DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: chaossystem on November 21, 2014, 06:44:17 PM
-
Okay.
Let's try this again.
Hopefully it'll be more fair this time.
-
Don't Look Past Me
-
Still missing "Where Are You Now?".
-Marc.
-
Still missing "Where Are You Now?".
-Marc.
About to say
Where Are You Now is one of my favorite's, but Don't Look Past Me takes the cake
Edit: forgot about Raise The Knife! How foolish of me! Probably would've voted that instead
-
Also missing "Eve". And if you're going to include "Another Won", why not the other 5 Majesty Demos tracks?
And why stop there - there's also "Resurrection of Ernie", "The School Song" and "Cry For Freedom"!
-Marc.
-
Also missing "Eve". And if you're going to include "Another Won", why not the other 5 Majesty Demos tracks?
And why stop there - there's also "Resurrection of Ernie", "The School Song" and "Cry For Freedom"!
-Marc.
Is there even room to put that many entries?
To be fair, Another Won has been immportalized as a Live Track on their official releases... Although if it's on a live album, along with Raise The Knife, would that make them album tracks?
Damn, so many technicalities!
-
The only one I know is Raw Dog hehe.
But I'll listen to the others before casting a vote.
-
Also missing "Eve". And if you're going to include "Another Won", why not the other 5 Majesty Demos tracks?
And why stop there - there's also "Resurrection of Ernie", "The School Song" and "Cry For Freedom"!
-Marc.
Is there even room to put that many entries?
To be fair, Another Won has been immportalized as a Live Track on their official releases... Although if it's on a live album, along with Raise The Knife, would that make them album tracks?
Damn, so many technicalities!
If we're including live tracks, then you'd also have to account for things like "Another Hand", "Bombay Vindaloo" and possibly even "Instrumedley", and maybe even jams like "The Spirit of St. Louis" and "The Oakdale Odessey".
-Marc.
-
Tough call between Raise the Knife and To Live Forever. I went with the former, but it honestly just would depend on when you happened to ask me.
And I don't care that a few tracks ended up being left off the poll. I wouldn't have voted for them anyway.
-
Daw Rog
-
Raise the Knife for sure. Top notch song.
-
eve
owait
-
Yeah, I would have been seriously torn between Raise the Knife and Eve if Eve had been on the thing.
-
Of these, definitely DLPM - the song that should've stayed on IAW.
-Marc.
-
I don't care that a few tracks ended up being left off the poll. I wouldn't have voted for them anyway.
I would have WTF
Why even do the poll if you aren't going to include them all? This is like running the poll for I&W but leaving off Another Day.
-
Raise The Knife by default. This is a pretty sad list of songs.
-
Raise the Knife, no contest.
-
To Live Forever, though I do really love the Score version of Another Won.
-
The Way it Used to Be is being beatin by Raw Dog.
(https://dancingczars.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/give-me-a-break-stossel.jpg)
-
To Live Forever, though I do really love the Score version of Another Won.
-
To Live Forever, though I do really love the Score version of Another Won.
I think To Live Forever is just ok for me. As for the second part of your statement . . . :metal
And I voted for Raise the Knife for the same reason
-
Listening to "Cover My Eyes", pretty cool song. Anyone hear a resemblance to "Burden In My Hand" by Soundgarden?
Specifically the verses of "Cover My Eyes", on the acoustic version.
I'm not a biggest fan of the non-album tracks, but I absolutely love Eve. So that's my (invisible) vote.
-
eve
owait
-
I forgot Eve.
But it has been added.
Like I said before:
There's no way I can please everybody.
I've seen other polls where I wish there were better options, as well.
I mostly went with songs that I was familiar with, or that I knew were favorites of a lot of people on here.
But I wasn't going to make the list any longer, in part because that just causes more confusion.
-
The only one I know is Raw Dog hehe.
But I'll listen to the others before casting a vote.
Really?!?! You're missing out on some really great tracks! I would be very surprised if anyone listened to these and couldn't find at least one that they really like alot.
-
To Live Forever.
God I love that song.
-
I went with Raw Dog because I do actually like to listen to it.
-
There's no way I can please everybody.
Sure there is. If you post a poll titled "What is Your Favorite Non-Album Track???" you could list ALL of the non-album tracks as options. This is not difficult, it's not like there is an infinite number of them.
I've seen other polls where I wish there were better options, as well.
So you decided to post a poll just like those? Again, it's not like you couldn't just list all of them.
I mostly went with songs that I was familiar with, or that I knew were favorites of a lot of people on here.
But I wasn't going to make the list any longer, in part because that just causes more confusion.
A complete list of options never causes confusion. I don't even understand what you are talking about.
-
There's no way I can please everybody.
Sure there is. If you post a poll titled "What is Your Favorite Non-Album Track???" you could list ALL of the non-album tracks as options. This is not difficult, it's not like there is an infinite number of them.
I've seen other polls where I wish there were better options, as well.
So you decided to post a poll just like those? Again, it's not like you couldn't just list all of them.
I mostly went with songs that I was familiar with, or that I knew were favorites of a lot of people on here.
But I wasn't going to make the list any longer, in part because that just causes more confusion.
A complete list of options never causes confusion. I don't even understand what you are talking about.
AAARRRRGGGHHHHHAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!!!!!
-
Yeah, that is what I said before I started typing.
-
goD waR
-
One thing I forgot.
The "average" Dream Theater album has eight tracks on it.
That's the main reason I didn't want the list of choices on THIS poll to be any longer than it was, so it would have the same number of options as what I consider to be "average."
I only included "The Way it Used to Be" because when I went on YouTube to hear "Don't Look Past Me," Which is a song that I know a lot of people on here love, I accidentally clicked on TWiUTB instead, and thought it sounded BETTER than DLPM, which is why I included it at the time to have an eighth song on the list.
But then people started complaining about "Eve" not being on the list, which I WOULD have included anyway, but I FORGOT about it, so when I was reminded, I added it on.
Otherwise the list would ONLY have seven or eight choices on it, instead of the nine that it now has, which is a decision that I still stand by.
-
There's no way I can please everybody.
Sure there is. If you post a poll titled "What is Your Favorite Non-Album Track???" you could list ALL of the non-album tracks as options. This is not difficult, it's not like there is an infinite number of them.
I've seen other polls where I wish there were better options, as well.
So you decided to post a poll just like those? Again, it's not like you couldn't just list all of them.
I mostly went with songs that I was familiar with, or that I knew were favorites of a lot of people on here.
But I wasn't going to make the list any longer, in part because that just causes more confusion.
A complete list of options never causes confusion. I don't even understand what you are talking about.
How many of them ARE there? I don't even have a guess.
If you feel that way about it, then why don't YOU track down all of those songs, compile a list, and start a poll or thread of your OWN about it???
-
If you don't know them, why would you start a poll about them?
-
Would have voted for Your Majesty...but there's no option for it. So Another Won, I guess.
-
If you don't know them, why would you start a poll about them?
All of the songs in this poll are the ones that I DO know.
-
If you don't know them, why would you start a poll about them?
All of the songs in this poll are the ones that I DO know.
I think what he means is, why would you start a poll that, at face values, looks like it SHOULD encompass *all* of the non-album tracks, when it only includes just the ones you personally know?
It would be like if someone came on here and posted a poll "What's your favorite DT album?" and only posted the 7 or 8 they knew, perhaps not having ever listened to WDADU or FII, or even TOT and 8VM. Including only albums they knew wouldn't really be indicative of the poll's question.
If you had worded the original poll's question as being "What is your favorite non-album DT song of these choices", then it would be less confusing. However, there are only so many DT non-album tracks that many of us here would consider including, mostly ACOS, "Raw Dog", and the 8 songs from Cleaning Out The Closet, making a total of 10 tracks, which, isn't a HUGE amount, and is less than the number of tracks on Awake, FII, SFAM and SDOIT. Many of us would also consider placing "Another Won" with its fellow Majesty Demos tracks, since that's where it originates from.
-Marc.
-
There's no way I can please everybody.
Sure there is. If you post a poll titled "What is Your Favorite Non-Album Track???" you could list ALL of the non-album tracks as options. This is not difficult, it's not like there is an infinite number of them.
I've seen other polls where I wish there were better options, as well.
So you decided to post a poll just like those? Again, it's not like you couldn't just list all of them.
I mostly went with songs that I was familiar with, or that I knew were favorites of a lot of people on here.
But I wasn't going to make the list any longer, in part because that just causes more confusion.
A complete list of options never causes confusion. I don't even understand what you are talking about.
How many of them ARE there? I don't even have a guess.
If you feel that way about it, then why don't YOU track down all of those songs, compile a list, and start a poll or thread of your OWN about it???
Here comes my favourite (not) argument in the Internet discussion ever. It's like:
- how can you say this food tastes like shit? If you feel that way about it, then why don't YOU cook instead of that restaurant chief next time?
- how can you say this music is unlistenable? If you feel that way about it, then why don't YOU go and record some album?
- how can you say this fuselage drawing is shit and not up to international standards? If you feel that way about it, then why don't YOU draw it?
Bloody pathetic.
And, eh, start a poll? It's not like DT section needs any more polls at that moment, really.
Sorry, just had to get this out.
-
If you don't know them, why would you start a poll about them?
All of the songs in this poll are the ones that I DO know.
I think what he means is, why would you start a poll that, at face values, looks like it SHOULD encompass *all* of the non-album tracks, when it only includes just the ones you personally know?
It would be like if someone came on here and posted a poll "What's your favorite DT album?" and only posted the 7 or 8 they knew, perhaps not having ever listened to WDADU or FII, or even TOT and 8VM. Including only albums they knew wouldn't really be indicative of the poll's question.
If you had worded the original poll's question as being "What is your favorite non-album DT song of these choices", then it would be less confusing. However, there are only so many DT non-album tracks that many of us here would consider including, mostly ACOS, "Raw Dog", and the 8 songs from Cleaning Out The Closet, making a total of 10 tracks, which, isn't a HUGE amount, and is less than the number of tracks on Awake, FII, SFAM and SDOIT. Many of us would also consider placing "Another Won" with its fellow Majesty Demos tracks, since that's where it originates from.
-Marc.
I tried to change the wording, but I couldn't.
-
How many of them ARE there? I don't even have a guess.
Thing is, it's really close. You're missing like 1 song. Maybe 2? (any more than that would be starting to get picky and choosing songs not everyone would even consider anyway). But the way I see it, Where are you Now is as relevant as all the songs on the list. Your Majesty is is kinda an official DT track now as it's been played live a few times and was on the original Lifting Shadows companion CD. Finally, you could debate You Or Me as a different song, it seems to be treated that way but now we're just getting padantic. :P
Anyway, tough call between Raise the Knife, To Live Forever, Eve. I'd even consider Another Won, but went with The Way it Used to Be.
For the record, imo Don't Look Past Me is probably the most boring song here. It's a kinda neat track in it's own regard, but I think that's cause it's a novelty track in the DT library. I don't listen to it very often and I don't really choose to put it on, but I'll listen if it comes on by itself. :lol
-
Im glad someone agrees with me about "the Way it Used to Be' being better than "Don't Look Past Me."
At least I'm not the ONLY one who sees it that way.
Also, I would have included "Bombay Vindaloo," but it's another one that I forgot.
-
^^^ It probably wouldn't have done very well, Bombay feels more like a somewhat incomplete Jam that doesn't quite go anywhere. It's not bad but its barely a song, or maybe I need to hear it again but that's the impression I remember having of it.
-
I wouldn't have included Bombay Vindaloo. It wasn't a song that they wrote and recorded /demoed, it was a live jam thing.
-
Voted Raise the Knife but Where are you now would have gotten my vote...
-
"Cover My Eyes" is my favorite DT song of all time, so that gets my vote. "To Live Forever" is up there too, as is "Raise The Knife" and "Eve".
-
Voted Raise the Knife but Where are you now would have gotten my vote...
love Derek's solo on that track.
-
How many of them ARE there? I don't even have a guess.
Thing is, it's really close. You're missing like 1 song. Maybe 2? (any more than that would be starting to get picky and choosing songs not everyone would even consider anyway). But the way I see it, Where are you Now is as relevant as all the songs on the list. Your Majesty is is kinda an official DT track now as it's been played live a few times and was on the original Lifting Shadows companion CD. Finally, you could debate You Or Me as a different song, it seems to be treated that way but now we're just getting padantic. :P
Anyway, tough call between Raise the Knife, To Live Forever, Eve. I'd even consider Another Won, but went with The Way it Used to Be.
For the record, imo Don't Look Past Me is probably the most boring song here. It's a kinda neat track in it's own regard, but I think that's cause it's a novelty track in the DT library. I don't listen to it very often and I don't really choose to put it on, but I'll listen if it comes on by itself. :lol
I'll take SOME of the blame for this, but:
When I first said "non-album tracks" I was thinking about ANY of DT's music that wasn't on one of their "official" full-length albums (with the exception of ACoS) in other words, anything that wasn't on the TWELVE albums that most people know about,
I wanted to include what I at least thought was a good listing of somewhat better-known songs that were NOT on any of those albums.
When I started getting told that my list of choices wasn't long or inclusive enough, I started thinking it was meant that I was supposed to include things such as the "Majesty" demos, ALL of the unreleased songs from the FII sessions, any studio recordings that are or were only available from the YtseJam web-site, fan club discs, and only GOD knows what else.
Or-to put it still ANOTHER way-I was referring to songs that were NOT on albums (Excluding live albums and the "Greatest Hit" collection) that you used to be-and sometimes still can-purchase at a any of your local record stores. Or that can be ordered from a "mainstream" online service such as Amazon.
So now I hope I've explained what I was going for, and I apologize for any and all misunderstandings.
..And YES, Hef, that means you too...
-
I would use the back of the 2006 anniversary shirt as a reference guide. It lists all the songs DT wrote from inception through 2006, so I would imagine it is a sanctioned, if not official, listing. It includes the Majesty demos, School Song, Resurrection of Ernie and even Bombay Vindaloo. It does not includes the various one-off jams, no surprise there. Anyway, thought it would help to point this out.
-
I would use the back of the 2006 anniversary shirt as a reference guide. It lists all the songs DT wrote from inception through 2006, so I would imagine it is a sanctioned, if not official, listing. It includes the Majesty demos, School Song, Resurrection of Ernie and even Bombay Vindaloo. It does not includes the various one-off jams, no surprise there. Anyway, thought it would help to point this out.
True, but those are unfinished demos and a live jam. I doubt anyone would seriously consider them as Non-album tracks. Right? I guess if they included "Bombay Vindaloo", I'm sure "Another Hand" was there as well, which isn't so much a song as it is a segue between two songs.
-Marc.
-
I would use the back of the 2006 anniversary shirt as a reference guide. It lists all the songs DT wrote from inception through 2006, so I would imagine it is a sanctioned, if not official, listing. It includes the Majesty demos, School Song, Resurrection of Ernie and even Bombay Vindaloo. It does not includes the various one-off jams, no surprise there. Anyway, thought it would help to point this out.
True, but those are unfinished demos and a live jam. I doubt anyone would seriously consider them as Non-album tracks. Right? I guess if they included "Bombay Vindaloo", I'm sure "Another Hand" was there as well, which isn't so much a song as it is a segue between two songs.
-Marc.
Another Hand IS actually on the shirt. It's placed among the I&W tracks. Whoever assembled that t-shirt (MP?) considered them DT "compositions," incomplete or otherwise.
-
Eve! What a Beautiful song!