Honestly, while I loved the album when I picked it up, I really could give a rats ass about it now.
I think myself and most people are much more fond of the "idea" of an Eminem who's cleaned up and ready to kick ass than the so-called "recovery" we're presented with on, well, "Recovery."
Not that the album doesn't have it's great moments, but it does seem like Eminem's still in the gutter for most of it. And when he's not, he's cringe-inducingly optimistic "The days are cold, living without youuuuuu."
Moreover, Mathers can't focus on one topic long enough to make a consistent artistic statement. Though, as I'm sure he'd admit, he's not out to do that. He's just making rap records.