Just finished listening to the 5 that were sent to me. Some good stuff there. I'm gonna drop the Great-Good-Average-Bad idea. I'm just gonna award points out of five.
1-Total miss
2-Some redeeming qualitites but not something I really care for
3-Average to above average
4-Headturning
5-Mindblowing
Bands that get a 1 or a 2 can be reused...but other than that, no band repeats.
Of the five I listened to, I gave out two 3's, one 4, one 1, and one 5. I can't tell you who got what, until the round is over.