I've heard the album maybe 10 times now, and while it's still good, the last few listens have given me the impression that the album is not gonna do anything more for me. Like, I've given it an 8, but I don't hear any new things or potential for it to become something higher than that.
While I like this more than The Hunter, the last two albums have been more "catchy Mastodon", and that's cool and all, but for me, albums like Leviathan, Crack the Skye and Blood Mountain have perhaps a bit more staying power. I can still hear new and exciting things in those albums.