DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
General => Archive => General Music Archives => Topic started by: senecadawg2 on October 10, 2014, 01:51:11 PM
-
I don't know what's up with the three people on top of the list, but right now we only have two roulettes running and Nekov's has been done for more than a week. So unless any of them object, I'm going to go ahead and start my thread.
I've been playing in almost every roulette recently, so this should be a nice change of pace. I'm going to do this a little differently than I did last time, and focus predominantly on older music. I was born about 20 years ago and didn't really get into intensive music-listening until I discovered DT a few years ago. Since then, music has become my most unrelenting obsession. I've discovered a ton of great bands, a lot of them here on DTF, and fully expect to keep that up. However, being so new to it all, I haven't been exposed to nearly as much old stuff. That's where this roulette comes in. I might change it up for the last couple rounds, but for the majority of this roulette, I will only accept pre-90s music.
Instead of giving you a list of off-limits bands (since most of those are more recent), I'm going to compile a list of my favorite bands. These are bands that would work if I was playing with myself but had dissociative identity disorder (picture that). A lot of these bands I've only heard one or two albums from. If that's the case, I'll identify which ones I've heard and if you think they've released stuff that is vastly different you can try sending it. I do discourage that though, simply because I want to get music that I'd be less likely to check out on my own.
Billy Joel
Black Sabbath
Bob Dylan
Bob Marley
Bob Seger
Bruce Springsteen
The Cars
Cat Stevens
The Cure (Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me & Disintegration)
Dio (Holy Diver)
Dire Straits
Electric Light Orchestra (Out of the Blue)
Eric Clapton
Fleetwood Mac
Genesis
Iron Maiden
Jethro Tull (Thick as a Brick)
John Lennon
Journey
Joy Division
King Crimson (Red & ITCOTCK)
Led Zeppelin
Marillion
Megadeth
Metallica
The Moody Blues
Neil Young
Nick Drake
Pete Townshend (Empty Glass)
Queensryche (Empire & O:M)
Quiet Riot
REO Speedwagon
Rush
Savatage
Scorpions
Steely Dan
Styx (The Grand Illusion)
Supertramp
Triumph (Just a Game)
Yes
And if you just want to get a more comprehensive (but not complete) view of what my tastes look like, here's a link to my first roulette with its list: https://www.dreamtheaterforums.org/boards/index.php?topic=40831.0 (https://www.dreamtheaterforums.org/boards/index.php?topic=40831.0)
The Players:
Dr. DTVT
Elite
jingle.boy
jjrock
kingshmegland
LieLowTheWantedMan
lonestar
Nekov
Scorpion
TAC
-
I'm not sure who is actually hosting now, but I'll definetely follow this roulette. I'd play as well if I actually knew some pre-90s music, but my musical education is definetely lacking in that regard :P ( Unless you want me to send classical music only, that is ::) )
-
EDIT: removed
-
I lost your last roulette by half a point. I demand a second chance :)
-
I hope you don't mind a young un wanting to take part?
-
Hmm I think just about all the pre-90's bands that I like are on your list :sadpanda:
Looks like I'll just be spectating this one.
-
Makin' this mah bitch, yo.
-
I'm your fogey huckleberry!
-
I hope you don't mind a young un wanting to take part?
Of course not :)
If I can get at least another 3-5 more people we'll be set, and start as soon as a slot opens up.
-
In. :)
-
^^ Good :)
Now someone bring me jingle.boy and lonestar!
-
I'm your fogey huckleberry!
:huckleberry:
I shall defend my crown!
But, as you stated in zzyz's thread, let him go first (since he's technically ahead of you on the waiting list). Seems as though obfuscation is back and ready to host as well, so this one might be waiting a few weeks to start - especially at the rate Doc's roulette is going.
-
Fair enough. I just figured that after more than a week had elapsed since Nekov finished his roulette someone needed to at least threaten to jump the top of the line.
So long as everyone is content to wait the current batch of roulettes out with me, we'll be ready to go as soon as my official turn comes up. Until then, we have the following 6 gentlemen planning on participating:
Elite
GentlemanofDread
Scorpion
kingshmegland
LieLowTheWantedMan
jingle.boy
I'd like to get a couple more, but no rush (obviously).
-
Ok, I'm in.
-
Fair enough. I just figured that after more than a week had elapsed since Nekov finished his roulette someone needed to at least threaten to jump the top of the line.
No, you're bang on... and if you'd started a few hours earlier, you'd be up. But, zyzz and Obfuscation finally piped up.
Lookin forward to this one. Love the pre-90s theme. Already mapping out my options.
-
Just like Chad, I'm digging through my vaults for some gems to send.
-
Just like Chad, I'm digging through my vaults for some gems to send.
Given his age and 'banned' list, we aren't going to need to dig very deep.
-
I may consider this since it's only pre 90's.
Seneca, if you need a Fogey, I can probably do this.
-
I may consider this since it's only pre 90's.
Seneca, if you need a Fogey, I can probably do this.
I'd love to have you!
-
Alright. Fogey reporting for duty.
-
I want in. I think I have quite some stuff in my library from before the 90s
-
You want jjrock too. I think he can count the number of post 90s albums he owns on his left hand.
-
You want jjrock too. I think he can count the number of post 90s albums he owns on his left hand.
:lol
yeah and they're all from 80's bands!
-
If you need people, you can call on me, but this isn't my wheel house so I might run out of good stuff if people take too many of my songs. However, I can always send Deathtrain. Man, it's been a while since I got to send Deathtrain in a roulette.
-
I think with what I know form the other old farts, I will go in a different direction with the 70's and 80's music in my catalog.
-
Elite
GentlemanofDread
Scorpion
kingshmegland
LieLowTheWantedMan
jingle.boy
lonestar
TAC
Nekov
Dr. DTVT
I'm going to have to cut it off there, although I will make an exception for jjrock, if he really wants in.
-
I'm going to have to cut it off there, although I will make an exception for jjrock, if he really wants in.
You should PM him and invite him. If he wants in, drop me as he would certainly be more of an authority on that era than most of us.
-
You want jjrock too. I think he can count the number of post 90s albums he owns on his left hand.
:lol
yeah and they're all from 80's bands!
True... Saxon, Accept, House of Lords, :TAC:
-
Elmo says one of these bands doesn't belong.
-
Point to where Kip touched you Tim.
-
That's NOT right. :lol
-
:lol ;D
-
My bat signal said something about pre 90s music!!
-
You should PM him and invite him. If he wants in, drop me
You sure?
-
Who would know pre 90s music better than The Nature Boy? If you are worried about my feelings (which I have none), I have an idea or two that would allow me to participate without participating.
-
Who would know pre 90s music better than The Nature Boy?
Word. I mean ...
(https://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm291/sfn18/Ric%20Flair%20WOO%20time/th2375254148_3201d51045_o.gif)
-
If you are worried about my feelings (which I have none)
What? :lol
-
These are bands that would work if I was playing with myself
I told you to dissociate your music listening from your chronic masterbation problem.
-
These are bands that would work if I was playing with myself
I told you to dissociate your music listening from your chronic masterbation problem.
Thanks for commenting on that. I was hoping someone would.
-
Oh, and there better be a round with the theme of "one-hit wonder".
Black Betty and Sharona demand it.
-
Oh, and there better be a round with the theme of "one-hit wonder".
Black Betty and Sharona demand it.
Good Girls Don't would like to have a word with you and Sharona. :lol
BTW, I LOVE that album.
-
I've never heard of any of those people :lol
As of right now, though, I'm not planning on using any themes.
-
Hot damn us old fart will have a lot to send! :lol
-
Oh, and there better be a round with the theme of "one-hit wonder".
Black Betty and Sharona demand it.
Good Girls Don't would like to have a word with you and Sharona. :lol
Sharona's bunked up with Jenny these days - give 'em a call at 867-5309.
Hot damn us old fart will have a lot to send! :lol
Not to mention the good stuff too! :lol
-
:facepalm:
I can't believe I'm gonna do this... but Jessie's Girl is upset you haven't mentioned her. One Way Or Another she's gonna getcha.
-
But both Springfield and Blonde had multiple hits.
-
Damn technicalities! :lol
-
:biggrin:
-
Coming into this thread I can feel my hair getting grey....
-
Coming into this thread I can feel my hair getting grey....
On your chest. Upstairs, mine is disappearing. :lol
-
Yeah, it's when the short and curlies get gray that really signifies the onset of serious fogey-dom...
-
Yeah, it's when the short and curlies get gray that really signifies the onset of serious fogey-dom...
Trim the hedges dude. Trim them hedges.
-
So Double Lex Luther
-
Ach, I'm sorry, but I'm gonna have to withdraw. Really sorry but I'm going on an internet break after the two roulette I'm in are done.
-
Bring back the good Doctor!
-
Ach, I'm sorry, but I'm gonna have to withdraw. Really sorry but I'm going on an internet break after the two roulette I'm in are done.
No worries man
Doc?
-
Doc better pay attention to his own roulette.....
-
I'm bumping in preparation for take off. I know it's been a little while since I started the thread, but hopefully everyone is still down to play. We still have a bit of time to collect ourselves anyhow, as we wait for either DTVT's or Laughingplace's roulettes to finish. Just some basic ground rules- please try to submit songs in a timely manner. And if you don't think you can send something within a couple days of results being posted, feel free to send songs ahead of time. Obviously if you're not going to have problems with sending on time you should wait for results so as to get a better idea of my tastes, but just try your best to stay mindful of a loose 48 hour deadline. Similarly, I'm going to make sure to get through listening and post results for each round in less than a week typically. I know- famous last words- but its true. If I ever take longer than a week to post results I will take a cleaver to my ball sack and send y'all the pieces. Hold me to that. Also- no themes for any of the rounds, apart from the obvious pre-90s bit. I don't want to restrict your options in the slightest.
Finally, I believe we settled on the following group of gladiators:
Dr. DTVT(?)
Elite
jingle.boy
jjrock
kingshmegland
LieLowTheWantedMan
lonestar
Nekov
Scorpion
TAC
It's a shame I can't win myself, as there are a lot of badasses on that list.
-
:D
-
Looking forward to raiding the vaults.
-
I'm actually very wary of winning this one, my oldies collection probably doesn't hold a candle to some of the other gents here. But I'll take my best shot of course.
-
I won't be able to finish until the new year probably since I am out of town, and only have my phone and iPad for Internet. You can start when you are ready since I am in my last round, but i don't know if this is a good time of year to start.
-
Alright everyone...
The new year is upon us and so is this roulette. As I mentioned in a previous post, there are not going to be any themes (just pre-90s). I'm aiming for 8 rounds, a week a piece, to finish before a change of seasons. Also mentioned previously- I'm hoping everyone can generally send within about 48 hours of each new round beginning. However, since this is the first round and we're still in the midst of the holidays with many people probably quite busy (or just avoiding the internet), I'll wait a bit longer before I start pestering people.
Now... go!
-
Sent for Round 1.
-
Thanks TAC!
Also, if anyone is interested in sending me mp3's (not necessary, but I'd appreciate it) just let me know and I'll shoot you a pm with my email address. Several of you may already have it from my first roulette.
-
Sent
-
Will send tonight! SWEET!
-
Sent!
-
Sent.
Let me know if you got the message.
-
Got it! Thanks
-
Sent!
-
Sent yo...
-
I don't really know Seneca and his band lists are kind of untelling. Can't wait to see the pre 90's submissions by everyone, but I really have no idea where to go with mine.
Should be interesting.
-
I don't really know Seneca and his band lists are kind of untelling. Can't wait to see the pre 90's submissions by everyone, but I really have no idea where to go with mine.
Should be interesting.
I think some of my pics will be something that others may surprised about. I want to give Seneca other bands that some may not listen to here at all.
-
Hopefully not the Flock of Seagulls
-
I don't mind a few songs from them but never owned their albums. I do have plenty others that will make you cringe. :lol
-
Hopefully not the Flock of Seagulls
A lot of their first album would translate very easily to a classic rock format. Wait, did I say that?? :lol
-
Hopefully not the Flock of Seagulls
A lot of their first album would translate very easily to a classic rock format. Wait, did I say that?? :lol
Lol. Just delete that comment and we will pretend it didn't happen
-
:rollin
-
Hopefully not the Flock of Seagulls
A lot of their first album would translate very easily to a classic rock format. Wait, did I say that?? :lol
*Peter Griffin voice* "Holy Crap!"
-
Who's Peter Griffin? :lol
-
Don't you joke with me Mr.
-
Don't you joke with me Mr.
:lol
Seriously, I don't know!
-
You'd have to be blind not to know who he is! :lol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrtVXI8kROY
-
You'd have to be blind not to know who he is! :lol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrtVXI8kROY
Dude, I have never watched ONE episode of Family Guy.
-
You are so old.
-
I haven't watched much Family Guy at all, but I did watch when Peter and some chicken had a 10 minute battle. That was funny stuff
-
You are so old.
:lol
September '68, you?? :rollin
-
In mentality you bugger!! :lol
March 68. :getoffmylawn:
-
In mentality you bugger!! :lol
March 68. :getoffmylawn:
Now THAT is old! :lol
-
:biggrin:
-
I'm loving the old folk banter :lol
I don't really know Seneca and his band lists are kind of untelling. Can't wait to see the pre 90's submissions by everyone, but I really have no idea where to go with mine.
Should be interesting.
Hopefully my tastes will be a little clearer as we get through the first couple rounds, but I'd encourage everyone to not overthink it all that much. I'd honestly prefer it if everyone just sends their personal favorites without too much thought for how I may or may not like it. For the older guys, I'm hoping for a glimpse into your pasts. In fact, thinking on that, I'm reminded of one of lonestar's old lists in which he detailed the most influential albums in his life and how they related to particular events in his life, though often not entirely for musical reasons. And while I'm likely never going to connect with Tales from Topographic Oceans in the same way or to the same degree as lonestar, I really did enjoy giving it a listen after going through the list. So yeah- go with your gut. I'll really appreciate it.
Looks like only Elite, Dr. DTVT (if he's still in) and jingle.boy (who I think already has a song picked out) are missing at this point.
-
You are so old.
:lol
September '68, you?? :rollin
In mentality you bugger!! :lol
March 68. :getoffmylawn:
September 69,you old fucks. :RJ:
-
I talked to Chad, I believe he sent you an email.
RJ.......yup. :lol
-
pre-90's music only? I didn't read that part and almost sent a 2014 song. I'm so fucked in this roulette :lol
-
I talked to Chad, I believe he sent you an email.
Yeah we've exhanged a couple emails the past few days. He mentioned not wanting to come into the thread itself for fear of having to deal with used catheters and depends diapers.
pre-90's music only? I didn't read that part and almost sent a 2014 song. I'm so fucked in this roulette :lol
:loser:
-
I talked to Chad, I believe he sent you an email.
Yeah we've exhanged a couple emails the past few days. He mentioned not wanting to come into the thread itself for fear of having to deal with used catheters and depends diapers.
I'm pretty sure he deals with those things everyday, so I don't see a reason not to come into the thread...
-
It "Depends".
-
I've got 10 songs now and a whole day to play with them. Gotta love the holidays!
-
Great first round, team. There probably aren’t going to be this many 8s in future rounds. And I’ll be very happy if anyone can get me another song as spectacular as the winner this round. On the flip side, I enjoyed all of these songs. Even the ones that scored lowest. So here are your results...
Elite Wishbone Ash - Sometime World
Oh that’s rich. He says he’s fucked in this roulette, but right now I’m the one who’s feeling fucked. In the most fantastic way imaginable. This was the first song that I listened to, and what a great song to open up the roulette! Seriously- I couldn’t be more pleased right now. I’ve already listened to the full album Argus. Great great stuff. The guitar work is spell-binding, the bass is just what it needs to be and the vocals are a great match. Lyrics are real nice, too. I feel both at peace and excited. The only downside to this submission is that you can only go downhill from here. 9.5
kingshmegland Jon Butcher - Send me Somebody
This here is a pretty straightforward tune, but really enjoyable nonetheless. It’s interesting that you mentioned this is his last album before moving into the blues, because there are definitely moments in the song that I can hear that beginning to seep in. It’s got a great groove to it and I love the guitar tone. Also- best chorus of the round and it’s not even close. Overall a really strong song which could easily have been my favorite of the round if not for Elite’s sensational pick. Also, really cool and funny story about you running into him in the mall. Thanks! 8
lonestar Robin Trower - Bridge of Sighs
I’ve got the blues now and evidently so did Robin Trower. I can feel it in the vocals, the emotive (albeit simple) guitar work, the lyrics, and the excellent atmosphere. I get the sense that if I were to strip away the first three components the fourth would still make for a nice ambient piece. My favorite thing about the song may be the slow pace with which it moves. There’s a patience here that lets the music swell, all the while keeping my attention. Very solid song to kick things off. 8
TAC UFO - Rock Bottom (live)
You’ve come out swinging- that’s for sure. At just over 11 minutes, this is easily the longest song of the round. It’s an unrelentingly fun, wild, and astonishingly impressive ride. As you mentioned when you sent the song, the Schekner guitar solo is not to be taken lightly. My one difficulty in judging this song was the length. While there aren’t any bad parts, I wonder if it could have been shrunk just a touch. That’s a minor qualm though and I think the music is more than satisfying enough to get a pass. With such a great start, Where do we go? Where do we go from here? 8
jingle.boy Slade - My oh My
So I’ve heard of Slade, and quite like Quiet Riot’s cover of their “Cum on Feel the Noize”, but never checked ‘em out. That’s going to change, if you could be so kind as to direct me to your favorite Slade album. As for this particular song- I’m really digging it. Simply put, it makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside. In part because of the uplifting vocals and lyrics, in part because of the nice piano intro, and in part because of the very full sound when it starts to take off. Thanks for mixing things up with a ballad! 8
Scorpion Judas Priest - Beyond the Realms of Death
I’ve listened to Judas Priest before on Spotify several times, but never really invested the time to check them out more fully. I left them off the banned list precisely because I was hoping someone would get me something better to prompt a stronger reaction in me, so thanks for fulfilling that wish. Assuming you’re familiar with more than just this song, how would you rank your top 3-5 Judas Priest albums? About the song, I can understand why it would be considered a classic. And about the guitar solo, you’re right on point- great stuff. Though I’d probably rate TAC’s guitar solo offering from this round a bit higher, this is a close second. Very good start. 7.5
jjrock88 Saxon - Power and the Glory
A minute and a half into the song the questions are posed: can you feel the power? Can you feel the glory? And to that, I answer yes. Apart from Iron Maiden I’ve never really delved into NWOBHM bands, though you’ve got me starting to question why. My one complaint with this song is the kind of dirty-sounding production. Overall, nice introduction to the band- I’m now going to look into checking out more. Which album would you suggest I try first? 7.5
LieLowTheWantedMan Can - Paperhouse
While you might not always send my favorite songs, you’re always introducing me to really interesting stuff. So thanks for that- I really do appreciate it. This song is no different. It’s astonishing to me that this album was released almost 45 years ago, the sound is not dated in the slightest. I’m not crazy about the gibberish vocals, but they’re certainly not unpleasant or inappropriate within the context of the song. I checked out a couple other tracks from Tago Mago and they were, once again, interesting. Kind of a lot for me to swallow, but still a fun and worthwhile meal. 7.5
Dr. DTVT Van Halen- Hot for Teacher
You’re right- this is a fun song. Paired with a fun video, no less. And I’m really enjoying EVH’s guitar work. But I’d be lying if I said this song didn’t still leave a little something to be desired. Not exactly sure what that something is, but I suspect it might have to do with the way the vocals are delivered. Regardless, it’s the difference between a 7.5 and a 7.
Nekov Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays - Ozark
This is a really pleasant instrumental that I enjoy. I’ve been playing the piano for about 10 years now and I really enjoy piano-centric music. My only issue with this song may be that it’s a touch too playful and more bouncy than what I typically go for. It’s up-tempo and festive- definitely appropriate for the holiday season. Unfortunately, I’ve never been all that wild about festive music. Still, that this should be my least favorite song of the round, despite still enjoying it, is a testament to how strong a batch of songs this was. 6.5
Send round 2 whenever you're ready!
-
Wow! :D I didn't expect that! And I didn't even tell you to listen to the full album :lol
Argus is one of my favourites, there should be a write-up about it in my first Top 50 thread. The whole album is indeed something unique, with those fantastic guitar and bass lines, vocal harmonies and song-writing. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
-
Yeah after hearing how awesome the song was I almost immediately went to check out the full album. It did not disappoint :tup
-
Very cool to see all the song selections. Man some memories here.
-
As I feared, at least three bands I wanted to send were sent by others. :lol
I'm gonna have to dig deep by the end of this thing. Dammit TAC, I was so gonna send Rock Bottom next. *shakes fist*
EDIT- Sent next round as to beat you to the punch...
-
Wow! :D I didn't expect that! And I didn't even tell you to listen to the full album :lol
Argus is one of my favourites, there should be a write-up about it in my first Top 50 thread. The whole album is indeed something unique, with those fantastic guitar and bass lines, vocal harmonies and song-writing. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Argus is awesome. The roots of Iron Maiden.
-
Opeth has a pretty good cover of Bridges of Sigh
-
I checked out a couple other tracks from Tago Mago and they were, once again, interesting. Kind of a lot for me to swallow, but still a fun and worthwhile meal.
Did you get any of the weird ones? :lol (Aumgn, Peking O)
And yeah, Tago Mago is definitely their most "out there" album. Surprisingly, it's only my third favourite despite it being mostly declared their best. I like Ege Bamyasi (more "straightforward" but still with its share of weirdness, especially on Soup) and Future Days (their most minimalist album, even strays into ambient territory at parts and has a really summery vibe throughout. Probably the least weird of the three) more.
-
I checked out a couple other tracks from Tago Mago and they were, once again, interesting. Kind of a lot for me to swallow, but still a fun and worthwhile meal.
Did you get any of the weird ones? :lol (Aumgn, Peking O)
And yeah, Tago Mago is definitely their most "out there" album. Surprisingly, it's only my third favourite despite it being mostly declared their best. I like Ege Bamyasi (more "straightforward" but still with its share of weirdness, especially on Soup) and Future Days (their most minimalist album, even strays into ambient territory at parts and has a really summery vibe throughout. Probably the least weird of the three) more.
The Tago Mago songs I listened to were Mushroom and Bring Me Coffee or Tea. I'll try to give those other two albums a try when I have the time. A little more accessible sounds promising.
-
Ahh yeah Bring Me Coffee Or Tea is a pretty weird one, though the two I mentioned are insanity basically, haha. The drums going on in Mushroom were what I was talking about in my message when I mentioned it being a hallmark of their sound. Anyways, hope you enjoy their other stuff. :biggrin:
-
Glad you liked Saxon and are interested in looking into more NWOBHM.
As far as Saxon's albums go, their classics from the 80's would be "Power and the Glory" and "Denim and Leather"
But this is a band that has just gotten better and better with age; their most recent album, "Sacrifice" is fantastic.
-
And just sent you round 2!
-
Glad you liked Saxon and are interested in looking into more NWOBHM.
As far as Saxon's albums go, their classics from the 80's would be "Power and the Glory" and "Denim and Leather"
But this is a band that has just gotten better and better with age; their most recent album, "Sacrifice" is fantastic.
You must listen to JJ.
Edit: ..and Sent!
-
DENIM AND LEATHER, BROUGHT US ALL TOGETHER...IT WAS YOU, THAT SET THE SPIRIT FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bout twenty of us with a bag of weed and a keg in some remote underdeveloped intersection, this cranking out of my buddy's car stereo, pretty much every Friday night my senior year.
Ahhhhhhhhhh the memories................
-
Denim and Leather it is! :smiley:
-
and landing strips. :biggrin:
Sent!
-
DENIM AND LEATHER, BROUGHT US ALL TOGETHER...IT WAS YOU, THAT SET THE SPIRIT FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bout twenty of us with a bag of weed and a keg in some remote underdeveloped intersection, this cranking out of my buddy's car stereo, pretty much every Friday night my senior year.
Ahhhhhhhhhh the memories................
It never gets old.
-
Well, I was shooting in the dark, same as I'm doing this round
Sent
-
DENIM AND LEATHER, BROUGHT US ALL TOGETHER...IT WAS YOU, THAT SET THE SPIRIT FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bout twenty of us with a bag of weed and a keg in some remote underdeveloped intersection, this cranking out of my buddy's car stereo, pretty much every Friday night my senior year.
Ahhhhhhhhhh the memories................
It never gets old.
And it was always the dude with the El Camino that had the sweet stereo, am I right??
-
Well it was usually coming from my car, but unfortunately, it was not an El Camino. :)
-
when I was younger my dad gave me his 1985 LeBaron........great tape deck to blast Saxon in
-
This thread is dripping with nostalgia...
Only missing Scorpion now. If he gets something to me soon I should be able to listen and score by no later than the end of the week.
-
I'm going to be starting classes tomorrow and the pace will probably return to closer to one week per round, but since I've had a lot more time these first two rounds have been super quick. I've listened to all the songs a handful of times and feel comfortable enough sharing the results now. Overall, there are a couple really good songs at the top, but also more songs on the lower end of the scale this time around.
Elite Deep Purple - Child in Time
Of course, I've heard Smoke on the Water before and I'm familiar with Deep Purple as being a massive influence on so much of the music that I listen to now. But I've also obviously never checked them out very thoroughly. Probably a mistake on my part, if this song is any indication as to what I might find. Because this is fantastic. Truly epic song, with great dynamic changes, awesome vocals, and a marvelous guitar solo. The organ adds a really nice touch too. I'm not going to dwell on it much more, just suffice it to say that you knocked it out of the park again. 9
kingshmegland Toto - Hydra
I've never even heard of these guys, so I had no idea what to expect. It didn't take long to figure it out though- this is a great song. Once again you're atop the list of non-Elite submissions, and this one is even a step up from the Jon Butcher song. I'm having a hard time trying to articulate why I enjoy this song so much. Rhythmically it's a real joy and makes me want to dance. The vocals are also perfect for the song. I didn't read the lyrics, but as far as I can tell there's something fun going on here involving a dragon and solitaire and other odd stuff. All in all, I really enjoyed this one and I look forward to checking out the rest of the album (and hopefully others too). 8.5
Nekov The Waterboys - Old England
This is a sizable step up from your last submission. Once again piano driven, which I once again appreciated. Of the songs at the top this seems to be the most simple. The vocals didn't really grab me the first couple times I listened to the song, but they've only grown on me. The brass, bells and choir (though only used sparingly) really add another dimension to the song. The way the song is set up really demands that attention is paid to the lyrics, and I really do like the lyrics. They have a bite to them that, at times, reminds me of one of my favorites: Bob Dylan.
Where the time stained of england flies
Where the homes are warm and the mothers sigh
Where comedians laugh and babies cry
Where criminals are televised politicians fraternize
Journalists are dignified and everyone is civilised
And children stare with heroin eyes
Old england!
:tup :tup 8.5
Scorpion Camel - Nimrodel/The Procession/The White Rider
While this is a multi-movement epic, everything flows quite well here. Flows in a dreamy sort of way, which really puts me at peace. The keyboards/moog/mellotron/whatever the else is going on there do a lot to contribute to that peaceful and dreamy mood. Even when the pace picks up near the four minute mark, I'm never really overwhelmed. It all just sort of makes sense and I might even say that it's predictable. I don't mean that in a bad way at all, quite the opposite. It's like everything is right where you would expect it to be, because it fits best there. Nothing is tedious, nothing is boring, nothing bothers me. At the same time, I'm not sure there's anything really astonishing about this song. Never do I feel blown away. It's just really solid on every level and a really enjoyable listen start to finish. I'll definitely be checking out more from Camel (been on my to-do list for a while now, anyways). Also, bonus points for the subject matter of the lyrics! 8.5
TAC Thin Lizzy - Emerald
When I saw that I had two Thin Lizzy songs this round I expected that they'd probably have leave a similar impression and score the same. As it turned out, I enjoyed this particular song a bit more than the other. It's softer on the edges and I like the guitar work more. Both are good guitar songs, but this one just left me wanting more. I'll have more to say about Thin Lizzy farther down in the write-ups, so I'll leave this one here. 8
Dr. DTVT Stevie Ray Vaughan - Crossfire
My first impression, as I payed attention to the bluesy vocals and the steadily walking bass line was that I might be walking into an old saloon or something of the sort. The music video certainly didn't help me escape that feeling and I consequently couldn't help but feel that this was quite a dated song. That was a bit of a turn off, and it initially got in the way of my enjoying the song. I've kind of accepted that now, thankfully, because there is still a lot here to enjoy. Most noteworthy is (of course) the guitar. Stevie Ray Vaughan is a greaaat guitarist. There's something about his playing that's very economical. Here, it's not about the number of notes and the speed of his playing, but rather choosing just the right note and letting it develop at a natural pace. The solo is mighty impressive, but also shows remarkable restraint. Step up from the Van Halen song! 7.5
lonestar Montrose - Bad Motor Scooter
This one is a little tricky for me, because I enjoy the verses quite a bit but don't particularly care for the chorus. The motorcycle guitar effect kind of rubs me the wrong way. It feels a bit gimmicky, to be honest. It's not painful or anything, and when I don't overthink it I hardly notice it, but I don't think it really adds anything to my enjoyment of the song. I do enjoy the vocals though from Sammy Hagar. Although different in many different ways, this song actually reminds me of a more straightforward, hard rock, poor man's Red Barchetta. I don't think it's a very fair comparison, but I couldn't help but think about it. 6.5
jingle.boy Mr. Big - Addicted to that Rush
It's a fun song to listen to, I'll give you that. It actually reminds me a bit of the Doc's first submission, Hot for Teacher. I don't really have any issues with the song. Apart from not having EVH on the guitar, this song might actually be a bit better. The bass guitar stands out, especially. At the same time, it's a bit repetitive and unfortunately it starts to wear me down after a few listens. Nothing bad here... just nothing super exciting either. 6.5
jjrock88 Thin Lizzy - Thunder and Lightning
I enjoyed the other Thin Lizzy song enough to get them on my 'check out' list, but this one alone probably wouldn't have done it. It's a little rougher than "Emerald", and not in a way that makes me happy. I'm not a big fan of the verging-on-breakneck speed with which the vocals are often delivered. Along with the rawness that I mentioned, it almost feels kind of punkish. I don't necessarily dislike punk, but I don't really enjoy that kind of texture on Thin Lizzy. I'll still definitely check them out though. 6.5
LieLowTheWantedMan Cardiacs - In a City Lining
Once again, an interesting song. It's a bit wild but in a very bouncy sort of way. I don't particularly like that bounciness, to be honest. Even so, I can enjoy most of this song most of the time. It loses me a bit in the sections when the tempo picks up a lot. There's a recklessness there that unnerves me a bit. Funnily enough, since you mentioned them, this is the same problem I have with Mr. Bungle. Their songs (and this one too) jumps from theme to theme in a manic way that makes for a fun first listen. But once I've become more familiar with those shifts, and the element of surprise wears off, I'm just left with a sort of jumbled song that I don't necessarily want to listen to again. Sorry :-[ 6
Standings:
Elite 18.5
kingshmegland 16.5
Scorpion 16
TAC 16
Nekov 15
Dr. DTVT 14.5
lonestar 14.5
jingle.boy 14.5
jjrock88 14
LieLowTheWantedMan 13.5
Obviously Elite has the edge right now, but it's still very early in this race and a lot can happen.
-
round 3 sent
-
:'(
-
Child In Time is a great tune. I would have never have thought to send it. Good call Elite!
Tough to decide what to send. The man likes piano. Hmm..
-
I'm gonna keep trying quirkier stuff till it works. :D Sent!
-
Sent.
-
Sent!
No piano though.
-
SWEET!! That album Hydra is a killer album. Listen to the whole album. I'm burning some music for my boss who's showing up tomorrow then I'll work on picking the next song to send!
-
SWEET!! That album Hydra is a killer album. Listen to the whole album.
King, just checked out Hydra (the song). Definitely not for me. I will say that if Dream Theater covered it, it would probably be OK though.
-
SWEET!! That album Hydra is a killer album. Listen to the whole album.
King, just checked out Hydra (the song). Definitely not for me. I will say that if Dream Theater covered it, it would probably be OK though.
If it was your roulette TAC, I would not send that song. I know it's not up your alley.
And yes, like the Queen cover, I'd love to here DT cover that.
-
If it was your roulette TAC, I would not send that song. I know it's not up your alley.
My roulette is a year away! :D
-
Holy Moly Batman!
-
Cool! That part you quoted from the lyrics is my favorite part of the song.
Sent
-
SWEET!! That album Hydra is a killer album. Listen to the whole album.
Definitely will. Keep em coming!
Cool! That part you quoted from the lyrics is my favorite part of the song.
Yeah, mine too :tup
-
Sent!
-
Nice to see some artists that I've heard of appearing in a roulette . ;D
-
Already forgot what I sent. I'm so fucking old.
(middle of the pack for this Geritol gang though :lol )
-
Already forgot what I sent. I'm so fucking old.
(middle of the pack for this Geritol gang though :lol )
I'd make fun of you but I've done that before. :lol
-
:rollin :rollin :rollin
-
Hey, you fogeys, I'm beating you at your own game!
Lol, I'm probably not going to keep up with this though.
-
I feel obligated to drop in and say that Cardiacs is one of the best bands ever and giving them a 6 is criminally low considering much worse music has gotten much higher scores. But I know it's all opinions n stuff. Still though, Cardiacs rules. :hat
-
Already forgot what I sent. I'm so fucking old.
It'll be a nice surprise to find out.
I feel obligated to drop in and say that Cardiacs is one of the best bands ever and giving them a 6 is criminally low considering much worse music has gotten much higher scores. But I know it's all opinions n stuff. Still though, Cardiacs rules. :hat
Thing about LieLow's submissions, both here and in my first roulette, is that they're very hit or miss. Same with your stuff as well, actually. When it hits, it's a blow strong enough to knock me off my feet. But when it doesn't hit, it's just there. Usually nothing bad to say about it, but not much in the way of praise either. A safe submission will usually not wow me either, but it's safe for a reason and I can usually enjoy it enough to get by. Cardiacs just didn't hit.
Only waiting on Elite, Scorpion, and DTVT now.
-
sent
-
I sent a couple of days back as well, but didn't report it in this thread. What's the status on this?
-
Hey, you fogeys, I'm beating you at your own game!
Lol, I'm probably not going to keep up with this though.
My wheelchair is keeping up with you. :lol
-
Yeah I sent as well.
-
I'm going to try to post results by the end of the day...
-
Hey, you fogeys, I'm beating you at your own game!
Lol, I'm probably not going to keep up with this though.
You've sent a couple of great tunes. I seriously would've never thought of using Wishbone Ash, even though I have their early albums.
-
Yeah, this should definitely push us fogies outside our box as far as to what to send. Though the track I sent is known, it's pretty out there as to standard 70s/ 80s fare. Hoping it helps!!!
-
Darn Whippersnapper
-
Okay guys... so I started classes this past week and so my life just got a lot more busy. Don't worry though, I'm still sticking to a week-per-round max. But the write-ups are likely to be more abbreviated now. Anyways, here are the round 3 results:
jingle.boy Meatloaf - Bat Out of Hell
Best song yet, from you! While clocking in at nearly 10 minutes, this song doesn't feel long to me. It never really lets up, even when it slows and quiets down (in fact, those are the sections which most draw me in). I enjoy this singer, and always have (used to listen to 2 out of 3 ain't bad, but never got around to checking out the full album). Great submission. 8.5
TAC Rainbow - The Temple of the King
Dio is an awesome vocalist. Absolutely love him, particularly on Holy Diver. And as I found out in the last round, Richie Blackmore is an awesome guitarist. So it's no surprise that this guitar ballad is also awesome. The lyrics are also really effective in drawing me into this fantasy world. Another great choice, TAC! 8.5
lonestar Blue Oyster Cult - Veteran of the Psychic Wars
This one made the strongest first impression and definitely deserves further exploration on my part. My knowledge of Blue Oyster Cult was, before this, limited to I'm Burnin' for You and Don't Fear the Reaper. Like those two, this song is very solid, but in a different way. It has more of a dark psychedelic, atmospheric and march-like feel to it that I wasn't really expecting. 8
Scorpion Candlemass - At the Gallows End
Most unique submission of the round, without a doubt. It's got a majestic and mournful sound to it, particularly with that first verse, that I really enjoy. The guitar riffing also does a really good job of keeping things moving along well. The guitar solo is also, unsurprisingly, a high point in the song. I'll be checking out more of this haunted music when I get the time... 8
jjrock88 Crimson Glory - Heart of Steel
There's really nothing to dislike about this song. I don't think its high points are quite as high as the top 4 songs from this round, but it remains an undoubtedly good song with no low points to speak of. Reminds me a lot of Queensryche, which makes sense given that they were contemporaries and both largely influential in the formative years of progressive metal. I can imagine hearing this kind of track on Empire, which is about as much as I can praise a song of this style. 8
Dr. DTVT Rainbow - Man on the Silver Mountain
I don't know what's up with this... I really enjoyed the other Rainbow song from this round. This one- not quite as much. It's not bad at all, but it doesn't sound as good. May just be the sound quality of the youtube clip, but this one sounds much muddier than Temple of the King. I'll still be checking out the full album. Dio still sounds awesome, that's for sure. 7.5
LieLowTheWantedMan and Nekov Gentle Giant - Peel the Paint and Free Hand
As you can see, I received two Gentle Giant songs this round. Unlike the pair of Thin Lizzy songs I received earlier, I enjoyed these two about the same. They're both a bit quirky, but never hard to follow or enjoy. I really enjoyed the way the instruments interacted in both of these songs- each impressing me in their own way. Strong musicianship across the board and a fun listening experience. 7.5
Elite Alan Parsons Project - Old and Wise
It's my least favorite submission from you thus far, clearly. But don't let that get you down, because it's still quite nice. Really, really relaxing song. My biggest complaint is that after a minute or two I find myself wanting to block it out a bit. If I'm not actively focusing on the song it kind of just drones on. Even with the couple crescendos I don't find myself really noticing much of a change until the saxophone(?) solo, which ends the song on a high note. 7.5
kingshmegland Zebra - Who's Behind the Door
You did a really good job the first two rounds, but here you've landed in last place. This song just doesn't grab me quite as much as your other submissions. It's mostly pleasant, but I'm not sure it's all that memorable. Also, not a big fan of the spacey vocal effects. Or, more broadly, most of the vocals. Sorry man... 6.5
Standings:
Elite 26
TAC 24.5
Scorpion 24
kingshmegland 23
jingle.boy 23
Nekov 22.5
lonestar 22.5
Dr. DTVT 22
jjrock88 22
LieLowTheWantedMan 21
Just a couple points separating most of you. Keep 'em coming!
-
Awe crap. I've been listening to songs today in preparation for the next round. I'll make up for this
-
Way to go LLTWM o/
Will think this one thruogh and send soon
-
*\o
Good choice too. Love Free Hand. :metal
-
The problem with the studio version of Man On The Silver Mountain is it's paced way too slow. The Rainbow debut is pretty cool. The original Elf band has a slightly "hokey" feel to them. It shines through on most of the album.
Seneca, if you want to check out Rainbow, go for On Stage, their live album. Rising and Long Live Rock n Roll are both good too.
King, love that Zebra tune.
Again, a bunch of interesting submissons.
-
And sent
-
awesome to see 2 Dio songs last round!!
Round 4 sent
-
Seneca: for further Rainbow, I recommend Stargazer off of Rising. One of my favourite rock songs ever.
-
Seneca: for further Rainbow, I recommend Stargazer off of Rising. One of my favourite rock songs ever.
Hell yes! :metal
Dream Theater crushed it to. They're version was incredible.
-
...and sent.
-
Bat out of Hell :2metal:
-
I have most of the round 4 submissions. You guys have done a good job of getting them to me quickly- thanks!
Seneca: for further Rainbow, I recommend Stargazer off of Rising. One of my favourite rock songs ever.
Hell yes! :metal
Dream Theater crushed it to. They're version was incredible.
Bat out of Hell :2metal:
All very true!
-
Sent!
-
I still need Elite...
I think he's having internet problems, but I'm going to go ahead and listen and rate all the other songs in the meantime.
-
I've been very busy, so that why I haven't been online at all. I'm still at work, so I will send when I get back home. Sorry for being late :(
-
No worries- good to know everything is alright! Being busy in the real world is a perfectly reasonable excuse :smiley:
-
Real World interferes with my DTF World. :lol
-
Sent a song probably everybody knows.
-
Real World interferes with my DTF World. :lol
You don't expect me to believe that you actually exist in the real world, right?
Sent a song probably everybody knows.
Everyone... Including me :lol Try again, good sir.
-
Oh fuck. Now what?
-
I am omnipresent.
-
You don't expect me to believe that you actually exist in the real world, right?
I know...you don't really want to believe that in this world there are bearded Patriot fans...but I can verify that he isn't some made up internet troll, because I met him.
He's just a real life troll ;)
-
:biggrin:
Mason, we need another meet up. Just don't wear any Steelers clothing.
-
I don't know when I'll be heading up north again. If I get this new job I am anticipating, I probably won't visit up north this summer.
As I like to remind everyone, I'm 30 minutes from Disneyland :biggrin:
-
Trust me. I've been pushing the Disney agenda for a while. If we do, you know we'll hook up. :eyebrows:
-
Trust me. I've been pushing the Disney agenda for a while. If we do, you know we'll hook up. :eyebrows:
Four more weeks!!!
-
Great time with your kids and their age right now. To be honest, I always loved going no matter what the age. I've been to Disney World 6 times and Disney Land once.
-
Disney World is awesome. Not gonna tell you how many times we've been.
Looking at finally hitting Disneyland this summer.
-
That Aerosmith roller coaster is the best ride ever!!
-
I enjoyed that ride a lot! The long line... Not so much
-
I'd like to post the results now. I do have to run to work in a few minutes though, so I don't have time to share a lot of my thoughts. Here's the abridged version:
TAC Fields of the Nephelim - Endemoniada
GREAT submission! You've consistently sent one of the top 2 or 3 songs, in any given round, but this time you take the crown unchallenged. It's a little odd and it does take a little while to get going- as you mentioned- but it all works so well regardless. A+ song here, keep it up... 9
LieLowTheWantedMan Van der Graaf Generator - The Sleepwalkers
The title of this song is so very appropriate :lol And you've done it this time- I'm hooked and I want more. Easily your best submission of the roulette thus far. It is a bit long, but It doesn't bore me in the slightest. I can understand why this is one of your favorite vocalists and, yes, he does sound a bit (or very) insane. 8.5
Dr. DTVT Fates Warning - Exodus
Arch is an odd duck. I can totally understand why many people might not like his vocals. In fact, wasn't he fired or somehow pushed out of the band? Or was that unrelated to his vocals? Anyways, that's not really the point. I enjoyed this song a lot. Not the longest, but definitely the most epic song of the round (and perhaps the whole roulette). Unusual vocals and all, I found no cracks in this, very strong, song. :tup 8.5
kingshmegland Asia - Wildest Dreams
I get that these are some heavy hitters in the world of progressive rock, but I don't really hear it here. Much more straightforward AOR-sounding rock. But don't let that get you down, because that is not a negative at all. In fact, I really enjoy it. Even reminds me a little bit of Journey, which I know a lot of folks will gag at, but once again- not a bad thing. Journey is one of my favorite bands and this is one of my favorite songs of the round. I'll be checking out the rest of the album as soon as I get out of the heat of this moment. 8
jingle.boy Emerson, Lake and Palmer - Karn Evil 9, 1st Impression Part 2
Without a doubt one of the largest omissions from my pre-90s music library, as I've known for a while. Not sure why I never took the time to check them out, but I will now. As you said- a very keyboard driven song. And the keyboards really deliver the goods, here. Guitarist ain't no slouch either. And the drumming! Very nice... 8
Scorpion and Nekov Ozric Tentacles and Frank Zappa - The Domes of G’ba and Night School respectively
I'm only using one writeup here because I'm likely to say many of the same things about these songs anyways. Both instrumentals, which are typically hit or miss with me (more often miss, actually). Here, both are quite strong and deserve future exploration on my part. The Tentacles song is much more psychedelic, but they're both unique in their own way. The propulsive rhythms in the Zappa song, along with the keys, are really great. Love that cover artwork, btw, Scorp. 7.5
Elite Bruce Springsteen - New York City Serenade
I decided to accept this song, even though Springsteen is on my banned list, because I'd never heard the song and it sounded quite a bit different than the more stripped back Nebraska (my most listened-to album from him). Anyways, this song... I was really wowed with the first few minutes. The piano intro, then the guitar, then the soulful vocals... I was eating it up without question. As the song wore on though, it began to lose some of that appeal. In fact, it kind of peaked for me about 5-6 minutes in. At which point I began to wonder if the 10 minute track length was necessary or excessive. 7
jjrock88 Metal Church - Badlands
I've got nothing bad to say about this song. It's a pretty straight forward heavy metal song, I suppose with some thrash elements? Maybe some NWoBHM sprinkled in? The vocals are good enough, but I wouldn't call them extraordinary. That's kind of a trend with this song, to be honest. I do legitimately enjoy it, but I'd be lying if I said it grabbed my in any way. 7
lonestar Demon - Touching the Ice
From Thrash/NWoBHM (I'm imagining something like Metal Church ^^) to this? That's quite the shift! I definitely hear the Pink Floyd influence there. It has that atmospheric and dreamy quality to it that I tend to enjoy. Unfortunately it's also the most forgettable song of the round for me, even after several tries. :sadpanda: 6.5
Standings:
TAC 33.5
Elite 33
Scorpion 31.5
kingshmegland 31
jingle.boy 31
Dr. DTVT 30.5
Nekov 30
LieLowTheWantedMan 29.5
lonestar 29
jjrock88 29
So we're at the half-way point now. Elite has lost his early lead and I have it on good authority that he may be running out of choices :lol... TAC, with consistency as his mantra, has taken the lead. LieLow is no longer in last place. Speaking of which, only a measly four and a half points separates first from last. A couple really good rounds in a row and anyone can win this. Keep 'em coming!
-
I thought you might like that. A Pink Floyd/Opeth/Porcupine Tree mashup from the 80's.
It's really a great album. Their next album,Elizium, is even more Floydish.
I really have no idea what to send. Seneca doesn't seem to be very impressed with 80's Rock/NWOBHM.
Thought about sending a Metal Church and old FW too. Now I don't know what to do.
-
I really have no idea what to send. Seneca doesn't seem to be very impressed with 80's Rock/NWOBHM.
Yeah, I'm not sure what the deal with that is... jjrock's submissions, in particular, always seem to evoke the same response from me. I've enjoyed all of those songs, I really have. And it hurts to consistently rate it in the bottom half, because of that. But they also never really blow me away. Apart from Saxon, I haven't felt too compelled to check out much of the rest. :-\
-
I really have no idea what to send. Seneca doesn't seem to be very impressed with 80's Rock/NWOBHM.
Yeah, I'm not sure what the deal with that is... jjrock's submissions, in particular, always seem to evoke the same response from me. I've enjoyed all of those songs, I really have. And it hurts to consistently rate it in the bottom half, because of that. But they also never really blow me away. Apart from Saxon, I haven't felt too compelled to check out much of the rest. :-\
Yeah unfortunately it will have to continue lol.
There is a zero percent chance that I will send anything other then 80s Rock/NWOBHM lol
-
By all means, keep them coming! I'm sure something more will stick.
-
And this is where Istart rrunning out of bands. Gonna have to dig deep man.
-
:D
-
Ok, guess i didn't have to dig that deep. Sent.
-
Glad you like Asia. The self titled album is awesome and yes, I did not send "Heat Of The Moment". :lol
Alright, I just sent a song from a band no one will send besides myself. I'd bet on that. Enjoy!
-
sent!
-
Sent, let's see if I can get a high score this round...
-
I am so stuck!
-
I am so wasted!
That's my skull!!
-
I am so wasted!
That's my skull!!
:metal
(https://mediafiles.cineplex.com/Blog/English/300x200/spicoli300.jpg)
-
Will send after work.
...and sent!
-
Way to go Hamilton!
-
I'm torn between a couple of early 80's songs, but I have no confidence in either for the next round. Really digging for material here.
-
Really digging for material here.
Me too :smiley:
I've received all the submissions now and will listen for the next couple days... Results will be posted no later than Saturday.
-
As promised, results. I realize that this is the longest I've taken to post them so far, but I also realize that its still in line with my goal of max-1 week per round. Not to toot my own horn, but I feel pretty good about that :smiley: Anyways, plenty of good stuff this round, along with a couple misses.
Nekov Casiopea - Galactic Funk
The Japanese really know how to have a good time on stage! Whether you know it or not, you took quite a risk with this submission. I've never listened to much on the funk side of things and that's because I don't typically like that style of music. In this case, another instrumental from you (3rd one in 5 rounds). As I've said with each one of those, I'm not usually crazy about instrumentals. This follows that trend, unfortunately. It does a few things that I enjoy. And it's pretty fun, particularly live. The solos are all pleasant enough. Still, the way they are arranged feels kind of formulaic and predictable. 6
kingshmegland The Fixx - Deeper and Deeper
Again, not a huge fan of this, although I enjoyed it a little more than Nekov's. It may have been pushing the envelope at its time, in terms of technology, but listening to it now it sounds a bit dated in my ears. And yes- it is quirky. But not in a way that I really enjoy. Some of the instrumental bits sound like they could have been taken straight out of an old arcade game. Not a terrible thing, but I don't really enjoy it that much... The chorus is probably my favorite part of the song, though repetitive. I might check out another one of their hits, since I imagine this could be very hit-or-miss, but you've missed on this one. 6.5
Scorpion Praying Mantis - Thirty Pieces of Silver
Right away, this sounds like another jjrock song. But it sounds like one of the better jjrock songs that have been submitted. Oh wait, this is someone else. Another step up from the lowest two songs, for a number of reasons. I'm more comfortable with this than the funk-leaning instrumental from Nekov and it's a lot more focused than The Fixx. There's nothing here that I would trim at just under 4 minutes. The vocalist is not awe-inspiring, but he doesn't really need to be. The guitar solo is pleasant, as well. Once again, not awe-inspiring. Just solid, from start to finish. 7
jingle.boy Jefferson Airplane - White Rabbit
I think the shortest song I've received in the entire roulette. And one that I've heard of before, at that. It's a psychedelic one too, and also not exactly what I would have expected from you given what I know about your music tastes. At the end of the day though, sending a short song is usually not going to be the best way to make up ground. Because the average ceiling for short songs tends to be pretty low imo, and to break through that ceiling I'm going to need something really extraordinary. Of course, short songs also tend to not score as low as a less-appealing long song. Anyways, I'm rambling. 7.5
LieLowTheWantedMan Gang of Four - Damaged Goods
As you mentioned, this is a really stripped back song. The raw texture of it reminds me a bit of Joy Division's Unknown Pleasures, but this particular song doesn't feel dark enough to be a song on that album. I noticed it's also labeled as 'Dance-punk', which seems fitting. My experimentation with post-punk has never been all that thorough, but I seem to find almost all of it fitting for dance. Especially The Cure's Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me. Obviously this is a lot more stark and even empty when compared to that synth-heavy album, but I couldn't help but make the comparison when I saw the sub-genre label. All of this is just to say that this song sounds familiar and reminds me of a lot of music that I enjoy quite a bit. I'll be checking out more, brotha. 8
jjrock88 W.A.S.P. - Wild Child
I think this is probably my favorite song that you've sent since Saxon in the first round. I've listened to Denim and Leather a few times since then, btw, and am quite thankful for the submission. As for this song... First of all- I think that this is a pretty stupid music video. But that's all part of the fun. I enjoy the singer quite a bit. The chorus is perfectly catchy and there's a palpable sense of energy that I can't escape. Not much else to say... Just a really solid song. 8
Elite Television - Marquee Moon
Another long one from you. It also happens to be another really good one. The vocalist has a sort of whiny/wailing quality to his voice that I really like. The repetitive little guitar lick might be a touch annoying at times, but that's a very minor complaint. You know the one I'm talking about, I expect. I also really enjoy the instrumental section that starts to take off around the 5 minute mark. The guitars are engaging but never overdone. The rhythm section does a really good job of keeping it all moving along, as well. And when the vocals finally reenter, with the song coming to a close, I feel completely satisfied. Not as strong as your submissions from the first two rounds, but better than the last couple. 8
TAC Shooting Star - Last Chance
Another really good one from you. More melodic, I guess AOR. But still a bit unique, particularly with the strings. They add a really nice touch to an otherwise strong song. I think the vocalist is kind of pedestrian, to be honest, just in the sense that he doesn't really stand out in the song. But that's more of a testament to the strong keyboard work, the economical guitar, and the rhythm section also being really strong. Also, quite the motivational tune. You've sold me on another band, thank you! 8
lonestar Pat Benatar - Hell is For Children
I've heard a few of her hits before, but this is a new one. What always struck me in those few select songs was the power of Benatar's voice. I get that here as well. Also enjoy the distinct dynamic shift between verses and the uber-catchy chorus. Then, of course, the larger shift at the 3 minute mark. All building up to a really effective climax with the guitar solo. Speaking of climax- she really is beautiful. I'll be exploring her more thoroughly when we wrap this roulette up. Thanks! 8.5
Dr. DTVT Queensryche - Take Hold of the Flame
Musically, I'm not sure I like this as much as most of the songs on Empire or O:M, but it's still a good one. So what elevates it above the other 9 songs from this round? Geoff Tate... :hefdaddy Yes, I understand that he's known to be an asshat, particularly in recent times, but I don't hold that against him. He really is a breathtaking vocalist. I'll pick up this album as soon as I get a chance. 8.5
Standings:
TAC 41.5
Elite 41
Dr. DTVT 39
Scorpion 38.5
jingle.boy 38.5
LieLowTheWantedMan 37.5
kingshmegland 37.5
lonestar 37.5
jjrock88 37
Nekov 36
Nekov and kingshmegland take the biggest drops, DTVT jumps up a little and the middle remains very close.
Something to consider in these final rounds... A little clue that might get you the inside track. I've been listening to a lot of Bob Dylan, Neil Young and early Tim Buckley recently. Obviously, if you don't have a lot of folk singer-songwriters at your disposal that's fine, but it certainly wouldn't hurt...
-
sent
-
Awesome choice of tune Lonestar!
-
Totally. Little known fact, that's the only song she has played at every single live performance ever.
And yes, she is soooooooooooooooo hot.
And sent.
-
Rat Farts.
Alright, I've got something up your sleeve then.
-
Up my sleeve? That should be interesting
-
Take Hold Of The Flame is great, but it's probably like my 5th favorite song on Warning. It is such a strong album.
Trying to find something folksy. This is going to be tough.
-
Take Hold is an awesome tune, what a performance by Geoff!!
-
Alright, I've got something up your sleeve then.
whoa, whoa, whoa! Get a room, you two. You can't be doing that out in public.
-
Alright, I've got something up your sleeve then.
whoa, whoa, whoa! Get a room, you two. You can't be doing that out in public.
Never. I'm all for public flogging.
-
And Sent!
-
Take Hold is an awesome tune, what a performance by Geoff!!
I would've personally gone with Roads To Madness. But Queensryche is on the list in the OP, with a couple albums in parentheses. I was actually thinking of sending a track by a band on the list that's not on the parenthetical album.
-
Dammit. I need to stop failing
-
I'm glad I won the round, even if you gave me a score that tied lonestar.
I don't have much in the Bob Dylan vein, matter of fact I had a one-two-three punch I was saving for the last rounds.
-
Sent!
-
Sent
-
I actually sent with the Dylan/Young theme in mind. Did everyone else?
-
I did but my 90's folk is much better
-
I don't have any folk! :lol
-
I do. Not a ton but I got to see some cool stuff in small clubs
-
I actually sent with the Dylan/Young theme in mind. Did everyone else?
Not a chance
-
I actually sent with the Dylan/Young theme in mind. Did everyone else?
No, but I have sunk the Dagger of Betrayal into another players back :xbones
-
Dagger of Betrayal
:lol
I think I'm more curious about this than about results.
-
Dagger of Betrayal
:lol
I think I'm more curious about this than about results.
Right between your 4th and 5th vertebrae. And yes, it was you RJ.
-
Hmmm, wondering if it's 80s Marillion or IQ, or if you went with one of the rock gods not on the list.. there are two I've yet to send.
One's definitely possible for you to send, the other would fucking shock me if anyone sent them.
Thanks for giving me something to think about on this otherwise lazy day of couch sitting, good looking out bro :tup
-
Marillion is on his banned list.
You had five rounds to send the band I sent. I already know what I'm sending the last two rounds, and I doubt anyone is going to scoop me on those bands.
-
Yeah Marillion wouldn't be allowed. IQ, I've only heard a couple more recent songs from (Road of Bones).
-
I need Elite!
-
Another week, another good round! I have a busy weekend, so I'm going to post these write-ups in a sloppy and rushed fashion.
LieLowTheWantedMan Exuma - Exuma, the Obeah Man
This just isn't my cup of tea, I'm sorry to say. I could go through all the thing that I dislike about the song, but that would essentially just boil down to 'everything'. Sorry man, this is not the kind of folk I was looking for. 6
Elite Supertramp - Fools Overture
Yes, Supertramp was on my banned artists list, but I'll take this song anyhow. Nice relaxing piano intro, but a little boring to be honest. Then the bells and what not come in and the song starts to really take off. But by that point I've already lost 3 and a half minutes of my life. Time I'm never going to get back, and I'm just not sure that intro was worth it. The song definitely picks up a bit once the vocals enter (halfway into the song), but that's not an easy intro to recover from. 6.5
kingshmegland Eagles - Seven Bridges Road
Explaining why I was disappointed with this song is very simple. Generally speaking, I'm not a big fan of vocal harmonies. Normally it's not enough to really turn me off from a band and rarely I actually really enjoy them, but this particular song doesn't fit into either of those categories. It all sounds a bit too a cappella for my taste (never have like a cappella, unfortunately). It is a bit more on the folk side of things, which I appreciated. But this isn't quite doing it for me :sad panda: 7
Nekov Pendragon - Insomnia
Pendragon is a band I've actually heard a bit from, but never from their earliest material. This ain't bad. Not at all. Good bang/buck ratio, without a doubt. Instrumentally, I can definitely get behind this. I'm not thrilled with the vocalist, but he's not bad either. Solid submission. 7.5
Dr. DTVT IQ - Widow's Peak
Dagger of betrayal, maybe, but lonestar still beat you out this round by a hair. Along with Pendragon, this is the second 'neo-prog' song/band this round. I like this one a bit more, but I can't exactly put my finger on why. There's just a bit more meat on this one. I especially love the bit from 4:40 onwards (was this album in 'inspiration corner' when DT wrote Octavarium?) Good stuff. 8
Scorpion Death - Leprosy
Going down a heavier route than everyone else this round, not for the first time either. I own and listen to Symbolic somewhat frequently, but I've never heard any of their other stuff. This particular song doesn't sound all that different from anything on that album, but I do feel like his growl-annunciation might have improved by the time they released Symbolic (I'm catching less lyrics in this one). The riffing is about what I would expect, which is quite good. I'm going to check out the full album now, thanks! 8
lonestar and jingle.boy Crosby Stills Nash - Carry On/Questions and Suite: Judy Blue Eyes
Both of you stepped up to the plate per my request for something a bit more folky this round, and both songs were great. I don't have a favorite between the two, but I also don't like them for the exact same reasons, which is nice. I'm going to check out a lot more from this iconic band. 8.5's
TAC Tesla - We're No Good Together
Another really good submission from you (I've probably said that every round). lonestar sent me a Tesla song in my last roulette and I didn't really enjoy it all that much (it was live version though, which in hindsight I don't think was as good as the original). jjrock also tried to submit that same song earlier in the roulette and I had to turn him down, but encouraged that he try something different from Tesla. He didn't, so I figured I'd probably not get another crack at them. I'm really thankful that you've given me that crack. I love how this song is essiantly just one large crescendo, with a really satisfying payoff to cap it all off. Really good stuff 8.5
jjrock88 Coney Hatch - First Time for Everything
Even now that I've let the songs sink in a bit more, I'm continually surprised that yours is my favorite. That's not meant to be a slight at you, I just really like this one :lol Love that innfectiously catchy chorus! In fact, I love everything about this song. 9
Standings:
TAC 50
Elite 47.5
Dr. DTVT 47
jingle.boy 47
Scorpion 46.5
lonestar 46
jjrock88 46
kingshmegland 44.5
LieLowTheWantedMan 43.5
Nekov 43.5
Only two rounds left now. Someone needs to take TAC down. All it takes is a couple mediocre songs from him and a couple great songs from one of you near the top and he'll be toppled.
-
Look at the old farts picking the same song. :lol
I'd say great minds....... but....... :lol
-
How the hell am I still in second place? :lol
-
Haha I knew it wasn't what you were looking for, I just wanted to try something weird. But fair enough. :lol
-
Coney Hatch is just a fantastic hard rock band. Underrated!
-
Seneca, what Tesla song were you given previously?
-
I had sent him Modern Day Cowboy
Sent for this round
-
I had sent him Modern Day Cowboy
That's an awesome song. The only reason I sent We're No Good Together was because Seneca mentioned Dylan/Young, and I thought that might fit.
Also, I was going to send Death too, but I thought they were on the banned band list.
-
Cool, enjoying diggin in all these oldies.
Sent...
-
Sent
-
Still deciding..
Someone needs to take TAC down.
Hey..that's not nice.
OK..sent!
-
Sent!
-
Thanks, I think that's everyone! I should have results up by either Friday or Saturday, and then on to the final round.
I have a lengthy list of bands to dive into once we wrap this up. Already been listening to a couple albums from the earlier rounds quite a bit. Feeling nostalgic for a time when I wasn't even alive. Or maybe I was...
-
I'm not going to let this go onto the second page. It's been a week since I posted the last set of results so here I am again. It was one of the most consistent rounds yet. I apologize in advance for the short write-ups.
Scorpion Blue Oyster Cult - “Then Came the Last Days of May”
Chills, straight from the beginning as the clean guitar sucks me right into the song. At first, I resented the fact that you sent me another Blue Oyster Cult song after RJ had already convinced me to check them out earlier in the roulette, but I never disallowed it and I really am thankful now. Because this is the better song. Really haunting, can’t wait to check out more! 9
Dr. DTVT Worlds- “The Fifth Wheel”
I’d never even heard of this band before, so I had no idea what to expect. Really good submission though; second best of the round, in fact. It’s really well-focused prog rock. 8.5
jingle.boy George Thorogood and the Destroyers - “One Bourbon One Scotch One Beer”
It’s story time! Each sentence punctuated with a nice, bluesy guitar lick. The story is pretty damn fun(ny). Could’ve very easily gone to hell if not for the well delivered narration though. I quite enjoy it when he eventually starts singing. But, not to get derailed, I shouldn’t get away from the real highlight of the song.The tasteful, economical guitar playing. Reminds me a bit of the Stevie Ray Vaughan track that I got earlier in the roulette, in that regard. Overall this song is a bit more interesting than that one, though. 8
kingshmegland Big Country - “Peace in Our Time”
Well you were right. This one could be described as a little bit progressive (not much though) and it definitely has some good melody and hooks. The essentially-one-line chorus is catchy and pleasant, even if it’s not super exciting. I’m going to give Big Country some more listens, would you recommend this particular album above the rest? 8
lonestar The Who - “Doctor Jimmy”
One of the longer songs of the round, at 8:40. My favorite parts of the song come at about the 3:30 and 6:30 minute marks, when the tempo slows down a bit. Not crazy about the chorus and the transitions into and out of it. Sounds a bit like a parade march at times, what with all the horns or trumpets. Not surprisingly, as is often the case when I listen to songs out of the context of their respective concept albums, I suspect I’d probably get more out of it if I heard the full album. But still, one of the better songs of the round. 8
LieLowTheWantedMan Talking Heads - "Crosseyed and Painless”
A little quirky here- why am I not surprised? Even still, it’s a bit more accessible than some of the other stuff you’ve sent me. And definitely a lot better than last round. Song really makes me want to dance. A trance-like dance, that is. Liking the vocals a lot. Some of the other effects are kind of wacky, but they don’t interrupt the flow of the song at all. 8
Nekov Sting - “Shadows in the Rain”
Not a big fan of Sting’s vocals here. It almost sounds like he’s intentionally mumbling. With that being said, the rest of the song more than makes up for that. The propulsive, slightly frantic drumming, the brass, the keyboard solo, it’s all great. 7.5
jjrock88 Icon - “Danger Calling”
Straight forward melodic hard rock, here. No big surprises, from you. But, similar to the Coney Hatch song from last round, this is one of my favorites from you this roulette. It’s only three and half minutes, which is about as long as I’d want it to be. Maybe a touch repetitive, but I don’t have a problem with that at all. Nice choice. 7.5
TAC Living Colour - “Cult of Personality”
This one is yours to lose, at this point. A really awesome song in this round would’ve all but locked it up. I’m not sure this one is really awesome or not. It’s got a really interesting mix of hard rock and I guess funk? The main riff is very repetitive, but I enjoy the way it pulses throughout the song. Guitar solo is the highlight- really enjoy that. 7.5
Elite Duncan Browne - “Wild Places”
So apparently this was somewhat of a hit in the Netherlands, huh? I don’t really enjoy the quieter parts of the song when he’s of whispering, but do enjoy the way those sections build into the chorus. Also really like the backing vocals. It all ebbs and flows really nicely, in a dreamy kind of way. It all changes a bit with the instrumental last minute and a half, which is interesting and not expected. Not sure whether or not it’s adding much to the song, though. Overall, this one has some really nice moments but also leaves a lot to be desired at times. 7
Standings:
TAC 57.5
Dr. DTVT 55.5
Scorpion 55.5
jingle.boy 55
Elite 54.5
lonestar 54
jjrock88 53.5
kingshmegland 52.5
LieLowTheWantedMan 51.5
Nekov 51
TAC's previous 3 and 3.5 leads over DTVT and Scorpion, respectively, has been cut to 2. jingle.boy and Elite also have a chance, albeit not as great, depending on how much TAC does or does note slip up.
I might give out a couple bonus points mid-week for songs/bands that have grown on me during the course of the roulette.
-
I was going to send that George Thorogood song earlier, but I decided to abandon the old rock when it wasn't working for me. Hopefully my previous songs are the ones earning points.
-
How the hell am I still in second place? :lol
I've yet to enjoy a song as much as your first submission in this roulette. And the second was also definitely top 5 overall, so far. You got off to a really strong start. You've certainly slipped, but it's been slow.
-
I'll send you s few songs from each album tomorrow!
-
Sent!
It wouldn't be a pre 90's roulette without me sending something from this artist. It was just tough deciding which song.
Hopefully I can stay within 2 points of Scorpion!
-
Fair assessment of that tune, and yes, Quadrophenia should be high on anyone's must listen list.
This is an interesting scenario here, winning this thing, though tricky, is not totally unfeasible. Think I'm gonna go ahead with the tune I selected, can't leave the roulette without sending this one. Sending later tonight.
-
Sent!
It wouldn't be a pre 90's roulette without me sending something from this artist. It was just tough deciding which song.
Hopefully I can stay within 2 points of Scorpion!
Iron Maiden?
Sent for last round
-
Sent
-
and Sent!
-
Sent!
It wouldn't be a pre 90's roulette without me sending something from this artist. It was just tough deciding which song.
Hopefully I can stay within 2 points of Scorpion!
Iron Maiden?
I think they were banned.
-
Yeah, no Maiden allowed.
And the song that he did settle on was also not allowed :-\
Whoops. no it was definitely allowed. I got lost somewhere along the way and thought that jjrock was responding to lonestar, whose song was rejected.
-
That's what you get hanging around so many Fogeys! It starts to rub off on you.
-
That's what you get hanging around so many Fogeys! It starts to rub off on you.
Giggity.
-
Kaboom
-
I have a couple different scores to bump up a little bit over the course of the week, but I'll start with this one.
jjrock88
Looking all the way back to the first round and Saxon's "Power and Glory", I think you deserved more points than I originally gave you. It's been one of my most-played songs throughout the roulette and it got me to buy Denim and Leather. I've listened to that album in full a handful of times now, with some of the tracks getting probably closer to 10 plays or so. I'm really enjoying it. Even though you're not likely to win the roulette at this point, I greatly appreciate this particular introduction. You've succeeded in making me feel nostalgic for a time in which I wasn't even alive :lol
and that's worth an extra point.
-
Saxon is a GREAT band. They have a huge discography and they as good now as they have ever been. Power And The Glory is a great place to start. D&L is a cool album too.
-
Saxon is a GREAT band. They have a huge discography and they as good now as they have ever been. Power And The Glory is a great place to start. D&L is a cool album too.
Very underrated. Work your way through their entire discography and you just may have a new favorite band lol
-
New thread title? Did someone send Helloween's Halloween? I actually almost sent that.
-
No, it has more to do with the line from "And the Bands Played On" off of Denim and Leather.
-
No, it has more to do with the line from "And the Bands Played On" off of Denim and Leather.
NICE!!!! :metal
That is a GREAT tune!!
-
It's my favorite from the album and has been stuck in my head off-and-on for the past couple weeks. Short and sweet, too :tup
-
It was the first Saxon song I ever heard. Hooked ever since.
-
No, it has more to do with the line from "And the Bands Played On" off of Denim and Leather.
Thats one of my favorites from the band...............check out "747 Strangers in the Night"
-
I quite enjoyed 747... Definitely looking forward to digging deeper. As I am with this band:
Blue Oyster Cult - "Veteran of the Psychic Wars"
As I mentioned in the most recent batch of write-ups, I think I prefer the song sent by Scorpion. Nonetheless, this one is also great and deserving of a slight bump from the score I originally gave it. Been listening to it quite a bit and I particularly enjoy the way it balances its haunting atmosphere and unusual lyrics.
Extra half a point for lonestar!
-
Sweet man, when this is done you need to watch the original Heavy Metal movie. That's where I first fell in love with that track. Many other great songs on it, and a disturbing amount of epic cartoon boobage to boot.
-
The last extra point is split between Dr. DTVT and Scorpion for their earlier Rainbow and Death songs, respectively. Both have grown on me and both warrant more investigation on my part.
Standings before Final Round:
TAC 57.5
Dr. DTVT 55.5+.5=56
Scorpion 55.5+.5=56
jingle.boy 55
jjrock88 53.5+1=54.5
Elite 54.5
lonestar 54+.5=54.5
kingshmegland 52.5
LieLowTheWantedMan 51.5
Nekov 51
Thanks to everyone for playing- I got a lot of great music and I can't wait to dig deeper! I should have the final results up by Saturday after giving this batch of songs a few more listens in the next couple of days.
-
As much as I hope I finished the comeback, my submission has hit and miss potential, and since it is an instrumental that risk is multiplied.
-
As much as I hope I finished the comeback, my submission has hit and miss potential, and since it is an instrumental that risk is multiplied.
Yeah I wouldn't get your hopes up if I were you :lol maybe
It takes a lot to really wow me with an instrumental
-
You meany. :lol
-
Seems my margin for error has been reduced by 25%. Can I have a bonus point? ;D
-
Seems my margin for error has been reduced by 25%. Can I have a bonus point? ;D
Since they were pretty much reserved for songs that didn't blow me away after only a handful of listens, most of yours didn't really qualify. You consistently sent me songs that were either the best, or very nearly the best, in their respective rounds. Not as much space for those ones to grow. ;D
I also thought about giving a little bit of a bonus for one of Nekov's earlier songs which has aged well on me, but I figured that wasn't really all that necessary. Big honorable mention for it though :lol
-
:metal
-
I also thought about giving a little bit of a bonus for one of Nekov's earlier songs which has aged well on me, but I figured that wasn't really all that necessary. Big honorable mention for it though :lol
:'(
-
Hah, sorry man. If it makes you feel better, your song might be an early favorite from this batch. Maybe ;)
-
Once again, I thank everyone for playing along with me! I was gifted a lot of great music over the course of the last 6 weeks or so. In that time, given all the old music, I feel like I've aged more than 6 weeks :smiley:
Elite, Queen - Innuendo
Obviously heard some Queen before, but this one is new for me. Freddie Mercury is pretty strong, as usual. Everything else fits in pretty well, musically. Highlight of the song for me comes about 3 minutes in, as I’m sure comes as no surprise to you. Love that little solo! The vocals that immediately follow it are a pretty good example of not-so-strong vocals though, imo. I’m talking about the uber-theatrical style. Just not my thing. And frankly, it spoils the rest of the song… 6.5
LieLow, Galaxie 500 - Decomposing Trees
One of the more relaxing songs of the round, and the whole roulette for that matter, and I can feel it only seconds in. The vocals are pretty nice, though not great, and I love the way the saxophone(?) mirrors it before taking a more predominant role in the last minute of the song. It’s all a pretty steady buildup. Not sure if the pay off is quite as strong as I was hoping for, but it builds nonetheless. 7
jingle.boy, Gowan - A Criminal Mind
It takes its time to get all the way through the intro and into the meat of the song. And by taking it’s time, I mean that it uses most of the song. The whole thing feels like a gigantic tease, to be honest. The buildup is slow and repetitive and I keep waiting for it to break into another level. Around the 6 minute mark I feel like it does fill out more and approach what seems to be a climax, but ultimately I’m left wanting more. Sorry
7
kingshmegland, GTR - Imagining
Sadly, you’re not going to win the roulette. It’s just too late and your submissions were a little inconsistent for me over the course of the last couple months. The ones that I did enjoy though were some of my favorites of all. This particular song is actually a pretty good example of what I’m talking about. Parts of the song- namely the intro, the instrumental work during the 5th minute of the song and the outro- are great. I can’t say that the rest of the song thrilled me though. Especially the vocals and its repetitive line(s). 7
Dr. DTVT, Tony MacAlpine - Tears of Sahara
Really interesting choice on your part, to go for an instrumental in this final round. With ground to make up, no less. And a short instrumental, it should be noted! Pretty ballsy, but unfortunately I don’t think it’s going to pay off for you. Don’t get me wrong, it’s actually quite good. I really like how focused and melodic it is. I really like how balanced the playing is between fast runs and the main lick. Unfortunately, liking it is not going to be enough. I needed to love it. 7.5
TAC, Alice Cooper - Pass the Gun Around
As was so often the case during this roulette, I entered this song with a few presumptions based on what I knew of the artist. So when I saw Alice Cooper I thought oh hey- shock rock. Which is something that has turned me off a bit from certain songs and artists in the past. Thankfully, and surprisingly, this wasn’t at all what I would have expected in such a song. Between the beautiful guitar solo and the heartfelt vocals I think you’ve sold me! Where do I go from here? 8
lonestar, Triumph - Headed for Nowhere
So as I mentioned before, I’m quite familiar with both Just a Game (awesome album) and the song Magic Power. According to my very quick research, this song and album came a little bit later. Unfortunately it sounds like they may be out of their prime. That’s not to say that this isn’t a good song, I’m just not sure whether I like it as much as the aforementioned Triumph songs that I’ve heard. Not sure what exactly it is about the song, but I’m not as wowed as I thought I might be. 8
jjrock88, Stryper - Soldiers Under Command
Another not-so-unpredictable song from you and another pretty good one. I really like the kind of drawn-out chorus, if that makes sense. Enjoy the guitar solo, even if it’s not blowing me away. The whole song feels very anthemic to me, which is nice and definitely cannot be said for the rest of the songs here. Which Stryper album would you suggest I check out first? 8
Scorpion, Fates Warning - Valley of Dolls
I don’t think I like this song quite as much as the one Mason submitted in one of the earlier rounds, but this is still a strong one. Once again, I’m enjoying the John Arch vocals and also definitely understanding why a lot of people might be put off by them. Everything else though, and I mean everything, is just right. Nothing in this 5:21 that I would even think about removing. Really strong submission, but will it be enough? 8.5
Nekov, Eloy - Silent Cries and Mighty Echoes
I realize it might not be worth all that much to you now, when you have no chance of winning the roulette, but this was an awesome song! A bit lengthy, relative to the rest of the submissions, but definitely worth it. The intro sets the tone just right. Absolutely love the atmosphere of those first couple minutes. Reminds me a lot of Pink Floyd, as I’m sure you’re aware of. Seriously, I can hear it in just about all aspects of the song. But that’s A-okay. Really beautiful song from a band that I’ve never heard about! 9
Final Standings:
TAC 57.5+8=65.5
Scorpion 56+8.5=64.5
Dr. DTVT 56+7.5=63.5
jjrock88 54.5+8=62.5
lonestar 54.5+8=62.5
jingle.boy 55+7=62
Elite 54.5+6.5=61
Nekov 51+9=60
kingshmegland 52.5+7=59.5
LieLowTheWantedMan 51.5+7=58.5
-
Congrats TAC! Since Irons were banned I kinda expected you to send Alice Cooper and you didn't disappoint. :rollin
I enjoyed following this. Good pace overall too. :tup
-
I avoided last place :metal
Glad you liked the song. Silent Cries and Mighty Echoes is actually the name of the album that song is from ;)
This was fun and it ended just in time for me to go on vacations. Thanks for running this in a timely and fun way
-
Congrats Tim!!! :metal
-
So close! Oh well, still happy that you liked my submissions overall.
Congrats TAC, good game.
-
Congrats to teh winnah!!!!
And a quality and fun roulette, was fun digging into all the oldies, and I never did send any of The Kinks. Oh well :dunno:
-
A loser is me. :sadpanda:
-
Congrats TAC
And great job running this!!!
For Stryper check out No More Hell to Pay or To Hell with the Devil
-
Awesome :metal :metal :metal
I'll get back once we get settled here in Florida.
There's tons of places to go with Alice Cooper.
As good as Pass The Gun Around is, that's one if the last albums I'd recommend.