Everything I'm typing is just for speculation.
[Flame shield ON]
Mangini certainly impacted DT enough to win over all of the other guys who auditioned. I hope they move in a great direction with this new album, however I view Mangini as a bit cliché compared to Marco/Wildoer.
When discussing the choice of Marco/Wildoer/Mangini in EP3, JP alone seemed to give Wildoer the axe, without really giving much of a reason, other than "he wasn't on the same psychic level." That is fine, but then what of Minneman/Mangini? What made Marco not the right choice of the two? While watching Marco, I was really starting to feel confident that if he was chosen, we would get a younger, fresher, different approach to DT for the next album. I didn't really have those same idea's when watching Mangini audition. Marco/Wildoer felt like a different pair of shoes, so to speak, on the band. Mangini
feels like same brand of shoe, just a bit different style; the 'safe' choice, without a lot of variation.
The next album will be excellent (i'm sure), Mangini will prove to be the best fit, and I will be wrong about everything above that I just typed. But for some reason I can't shake some of the suspicion about this.