Well, Alyssa (#1) really is not very good. She's missing all of the 32nd notes in the fills. Plus shes not all that hot.
Lux (#3) is not too bad. Not a lot of technique, but she can play. However, she's using an Onyx snare head, which is a terrible choice. Yeah, it looks cool, but it pretty much has zero tone.
Emmanuelle (#2) is incredible. She's cute, and shes really talented. She could give me a run for my money. My vote goes to her.