I know many of you visit The Breakdown Room. Just got the e-mail about its closing. Sad day, but that forum sure accomplished a lot.
Link: https://www.anybodylistening.net/breakdownroom/index.php?topic=5366.msg124993#new
This is nothing but pure speculation on my part, but I can't help but wonder: Was this perhaps part of the settlement? The owner of the Brakedown Room was not a party to the lawsuit, so of course, he would not have to agree to anything. But I could perhaps envision a scenario along the lines of the Tates asking the the band request that Samsara shut the site down as part of the settlement, and if both the band and Samsara ultimately thought that that was in the band's best interest...who knows? Certainly within the realm of possibility. But, again, I am only speculating.
Given how you make your living, bosk1, I would have thought you'd be a bit more responsible than throwing out ridiculous speculation, particularly when you have the ability to straight-up ask me what the deal was. But since you didn't bother to do that, I'll go ahead and put it out there for you:
Emphatically -- NO, closing The Breakdown Room was never a part of a settlement. First, I'm not a party to the lawsuit. Second, had that been something requested by the Tates, and the band (Michael, Eddie and Scott) asked me to do it, I would NOT have agreed to it. I would never concede anything to Geoff Tate. Ever. Had that request even been made of me, I would have posted it publicly for everyone to see. The Breakdown Room is a symbol of integrity, and I wouldn't break that for anyone.
The reasons for me shutting down The Breakdown Room are as I stated before --
https://www.anybodylistening.net/breakdownroom/index.php?topic=5366.msg124961#msg124961And there's also this --
https://www.anybodylistening.net/breakdownroom/index.php?topic=5372.0 That really sums it up entirely. A personal decision after 10 years beating the drum...and winning. I accomplished what I set out to do with the forum. It goes out at the top of its game. Just the way I wanted it, on my own terms. For those of you that are football fans, think Jim Brown or Barry Sanders.
There is so much more great music to enjoy and frankly, I'm glad to be moving on from leading a forum. I can be just a fan again and so some other things I have wanted to do.
So to reiterate, your speculation is completely off the mark and inaccurate and could have been avoided had you simply just asked.
B