DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
General => Polls/Survivors => Topic started by: LordCost on February 07, 2017, 01:29:33 PM
-
Main thread with the complete results: https://www.dreamtheaterforums.org/boards/index.php?topic=49212.msg2257650#msg2257650
Round 10 results
Used : 6 votes
The Perfect Element: 5 votes
Idioglossia: 3 votes
Another close round with an elimination with 6 votes against 5! So Used and Her Voices goes to consolations and The Perfect Element and Idioglossia are in the finals.
1-
2-
3- Used
4- Her Voices
5- In The Flesh
6- King Of Loss
7- Ashes
8- Reconciliation
9- Song For The Innocent
10- Morning On Earth
11- Dedication
12- Falling
My ranking:
1- Idioglossia
2- The Perfect Element
3- Used
4- In The Flesh
5- King Of Loss
6- Her Voices
7- Ashes
8- Morning On Earth
9- Dedication
10- Song For The Innocent
11- Reconciliation
12- Falling
-
My first actual vote, since the only song I place above the others is Idioglossia. So amazed it came this far, don't expect it to win.
-
Of course Idioglossia is going to win. People love that song.
My ranking:
1. King of Loss
2. In the Flesh
3. The Perfect Element
4. Idioglossia
5. Her Voices
6. Used
7. Song for the Innocent
8. Reconciliation
9. Ashes
10. Morning on Earth
11. Dedication
12. Falling
EDIT :facepalm: I voted for TPE, but I meant to vote Idioglossia. Stupid phone, I clicked the wrong one
-
Idioglossia is the best song here, so I'm glad that it's winning this.
The Perfect Element.
-
My vote is likely not going to matter anyway, but I prefer TPE by a slight margin, mainly because of the verses and because I've seen them play it live twice and it absolutely slays live. While Idioglossia is more 'flashy', for lack of a better word, the title track is more coherent in my eyes. I like both tracks a lot though, see my ranking above (though neither is in my top 2).
King of Loss is, by far, the best song though.
-
title track, easy vote lol
-
I have to admit, I am a bit surprised. Idioglossia is my favorite song in general, but rarely do people ever talk about it. People talk a lot about lots of other tracks, so I just assumed it wasn't anyone's favorite. Crazy times.
-
Idioglossia is the most proggy one with that intro but it's far from being the best song here, imo.
-
yeah but how about
the intense verses
the ashes reprises
dat guitar solo
dat, goddamn, outrooooo
-
Just for funsies, here's how I'd rank the album.
1. Idioglossia
2. King of Loss
3. Falling/The Perfect Element
4. Song for the Innocent
5. Used
6. Her Voices
7. Ashes
8. Reconciliation
9. In the Flesh
10. Morning on Earth
11. Dedication
-
Title track.
-
Idioglossia
Used was the first PoS song that I ever heard, and is still my favorite. Her Voices is my 3rd favorite.
-
Scorp why the fuck is In the Flesh so low on your list? :(
-
Scorp why the fuck is In the Flesh so low on your list? :(
Because every other song is better. :) I like it a lot still.
-
but she will flyyyyy
I think In the Flesh is amazing. A shame that it didn't make the finals. I'm more bummed about KoL though. I won't stop mentioning that until this survivor is over :lol
-
The Perfect Element
-
Idioglossia is a worthy #1, was expecting the title track which I always thought was overrated and not their best epic. This makes up for the indefensible early elimination of King of Loss.