I'm on my third spin through the record. Alter Bridge is my favorite active band, and has been for about a decade now, and I'm not sure how to judge this one.
I've found songs growing on me more and more with each listen. The title track, Clear Horizon, Wouldn't You Rather, Dying Light, and In the Deep resonate so far as the highlights, although there are a couple of others that have the potential to join them.
But as a total album...I just don't know yet. I consider Blackbird to be their high point, both as a song, and as a record. AB III is probably my next favorite based on the fact my favorite songs from that record are just so killer to me, that it kind of masks the fact there is some filler to me on that record. But Walk the Sky is, at least to my ears, very different than the rest of the AB catalog. Some of the synth gives them a Muse-like vibe at time. And while I like Muse, I don't LOVE Muse. So, I'm just not sure where Walk the Sky ranks as a record. It's early.
But the overwhelming feeling on this one is that I need to give it time and dig into it lyrically. I do like the fact the songs seem to breathe a bit more. They really focused on atmosphere to me, which I like. That has been missing to my ears on the last couple records, with a couple of songs being exceptions.
I'm not going to get deep into the mixing/production stuff. I've said repeatedly that I really think they need to break away from Elvis and try something new, and was hoping this would be the album they did it. No dice. But overall, I think Walk the Sky is a good record, with the potential to be very good. I don't think it'll near the top of my rankings, but already sits ahead of The Last Hero (I really only listen to Show Me a Leader, My Champion, and Cradle from the Grave from that album), which unfortunately suffered by all the songs being so in your face loud, it just washed the dynamics out. At least Walk the Sky seems to have addressed that a little.
Anyway, time will tell what repeated listens will unveil with Walk the Sky. I dig it, but it's different for sure, which if I recall is one of the major complaints some have had about AB -- about stuff sounding the same. This doesn't. Looking forward to seeing some of the tunes live. That always brings a new perspective.