I enjoy Mullmuzzler 2 over Keep It To Yourself.
I do like the way both albums have a sort of late 90's sound to it, in the terms of what styles of music were around at the time, more so Keep It To Yourself.
It wasn't until the label changed the name to James LaBrie when the sound began to lean to more metal. I think, it's just what was selling at the time, and having LaBrie sing songs closer to the Dream Theater style would sell more records as well. Wouldn't it be funny if the label itself was responsible for the Octavarium album leak fiasco, as a means to utilize and take advantage of downloading to draw attention to how similar LaBrie's solo album is to Dream Theaters sound (The intro to Crucify begins like A Change of Seasons, which I find interesting. And funnily enough, also sounds a bit like the intro to Untethered Angel). Which is unlike his past 2 albums.