Awake is, to me, the most awkward Dream Theater album. As a whole it just feels incomplete, like I wanted something bigger. Perhaps it is because it's an album with no real epic (and I don't count Scarred or A Mind Beside Itself). However, since Awake is sort of unconventional and moody it finds a strong cult following here on DTF.
First there are the "A-rank" songs. Erotomania, Voices, and The Silent Man are a brilliant combination, but unfortunately they are awkwardly placed in the middle of the album. Lifting Shadows is lovely. Space-Dye Vest is a tossup song, but I love it. I don't think it works well as a closer though.
Then there are the "B-rank" songs. 6:00 is a great opener and totally groovy but gets old by the last minute or two. Lie is a great rocker up there with Constant Motion, but vocally and lyrically I think it's somewhat painful. Scarred is great in the first half, but after the "do you feel" section it is horrible. I would much prefer an ending akin to how they did it in Once in a Livetime.
Then there are the "C-rank" songs. Caught in a Web has a group of people that love it, but to me it seems jumbled and muddy. Innocence Faded is my least favorite on the album--I always felt the song was too bright and top heavy (does anyone know if it is in a major key?). The Mirror is a weird song with a group of people that love it to death, but for me it's too one-dimensional.
To me, there are some wonderful DT moments, but no song is truly outstanding (except for maybe Voices), and there are some really bad songs. All this combined makes for an incredibly inconsistent album.
It used to be my fave too....but after I started analyzing it, it just isn't as mind blowing as I thought it was.