A few years isn't much.
I think I reached somewhere along 1,7k-1,8k plays with Oceansize within 4-5 months, which is a pretty high number.
Giving something a rest for a year or two isn't rare for me, I've done it with Opeth and Porcupine Tree, and I go after the philosophy that "Why only listen to stuff I already know, when there's so much more out there?", so I pretty much try to constantly explore new stuff.
Obviously I go back to stuff I love also, but I think it's necessary to let it rest for some time, because otherwise the magic will never come back, at least not if I've overplayed it.