I enjoy SDOIT, but that's really it.
I rarely listen to disc 1 and disc 2 is pretty cool to break out from time to time, but even when the album first came out, i was like "ok, that's cool, they are trying different stuff", but I wasn't ever like "OH MY GOD!! this is amazing!".
The only albums that made me go "Oh my god that's amazing" on the first listen, are I&W, SFOM and ADTOE.