Am I an idiot for not liking Beatles/John Lennon while at the same time having loads of respect for the songwriting and impact they had on modern music?
No, but when you come into a thread that is a dedication to the man who is deceased and crap on the music he and his bandmates made, then, yes, you are an idiot.
Note: I mean the general "you," not you specifically.
And as a point of reference, I don't like Pantera, but you don't see me going into the Dimebag thread and making stupid remarks, do you?
But I am sure someone will find a way again to spin this like we have a problem with those who don't like the Beatles.