OMRTS is weird for me. I really love most of the songs individually (including the often-maligned Diamond In The Witch House), but putting it all together, something about it doesn't quite hit for me.
EOS though is the opposite. I can point to Precious Stones or Scorpion Breath as being clear lowlights for me, & others like Steambreather or Roots Remain work better in the album context, but listening to it in full has a really captivating tone & I'm always in awe by the time it ends.
That said, I think Cold Dark Place tops them both by a landslide. How those songs got cut from the respective albums is beyond me.