2. Reckoner - This was a major surprise.. After all the fuss when In Rainbows came out due to the whole "pay what you like thing", when I got down to listening, I was simply expecting polished versions of the songs that had previously been showcased live. I wasn't too bothered about hearing this song in particular, since a song called "The Reckoner" already existed, and to be honest, it wasn't that great. Thankfully, it wasn't the same song. This was an instant classic for me, and it has remained so. After HTTT (not that it's bad at all), I honestly didn't think they could craft such a song again.. it's a stunner, particularly when the strings kick in on the final chorus.