They basically called his bluff after the whole “I want a break situation”
That's not accurate at all. From what we heard from both DT and MP, the band said they wanted him to stay involved and to work with them on the next album. That isn't "calling his bluff." Again, even MP doesn't see it that way. So there is no basis for fans to revise history in that regard.
"Calling his bluff" is how I read the situation.
Are saying that they wanted MP to do the album, but they'd tour with a fill in drummer? Are you sure it's not a case of "We'd love for you to stay.....(not really).."
No, I'm saying they wanted MP to do the album and tour. But he said no.
So..
Band-"Even though you think the band should take a break, we don't think so, and we still want you to do the album and the tour"
MP-" I think we need a break"
Band-"Well we don't think so"
MP-"Then I have to leave"
Band-"Well we wish you wouldn't but if that's your choice so be it. We are going to continue."
I mean, if you are alluding that Dream Theater has told you differently, then by all means, please share, unless it was told to you confidentially. I believe JP has always said the right, positive spin responses publicly, and likely privately to you. There is no way that he will ever say that they were glad he left.