Waking the Fallen is by a long way the weakest of those three.
Also, am I missing something on the M. Shadows having an annoying voice thing? I mean, ok he used to (heard the debut the other day, he sounded horrible), but he's been having vocal coaching since City of Evil and I think he has a really powerful and versatile voice. Do people continue to make the comments because of what he used to sound like, rather than how he sounds now?