DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: Ħ on March 21, 2012, 01:20:34 AM
-
Bandmember interviewed: John Petrucci
Interviewer: www.spaziorock.it (https://www.spaziorock.it)
Date: March 5, 2012Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Be8rHhOO2wc&feature=related (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Be8rHhOO2wc&feature=related)
Basically talking about wrapping up touring, looking at fan reactions to help them write setlists, and Mangini writing on the next album.
-
Well, I'd be surprised if he'd stated the opposite... ;)
-
Mike also told me last weekend that he would be/already has been involved. Good news! :metal
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
-
That makes me happy, and guys, he had actually stated the opposite a few months ago. This makes me very happy.
-
That's a funny video the way JP has to look up at whoever is asking the Q's and the way it is edited, it sounds like she keeps butting in. :biggrin:
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
I can almost guarantee you that the majority of the fans thinks otherwise.
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
Very smart move! :tup :tup
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
:|
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
i don't know about that, but it's a shitload better than Outcry. If they ditched Outcry for LNF, then it would have been a great move.
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
No.
i don't know about that, but it's a shitload better than Outcry. If they ditched Outcry for LNF, then it would have been a great move.
Maybe so. Though I'm personally glad I got to see Outcry live - it was a pretty cool song for the live setting.
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
I can almost guarantee you that the majority of the fans thinks otherwise.
That's okay. I can guarantee you that a lot of people think Obama's birth certificate was forged.
-
Nowhere near the majority.
-
Can't understand why Outcry is gaining negative reactions. It's the best song on the album and great to see live, IMO. Its vocal melodies and arrangement remind me Metropolis.
That's very cool to know DT do care fans thoughts.
-
Can't understand why Outcry is gaining negative reactions. It's the best song on the album and great to see live, IMO.
^That. ...although lately I've been feeling that Bridges In The Sky might actually be the "best," with Outcry being a very close second. But close enough...
That's very cool to know DT do care fans thoughts.
In all seriousness, that.^
-
So can't wait for the second U.S leg.
-
I'm really glad I got to see The Great Debate rather than Outcry when I saw them in Chicago. I've wanted to see The Great Debate for years.
-
Better song aside, they basically made the setlist a LOT more sterile by taking 15 minutes worth of show and making it the same song every night as opposed to rotating, and in the process they completely removed a song. I specifically love going to multiple DT shows because they vary up the sets, and I was REALLY looking forward to The Great Debate. So instead of seeing all three songs I ended up seeing two songs twice, lame.
-
TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
(https://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa383/TisBOOLsheet/gif/o9jlj.gif)
-
So can't wait for the second U.S leg.
There are going to be more US shows on this tour?
-
So can't wait for the second U.S leg.
There are going to be more US shows on this tour?
They've been doing at least two US tours during an album cycle since the Images and Words days with few exceptions.
-
So can't wait for the second U.S leg.
There are going to be more US shows on this tour?
They've been doing two US tours during an album cycle for a long time now
They already have a festival date in August in Quebec, so I don't see a reason not to come through a second time. Especially since they've coming through for a second leg for the past several tours, at least.
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
NO!
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
I can almost guarantee you that the majority of the fans thinks otherwise.
That's okay. I can guarantee you that a lot of people think Obama's birth certificate was forged.
Bosk1, I guess you and Obama share the same distaste for BAI:
(https://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w265/llamabearduck/DTBURN1.jpg)
-
:clap: :lol
-
That is amazing.
-
:rollin
-
It reminds me of the Kramer poster from Seinfield. :lol
-
Well, I'd be surprised if he'd stated the opposite... ;)
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
I can almost guarantee you that the majority of the fans thinks otherwise.
That's okay. I can guarantee you that a lot of people think Obama's birth certificate was forged.
I see what you did there.
For what's it's worth, I'd much rather see The Great Debate than Breaking All Illusions myself. But I'd rather see Breaking All Illusions than Lost Not Forgotten.
-
i saw them at wembley, and they played, outcry and BAI
-
If I had to choose between Lost Not Forgotten and The Great Debate, I'd choose Breaking all Illusions. ;)
Now I just need to go to my first DT concert (it's taking too long!)
-
That is amazing.
2nd that!
-
If I had to choose between Lost Not Forgotten and The Great Debate, I'd choose Breaking all Illusions. ;)
Now I just need to go to my first DT concert (it's taking too long!)
Well if they actually do come back to the US (assuming you live in the US), you should see this show ASAP.
-
I had to choose, I wouldn't care because I've never seen DT live before. :loser:
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
Agreed, TGD is around top 10 for me, while BAI isn't even top 30.
-
I do love the great debate but maybe I'm just old school. One of the coolest buildups in the dt catologue in that there tune.
-
The Great Debate probably in my top 3 favorite songs, so i was quite glad that I got to see it in Vancouver. Now all I need is Hell's Kitchen. :heart
-
TGD has awesome moments but it's so long that I'd rather see two or three other songs in it's place.
-
If I had to choose between Lost Not Forgotten and The Great Debate, I'd choose Breaking all Illusions. ;)
Now I just need to go to my first DT concert (it's taking too long!)
Well if they actually do come back to the US (assuming you live in the US), you should see this show ASAP.
Well I live in Canada, I guess that counts as another US tour. :P It wouldn't matter which setlist, but I hope they keep The Root of All Evil/The Dark Eternal Night in the setlist. I imagine they would, since it wasn't in the previous NA setlist.
-
So he confirms that TGD was taken out so they could play both Outcry and BAI from the fans complaining..Cool!
That's weak. TGD is a MUCH better song than BAI.
............................................________
....................................,.-'"...................``~.,
.............................,.-"..................................."-.,
.........................,/...............................................":,
.....................,?......................................................,
.................../...........................................................,}
................./......................................................,:`^`..}
.............../...................................................,:"........./
..............?.....__.........................................:`.........../
............./__.(....."~-,_..............................,:`........../
.........../(_...."~,_........"~,_....................,:`........_/
..........{.._$;_......"=,_......."-,_.......,.-~-,},.~";/....}
...........((.....*~_......."=-._......";,,./`..../"............../
...,,,___.`~,......"~.,....................`.....}............../
............(....`=-,,.......`........................(......;_,,-"
............/.`~,......`-...................................../
.............`~.*-,.....................................|,./.....,__
,,_..........}.>-._...................................|..............`=~-,
.....`=~-,__......`,.................................
...................`=~-,,.,...............................
................................`:,,...........................`..............__
.....................................`=-,...................,%`>--==``
........................................_..........._,-%.......`
...................................,
:p
-
:bosk1:
-
As much as I'd love to see DT again this year in the states, I'm already ready for a new album
-
Dude, grow an attention span.
-
Lol. You're not going to get a new album for at least another year. In the meantime, enjoy the tour and the upcoming (I hope) DVD.
-
At the earliest, I could maybe see DT going into the studio in January or February only because of how much attention is on them right now and the fact that they have reportedly been jamming and creating with Mangini. They might just want to run with the momentum they've got going.
-
^ And they don't take a year to write one song like TOOL.
-
At the earliest, I could maybe see DT going into the studio in January or February only because of how much attention is on them right now and the fact that they have reportedly been jamming and creating with Mangini. They might just want to run with the momentum they've got going.
They have usually released one album every two years, even in the years when they had less attention. Therefore, we can pretty much expect another record by the end of 2013. In order to achieve this, they would need to get some serious writing going by January. This wouldn't be anything extraordinary, they operated like this for the past ten years (except for Train of Thought, when they were even faster).
Assuming they want to push it because of the attention surrounding the Grammy nomination and how the fans love Mangini, they could enter the studio as early as late 2012 and have a record in stores by mid 2013. This would be faster than normal, but still within the boundaries of what they've done before.
-
That makes me happy, and guys, he had actually stated the opposite a few months ago. This makes me very happy.
What, he said that Mangini would not be involved in writing the next album? Source?
-
At the earliest, I could maybe see DT going into the studio in January or February only because of how much attention is on them right now and the fact that they have reportedly been jamming and creating with Mangini. They might just want to run with the momentum they've got going.
They have usually released one album every two years, even in the years when they had less attention. Therefore, we can pretty much expect another record by the end of 2013. In order to achieve this, they would need to get some serious writing going by January. This wouldn't be anything extraordinary, they operated like this for the past ten years (except for Train of Thought, when they were even faster).
Assuming they want to push it because of the attention surrounding the Grammy nomination and how the fans love Mangini, they could enter the studio as early as late 2012 and have a record in stores by mid 2013. This would be faster than normal, but still within the boundaries of what they've done before.
As I recall, they said they tentatively planned to start writing around the end of this year, which would be almost exactly 2 years after they started writing ADTOE, so the timeline fits. Given that they do not have the same issues with auditions, breaking in a new member, etc., if they do, it would put them on pace for a summer release if they followed their typical pattern. I would guess mid-summer to early fall next year unless something changes from what they previously said.
That makes me happy, and guys, he had actually stated the opposite a few months ago. This makes me very happy.
What, he said that Mangini would not be involved in writing the next album? Source?
Not exactly. As I recall, it was just a passing comment where JP gave a long detailed description of the writing process this time around, and at the end of that discussion, mentioned that Mangini was not primarily involved while they were doing the initial writing, and then he made the passing comment of, "we'll probably follow a similar pattern next time around." I don't think he was necessarily saying one way or the other whether Mangini would be involved in the writing, but more just making the general comment that they will generally follow the same writing formula as last time. But who knows, really? They'll do what they all think is best when the time comes.
-
Ah, that makes more sense.
-
I'll take Breaking All Illusions over The Great Debate any day of the week.
-
The Great Debate is one of my favorite songs but I'd rather see Breaking All Illusions played.
-
I've never understood why people care so much about who is involved in the writing process. Some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with only one writer, and some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with lots of writers. I really don't care who writes as long as no one is involved that sucks at writing.
-
I've never understood why people care so much about who is involved in the writing process. Some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with only one writer, and some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with lots of writers. I really don't care who writes as long as no one is involved that sucks at writing.
Because a lot of people want to hear new interesting drum parts in DT?
-
Are you implying that ADTOE didn't have any interesting drum parts?
-
Are you implying that ADTOE didn't have any interesting drum parts?
lol...no. Although, I know MM is capable of a LOT more than DT allowed him on this past record. I'm still satisfied by the drums. I'm simply saying that people want to hear what comes out of MM when HE comes up with the first part of a song.
-
Are you implying that ADTOE didn't have any interesting drum parts?
lol...no. Although, I know MM is capable of a LOT more than DT allowed him on this past record. I'm still satisfied by the drums. I'm simply saying that people want to hear what comes out of MM when HE comes up with the first part of a song.
I don't I costantly hear this "capable of a lot more" stuff. He has repeatedly said that some of the stuff he's doing on this album is incredibly difficult even on OTBOA. It's way harder to play that kind of stuff than it is to play straight timing at blistering speed.
The guy's drumming is far more intricate than what we've had on previous DT albums as it is. It's a different style. Maybe we'll get some additional simultanious multi time signature stuff, but i think if you're expecting more you'll be disappointed. There is a limit to what somone can do. What we had before in DT was admittedly louder but not as difficult. Not saying MP's stuff was bad by any means, he was great. I own all of his drumming vids so obviously I was impressed. Just now not nearly as much as with MM. So how about somebody tells me what more should be expected of him. Maybe some high speed double pedal in a balad? I'd rather have the guy play within the music like he does now. I appreciate the humility, yet his talent speak loud enough. I mean the guy's doing insane... yet tasty stuff now.
-
I've never understood why people care so much about who is involved in the writing process. Some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with only one writer, and some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with lots of writers. I really don't care who writes as long as no one is involved that sucks at writing.
For me personally, I really want to hear MM in the writing process because I think the writing dynamic of ADTOE really needs that something more, and I'm hoping MM inspires them to break out of the mold a bit.
-
That's pretty much how I feel. I always like to hear what kind of music can come out of different collaborations. Having him involved from the start will be different from having him come on board with the music basically finished and just waiting for him to add his parts. Mangini's contributions will not necessarily make everything suddenly amazing, but it's possible that there will be something different and hard to pinpoint about the new album, and it will be his hand in it, the same way MP had a hand in how things sounded that was more than just his writing and playing.
-
I've never understood why people care so much about who is involved in the writing process. Some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with only one writer, and some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with lots of writers. I really don't care who writes as long as no one is involved that sucks at writing.
For me personally, I really want to hear MM in the writing process because I think the writing dynamic of ADTOE really needs that something more, and I'm hoping MM inspires them to break out of the mold a bit.
I hate to break it to you, but that's not going to happen. DT is an established brand now, with somewhat of a formula (which is sorta weird for a "progressive' band). MM's style is also one that fits perfectly with what they do. If they were going for someone who was going to break the mold, then they would have picked Virgil or Marco.
-
I've never understood why people care so much about who is involved in the writing process. Some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with only one writer, and some of the best music I've ever heard was by bands with lots of writers. I really don't care who writes as long as no one is involved that sucks at writing.
For me personally, I really want to hear MM in the writing process because I think the writing dynamic of ADTOE really needs that something more, and I'm hoping MM inspires them to break out of the mold a bit.
I hate to break it to you, but that's not going to happen. DT is an established brand now, with somewhat of a formula (which is sorta weird for a "progressive' band). MM's style is also one that fits perfectly with what they do. If they were going for someone who was going to break the mold, then they would have picked Virgil or Marco.
And I don't expect him to completely shake things up, or perhaps even want that. I just mean add his own "character" to the songwriting dynamic, and be involved in writing beats/rhythms from day 1, instead of coming in after the songs were already written.
Even just that much could add a lot of inspiration to vary the songwriting a bit, using an MM beat as the basis of a section of a song. We'll see. He may not have much influence at all, or maybe we'll notice something a little different. Either way, it's something I'm excited and interested to hear.
-
Are you implying that ADTOE didn't have any interesting drum parts?
lol...no. Although, I know MM is capable of a LOT more than DT allowed him on this past record. I'm still satisfied by the drums. I'm simply saying that people want to hear what comes out of MM when HE comes up with the first part of a song.
I don't I costantly hear this "capable of a lot more" stuff. He has repeatedly said that some of the stuff he's doing on this album is incredibly difficult even on OTBOA. It's way harder to play that kind of stuff than it is to play straight timing at blistering speed.
The guy's drumming is far more intricate than what we've had on previous DT albums as it is. It's a different style. Maybe we'll get some additional simultanious multi time signature stuff, but i think if you're expecting more you'll be disappointed. There is a limit to what somone can do. What we had before in DT was admittedly louder but not as difficult. Not saying MP's stuff was bad by any means, he was great. I own all of his drumming vids so obviously I was impressed. Just now not nearly as much as with MM. So how about somebody tells me what more should be expected of him. Maybe some high speed double pedal in a balad? I'd rather have the guy play within the music like he does now. I appreciate the humility, yet his talent speak loud enough. I mean the guy's doing insane... yet tasty stuff now.
When did MM ever say that it's incredibly difficult? If anything, I remember a couple interviews in which he was asked which songs were the most difficult and either he replied This is the Life or he said none of them were really hard for him. Aside from the one handed single stroke technique he uses, I don't think any of the parts are really that difficult for an intermediate drummer. That is different from well-thought-out. Some of the parts, which I presume he spiced up, are very melodic.
I said from the beginning that I noticed the drumming on the new album was already more intricate than previous DT albums, and more difficult to play (even though I'm not a drummer).
I simply stated that MM is able to play a LOT more stuff than what was on the album. If you have watched videos of him (not in DT) and payed attention to his solo, it's pretty clear. I'm satisfied with the drum parts on the album, I'm just saying that I've observed he's capable of far more. Outcry is probably the most difficult because of the set up involved, but other than that I don't think any of the songs ventures away from intermediate metal drumming skill, technically (aside from the thing I mentioned earlier). That makes sense since MM is a rock and metal drummer, but he's not just any...he's a classically trained one with amazing technique.
I don't expect the drum parts to change that much in the future, Im just sayin'...
-
No actually MM said Outcry was a bitch to play in interviews.
-
(https://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w265/llamabearduck/DTBURN1.jpg)
Why is a well-tanned Abe Vigoda burning the Constitution? ???
-
It's definitely going to be interesting to hear how Mangini's drum parts change when he is the one primarily writing them, but at the end of the day... They're drums. :lol I don't think Mangini's involvement is actually going to affect the music that much.
-
It's time for me to input my.... input. I suppose.
He's a fucking genie. How could DT12 not be awesome :heart
-
OK so I'm full of crap. I take back everything I said about there being limits to what someone can do after seeing this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAuJp7ikZzk Problem is I don't know how the other guys can holdup to this. If they can however....... :biggrin:
PS must see in HD
-
OK so I'm full of crap. I take back everything I said about there being limits to what someone can do after seeing this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAuJp7ikZzk Problem is I don't know how the other guys can holdup to this. If they can however....... :biggrin:
PS must see in HD
:hefdaddy
-
My man reason for wanting MM involved from the get-go is that I don't think the majority of the rhythms on ADTOE are as interesting as MP would come up with, and that is JP's fault.
-
And I don't expect him to completely shake things up, or perhaps even want that. I just mean add his own "character" to the songwriting dynamic, and be involved in writing beats/rhythms from day 1, instead of coming in after the songs were already written.
Even just that much could add a lot of inspiration to vary the songwriting a bit, using an MM beat as the basis of a section of a song. We'll see. He may not have much influence at all, or maybe we'll notice something a little different. Either way, it's something I'm excited and interested to hear.
Everyone keeps talking about what MM will add to the drums/rhythm like that is the only thing he will contribute to the song writing. I think people forget that MM is well versed in all manners of music composition and theory and from some of the interviews he has given it is very likely that he will also be adding to the songs in ways that go far beyond the "rhythm/drums". I don't recall him ever talking about writing lyrics, but he has talked about writing melodies, harmonies, and riffs.
This is why I am excited to hear what MM brings to the music. Because it will add another voice to the JP/JR (sometimes JMX) team that has written all of the musical elements to their music since SDOIT. This is something that MP usually didn't do and will be the most unique thing that adding another dedicated and knowledgeable musician to the group, as opposed to just adding (or replacing) a talented and virtuoso drummer.
-
My man reason for wanting MM involved from the get-go is that I don't think the majority of the rhythms on ADTOE are as interesting as MP would come up with, and that is JP's fault.
I think Lost Not Forgotten has a lot of cool rhythms that are interesting.
-
I am not a drummer, so my knowledge on interesting rhythms extends to what "sounds" cool and different, and odd times.
Looking at scores and listening; I thought ADTOE has a lot of odd times compared to past stuff, and especially the MP metal albums.
I was shocked seeing how OTBOA was noted for time. i took it as PMU-esque as a standard time wrong, minus the obvious post chorus and outro riff.