I hate to say it, but Wildoer's screams are the reason I never got into SI, aside from loving the first two tracks (and I don't like the verses of One More Time, despite loving that amazing chorus to death). I listened to the album a few times at first, and the screams put me right off. They were just overwhelming.
I'm not a fan of them either, but apart from the two songs where he did the verses, I didn't mind them, because usually, they were either underneath the vocals, or just a couple of lines here and there. I definitely liked them better than MP's "Brothahood!" on AROP and some of the other stuff he did on BC&SL.
I didn't. I've never had a problem with MP's backups, I think they worked well. But I thought the growled verses on SI were far too much, and detracted from the songs, and the album. It's much more than what DT ever had. I haven't even felt like going back and giving another chance to the songs without growls, because I don't enjoy the album experience.
But One More Time is seriously one of my favourite choruses ever though.
I agree with aprilethereal that the screams have improved. As soon as I heard those deep growls on Agony, I was one happy camper. They're used in the exact same context as on One More Time, but I just enjoy them a lot more on IR.
It's seemingly a small difference, but it's made a big difference for me. IR continues to grow on me, and I think it's a really strong album.
I couldn't see this being posted:
Peter Wildoer tracking drums for James LaBrie
Love the acoustic sound from the kit.
Watched them the other day. It makes me appreciate his drumming a lot. I love his cymbal work during the fills.