DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: KevShmev on October 30, 2021, 01:42:53 PM
-
Let's view these all of pieces of work for the sake of this poll (instead of songs, suites, whatever).
Vote for your 3 favorites.
I am going with:
A Mind Beside Itself suite (Erotomania, Voices, The Silent Man)
A Change of Seasons
Octavarium
-
8V
TCOT
ACOS
-
Octavarium
Illumination Theory
ITPOE 1 & 2
-
I went with SDOIT, the Twelve-Step Suite, and Octavarium.
I like ACOS, and it might be been my third pick but I've really enjoyed the 12SS quite a bit since it wrapped up 12 years ago. In fact, I listened to my personal mix of it just last night!
-Marc.
-
ITPOE 1 & 2
I didn't know there were two ITPOE's.
;D
-
ACOS
AMBI
SDOIT
-
AMBI
6DOIT
Octavarium
-
1. Octavarium
2. Six Degrees Disc 2
3. The Count of Tuscany. Ah Ah Ah !!
-
Octavarium
Illumination Theory
ITPOE 1 & 2
That's my 3.
-
A Mind Beside Itself
A Chance of Seasons
Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
-
A change of seasons
A mind beside itself
In the presence of enemies
-
A Change of Seasons
Octavarium
Illumination Theory
-
A Change of Seasons
In the Presence of Enemies Parts 1 and 2
Octavarium
And it isn't really close for me.
-
This was pretty easy. ACOS is my favorite DT song. SDOIT is my #3 DT album, primarily on the strength of disc 2. I love 8VM as a whole, and particularly the second half of it.
After those, I'd go with IT, AMBI and TCOT, in that order.
I have almost no affinity for ANTR or ITPOE, and TDS and Repentance make the 12SS largely unlistenable, even though I like TGP and Root (TSF is just ok).
-
8V
ITPOE
TCOT
I also know this is probably a controversial statement, but I put INPOE over Change Of Seasons. :omg: :omg:
-
A Change Of Seasons (My favorite epic)
A Mind Beside Itself
Octavarium
-
Tough call. ACoS and TCoT are easy picks for me - just gonna have to think about what my third choice will be....
-
Twelve Step suite by far, followed by both a Mind by Itself and the second disc of Six Degrees.
The Twelve Step suite as a whole is probably what I love about Dream Theater the most. So many chills, manic riffs, metal phrases and still so vunerable.
-
IT, SDOIT, ITPOE for me.
-
Twelve Step suite by far, followed by both a Mind by Itself and the second disc of Six Degrees.
The Twelve Step suite as a whole is probably what I love about Dream Theater the most. So many chills, manic riffs, metal phrases and still so vunerable.
"Vulnerable" or "venerable"? I mean either work, just making sure. 😅
But yeah, I'm surprised fewer people are speaking out for the Twelve-Step Suite. It's one of my favorite things the band has ever done and I'm glad Mike was able to put it all out there before he left the band. When I first discovered the band, I didn't really know that TGP and TDS had subsections or that they were related, but when I started looking more into them online in 2004 or so, I discovered that they were part of a suite that Mike was writing lyrics for album-by-album and so my excitement to hear the next song/parts grew with the next 3 albums as they came out. I love how each song is just different enough from each other to continue being entertaining to my ears. I also really liked how each of the 12 steps start with "Re-" in their titles, and how each successive song referenced or used a riff from the previous song, with the final song taking parts from across the suite to wrap things up.
Such a shame we will never see Mike and the rest of DT perform it all live like he would've wanted. Makes me wish I could've gone to his Shattered Fortress shows!
-Marc.
-
lol Marc, I mean vulnerable indeed. That suite has so many layers and although it’s hard for me to dig my way through Repentance, I love everything else on it. The prayer at the end of the Shattered Fortress is probably the part I can relate to the most.
So beautiful.
-
Octavarium
Illumination Theory
A Change of Seasons
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
-
Going with
A Change of Seasons
Erotomania / Voices / The Silent Man
Octavarium
it surprises me to not see so many votes for the AA Suite.
-
Octavarium
Illumination Theory
ITPOE 1 & 2
That's my 3.
Same here I think, was tough to leave out ACOS though.
-
ITPOE 1 & 2
I didn't know there were two ITPOE's.
;D
There isn't. There's Part 1 and no Part 2. :police:
-
A change of seasons
A mind beside itself
In the presence of enemies
Voted first then saw this. My votes too. I really wanted to include votes for #4 and #5.
Why isn't Scenes on the list? Probably just dominate the poll, huh? Then the inverse for TA (although I like it)
-
[Why isn't Scenes on the list? Probably just dominate the poll, huh? Then the inverse for TA (although I like it)
It's an entire album, just like TA. Neither of them are really a "piece" the way that this thread is intending.
I would go with ACOS, 8VM, and AMBI.
I
-
OCTAVARIUM
A CHANGE OF SEASONS
SDOIT
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
You’re half right! It’s the best song on their absolute worst album by some distance.
My first two picks are pretty easy and they are ACOS and TCOT. For the third one I have eventually settled on Illumination Theory.
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
I just had to +1 this.
-
ACOS
IT
8VM
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
You’re half right! It’s the best song on their absolute worst album by some distance.
My first two picks are pretty easy and they are ACOS and TCOT. For the third one I have eventually settled on Illumination Theory.
Well, you're both half right! It probably is the best song on the album, though not by much, but it's neither their best nor worst album. 8V is a top three or four album, though, and I for one would love to see a little acknowledgement of that style in the band's current music.
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
I just had to +1 this.
Because it's obviously correct. :hat
-
Sorry wrong post.
-
I used to think A Mind Beside Itself was amazing. Then I realized it was just Voices that was amazing. Erotomania is a hot mess, and The Silent Man is just all right. I definitely prefer SDOIT disc 2, Octavarium, and ACOS....although ACOS is kind of a hot mess, too.
-
Octavarium winning and rightly so.
Their best song on their best album. :hat
You’re half right! It’s the best song on their absolute worst album by some distance.
That's not true. Octavarium isn't on The Astonishing (and, if it were, that album would be quite a bit better).
-
I wanted to pick the 12 step suite, but I just can't stand Repentance at all, and The Root of All Evil just doesn't fit in the theme at all IMO, but The Glass Prison, This Dying Soul, and The Shattered Fortress are STELLAR....