Why don't people like the title?
1. It's a cliche. To me, album titles should have at least some semblance of originality. Whereas this title is a phrase which has appeared in a billion oldschool mystery novels. I wouldn't mind if they included it as a line in a song somewhere, but to title the whole album that? It's just weak to me.
2. I was personally hoping DT11 wouldn't be drenched in MP references, and it seems to me that the title indicates it will be. The idea that they coincidentally came up with this title without thinking of the drummer switch is too big a coincidence for me to swallow.
3. It seems to scream, 'Hey, look at us, we're moving in a new direction!" If they are moving in a new direction, good for them, but... like, I also wouldn't like an album called 'Really Good Stuff.' Sure, I'd like an album to
contain really good stuff, but I don't want the title to scream so obviously about it.
It probably doesn't help that cool titles like Geometry of the Void were being discussed on DTF, either. I had high expectations.
And for the record, I don't have any problems with the song titles themselves. Except track 2.