DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: Blind Faythe on October 26, 2016, 06:50:24 PM
-
I was just remembering how good of a band Dream theater was and I wanted to take the time to properly listen to a Dream Theater song and I decided to try "A Nightmare to Remember." At first, like any other song, I just went over it, not really thinking about the song, but when I took the time to read the lyrics and try paying attention to the song, it really changed my perspective.
My first perspective was that it was an average song with good melodies here and good melodies there and that oh so horrifying vocal part by Mike Portnoy. I simply dismissed as any other song.
The next time I heard it, I just realized the beauty of it. Thankfully, I have a prog equipped family and I would sometimes ask them about the whole nature of "progressive" music and my dad said that he was in a band when he was young and Dream Theater had been a huge influence. I feel like the song is very beautiful throughout, though it kind of slips out in the ending. I love how the song shifts from an aggressive verse to a really calming, almost relaxing part. I absolutely adore the vocal harmonies that go on through there and man, I can feel the song, I can feel the pain John Petrucci went through. The instrumental section after is great, but it slips out near the end. Even though it slips out, I never get bored and the song keeps my interest. The blast beat in the end sounds so cool and the drum outro makes my heart race every time.
That's all I wanted to say. :)
-
I consider that song (and the whole album to some degree) perhaps the biggest missed opportunity in DT's catalog. There are so many fantastic moments but there's also a lot of clutter that really drags it down.
-
I have always like that song. A combination of heavy stuff and prog and melodic other parts. In fact the whole album is a pretty good one for me.
-
The song is good but not perfect. I remember seeing a live video of it: the dramatic intro, the heavy part kicking in and getting the crowd excited, the mellow part in the middle that changed the atmosphere... up until that section the song is flawless. It's what comes next that's a bit more meandering and should have been more concise, and reworked cutting the fat.
The infamous "Day after day" part mainly has the weird contrast of music vs lyrics... I get there had to be the portion explaining how no one died but "everyone survived, groarrrrrr!!!!" wasn't the best option.
-
I will just say that my opinion remains unchanged.
But I'm glad you like it.
-
I will just say that my opinion remains unchanged.
Same here. I still think it is all kinds of awesome. :D
-
That blast beat actually sounds so awkward. :lol
-
That's their attempt to go death metal with those "growls" and blast beat. Please, stick to program.
-
That blast beat actually sounds so awkward. :lol
Yeah, Portnoy didn't quite have it down at that time, unfortunately. One of a few flaws that keep it from being just about a perfect song.
That's their attempt to go death metal with those "growls" and blast beat. Please, stick to program.
I will pass your instructions on to the band. I am sure they will be glad for the help. But I suspect they will also request that you better educate yourself as to what growls are.
-
That's their attempt to go death metal with those "growls" and blast beat. Please, stick to program.
I will pass your instructions on to the band. I am sure they will be glad for the help. But I suspect they will also request that you better educate yourself as to what growls are.
:lol
We talked about this before about the growls. That's why I pit it in parenthesis. I know that's not a real growl because on the Portnoy appreciation thread, you said that was not a growl and even if they did a growl you wouldn't like it. Sorry for the confusion.
-
My 2nd favorite Dream Theater song. Absolutely love every part of it. :metal :metal :metal
-
That's their attempt to go death metal with those "growls" and blast beat. Please, stick to program.
True. I like the song minus those elements.
-
That's their attempt to go death metal with those "growls" and blast beat. Please, stick to program.
This is a skewed perception of death metal if I've ever seen one
-
Agreed. DT skewed the perception.
-
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
-
To each their own, I guess.
For me, it seemed out of place. With Rudess' continuum, it did not sound on beat. Its like multiple lightning strikes in a dang second
-
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
It would have been cool, but the timing was off.
-
(https://i583.photobucket.com/albums/ss272/kingshmegland/67036717_zpsgqribkxx.jpg) (https://s583.photobucket.com/user/kingshmegland/media/67036717_zpsgqribkxx.jpg.html)
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
I would have been cool, but the timing was off.
-
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
I would have been cool, but the timing was off.
Peter Wildoer made the blast beat badass in his audition.
-
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
I would have been cool, but the timing was off.
Peter Wildoer made the blast beat badass in his audition.
Yup. I thought Roddy did as well (even despite the sound quality of his footage).
-
I have always like that song. A combination of heavy stuff and prog and melodic other parts. In fact the whole album is a pretty good one for me.
This.
MP's vocals aren't very good, but it's not nearly as bad as this forum makes it seem IMO and those 15 seconds hardly drags down the 15 minute song.
-
Listening to the album now. Yup, it definitely sounds like Dream Theater. One of the many reasons I like it.
-
I have always like that song. A combination of heavy stuff and prog and melodic other parts. In fact the whole album is a pretty good one for me.
This.
MP's vocals aren't very good, but it's not nearly as bad as this forum makes it seem IMO and those 15 seconds hardly drags down the 15 minute song.
Totally!
-
I have also always loved this tune. Back in 2009 I was 16 and couldn't wait for the album to come out. Next to The Astonishing, probably my most anticipated album ever. Then some radio DJ mistakenly played Nightmare and Rite on his radio show, not knowing he wasn't allowed to. A friend of mine recorded it with some program and I listened to it 24/7 for about two weeks.
I always liked the MP vocals and his blast beat. Possible in the Top 5 of all my DT songs.
-
I always liked the MP vocals and his blast beat.
Overall, I like them too. But there are unfortunate problems with both. The vocals they chose are great, and of the three options, were easily the best choice. But the "rooooooooaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrr!" at the end is silly and doesn't fit. With the blast beat, that is a great place to have done it. And it almost sounds great. But the timing is slightly off--just enough to the point that it is noticeable and jarring.
-
(https://i583.photobucket.com/albums/ss272/kingshmegland/67036717_zpsgqribkxx.jpg) (https://s583.photobucket.com/user/kingshmegland/media/67036717_zpsgqribkxx.jpg.html)
I thought the blast beat was cool :)
It would have been cool, but the timing was off.
??? This makes zero sense.
-
I always liked the MP vocals and his blast beat.
Overall, I like them too. But there are unfortunate problems with both. The vocals they chose are great, and of the three options, were easily the best choice. But the "rooooooooaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrr!" at the end is silly and doesn't fit. With the blast beat, that is a great place to have done it. And it almost sounds great. But the timing is slightly off--just enough to the point that it is noticeable and jarring.
Holy crap. That roar is just plain silly. I laugh everytime. :lol
-
If I may quote something I read once:
"...because nothing merits a ferocious metal roar quite like a religiously grateful account of a car wreck that claimed no casualties." :lol
-
:rollin
Peter Wildoer made the blast beat badass in his audition.
And, to be honest, he probably would have done the Portnoy vocal section better
-
If I may quote something I read once:
"...because nothing merits a ferocious metal roar quite like a religiously grateful account of a car wreck that claimed no casualties." :lol
Yeah, that quote really misses the point.
Peter Wildoer made the blast beat badass in his audition.
And, to be honest, he probably would have done the Portnoy vocal section better
I disagree. He does a really good screamy vocal. But that isn't really what is called for in that part of the song, much like the originally-planned growls wouldn't have really fit either.
-
:rollin
Peter Wildoer made the blast beat badass in his audition.
And, to be honest, he probably would have done the Portnoy vocal section better
I really like his vocals on JLB solo albums and I am not typically a fan of the scream/growl vocals.
-
I consider that song (and the whole album to some degree) perhaps the biggest missed opportunity in DT's catalog. There are so many fantastic moments but there's also a lot of clutter that really drags it down.
Definitely agree on this. :tup