Your Life

Consolation
3. The End of the Line

Rest
4. The Judas Kiss
5. Cyanide
6. The Day That Never Comes
7. Broken, Beat & Scarred
8. Unforgiven III
9. My Apocalypse
10. Suicide & Redemption

I just noticed that there are no album winners for all the other albums, but oh well.

[Scorpion]

I APOLOGISE FOR THE DELAY HERE ARE THE RESULTS OF THE CONSOLATION FINALS UP SHORTLY

Consolation

1. Battery
2. Fade to Black
3. ...And Justice for All
4. Nothing Else Matters
5. Whiplash
6. Until It Sleeps
7. The End of the Line
8. The Unforgiven II
9. St. Anger

Finalists

The Four Horsemen
Seek and Destroy
Ride the Lightning
Creeping Death
Battery
Master of Puppets
Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
Blackened
One
The Unforgiven
Wherever I May Roam
Bleeding Me
The Outlaw Torn
Low Man's Lyrics
Fixxxer
Frantic
The Unnamed Feeling
That Was Just Your Life
All Nightmare Long

[Onno]

FINAL RESULTS

To continue Scorpion's pun series: Master's life was out of season.

1. One
2. Master of Puppets
3. Blackened
4. Creeping Death
5. Battery
6. Ride the Lightning
7. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
8. The Four Horsemen
9. The Unforgiven
10. Bleeding Me
11. Seek & Destroy
12. Wherever I May Roam
13. The Outlaw Torn
14. That Was Just Your Life
15. All Nightmare Long
16. Low Man's Lyric
17. Fixxxer
18. The Unnamed Feeling
19. Frantic

[Mladen]

Nice top 5. 

Thanks for running this, man.