- ITPOE1: It's okay. It doesn't really grab me, but I can't think of anything wrong with it.
- Forsaken: Lousy chorus, but the rest is really really good.
- CM: MP backing vocals are lame at points, but overall an extremely solid song.
- TDEN: There comes a point when wacky is just too wacky. There's not much rhyme or reason to the melodies or rhythms apart from the chorus.
- Repentance: Goes on way too long and those vocal harmonies aren't good enough to compensate. Everything before the long outro is good though.
- POW: Worst song ever.
- TMOLS: There are some awesome parts of this song ("I used my freedom to protect you") but there's some drawbacks. I don't like the bombastic intro for a ballad, the uncalled-for instrumental section, and the extended outro.
- ITPOE2: Amazing. Everything blows me away. I especially love the chanting section with the chugging guitar underneath. I guess the instrumental section is eh, and I'm not into the Mario sounds, but everything else is brilliant.
ANTR: One of the best DT intros there is. It's perfect up until the end of Beautiful Agony, and then it gets old real fast.
AROP: The riff isn't that cool. James is great, but that's about it. Nothing special here.
Wither: Never really got this one. The guitar tone is great but this song doesn't cover any new territory at all. It's okay, I guess.
TSF: Used to love it. Instrumentally, it's terrific. That solo at the end is one of JP's best. Unfortunately the lyrics are, in my opinion, the worst lyrics of any DT song.
TBOT: Actually not that bad. It's sentimental and can get corny at times, but if I place myself in MP's shoes, it's really a heart-warming song.
TCOT: Don't love it as much as I used to. The intro is, of course, awesome, as is the outro. Everything else is pretty lame though.
So, the verdict from me is that these albums aren't that good, although there are a few shining moments on each. They simply don't hold a candle to IAW, SFAM, SDOIT, and FII.